UPDATING LECH L’CHA for TODAY
Lech L’CHA (“for you”) is worded as a private and subjective command to every Jew in each generation to make Aliya. In fact, such a multi-faceted and all-encompassing move is inevitably going to be unique for every person in his time period, but it’s important to identify & summarize the differences in what is our “Lech L’cha, what has changed in our era, in order not to be locked-in to previous misconceptions.
Rav Yisrael Yehoshua (Trunk) of Kutno, one of the leading poskim in his famous Responsa (Yeshu’ot Malko YD 66, wrote a classic update to this question in 1891/תרנ”א, which is obviously also in need of a modern revision.
1. He wrote already 135 years ago that the excuse of not making Aliya because of DANGER no longer applies. This was WAY BEFORE the Jewish army and IDF became the most formidable military force in the Middle East (see details of our decimating of Iran BH, considered the strongest Arab army). Of course there’s still some danger, but already then, it wasn’t considered enough to exempt from Aliyah.
2. He writes that similarly the excuse of ECONOMIC hardships already no longer applies (more than a century ago!). How much more so when just this week, the OECD projected Israel’s economy as the foreseen WORLD LEADER in economic growth. The US News ranked Israel this year as the 10^th^ “most powerful” (economically & militarily) country in the world (not bad, out of 193!), and surely the strongest “pound for pound”. For those who may still think of using this excuse, see my article translated to English from the Torah journal Tchumin, to check if you are intellectually honest regarding your observance:
part 1: https://www.yeshiva.co/midrash/20192
part 2: https://www.yeshiva.co/midrash/20193
part 3: https://www.yeshiva.co/midrash/20194
3. He concedes that the real mitzva would be to settle the Land if it were to be under Jewish, not Turkish, rule, as the mitzva is “והורשתם את הארץ וישבתם בה”, “inherit/rule the Land and settle her” (Bam. 33, 53). Here too, the STATE of Israel founded more than 75 years ago, has halachically changed and completed the cited void.
4. R. Trunk celebrates in 1891/תרנ”א that there are already 20,000 Jews in Eretz Yisrael (based on Yevamot 64 that the Shchina rests upon 22,000 Jews), including even secular Jews who have returned (exact opposite of the Satmar Rov, who feels that Zionism can’t be part of the Ge’ula process if secular are involved!), which proves that this is G-dly and the historic movement of “Atchalta d’GE’ULA”. How much more so today when not 10 times, not 100 times, but more than 300 times that many, comprising MOST of the Jewish people in the world, have come home. Rav Zvi Yehuda Kook replied almost 60 years ago after the Six Day War, “Some talk about Atchalta D’Geula, but one who opens his eyes will see we are already in the middle of the Ge’ula process, no longer in the beginning or hallway (“פרוזדור”), but we’re already into the main hall (“טרקלין”)!”. What would he say today, if he were to see the additional 60 years of spiritual and economic development.
5. The Yeshu’ot Malko obviously didn’t yet see that Israel today is the TORAH CENTER of the world Jewry, home of the most yeshivot, poskim and Batei Din. From all sects throughout the world, when one wants to learn high-level Torah, they come to Israel. As Prof. Ch.H. Ben-Sasson described, the world’s Torah Center began in Israel, then moved eastward to Bavel, then westward to Kirwan (Morrocco Geonim) and to Ashkenaz, then began returning eastward to Spain, Lithuania, and from now on has returned to Israel, its final destination.
6. The only place our Avodat Hashem is b’SIMCHA is Eretz Yisrael (Zohar Bamidbar 118a), where we feel at home and have the home-court advantage. No embarrassment to walk with a kipa, tzitzit or lulav, for here it’s the norm. No need to worry about anti-Semitism rearing her ugly head (in present or future), for here, we are the majority. Accordingly, here we say Birkat Kohanim every day, not just on Yom Tov (see Darkei Moshe Or.Ch. 128, 21 and Netziv Res. Meishiv Davar ii, 104).
7. The famed rabbi of Jerusalem’s Sha’arei Chessed neighborhood, Rav Ya’akov Moshe Charlap zt’l (close student of Rav Kook), wrote (Mimaynei HaY’shua p. 196) that the gentiles are messengers of G-d to help us identify “The Mitzva” of each generation. In particular periods, they prohibited learning Torah or Brit Mila, Mikveh or Kiddush HaChodesh, raising those mitzvot in each respective generation to “yehareg v’al ya’avor” (that we must even give our lives to fulfill, Sanhedrin 74a; Rambam Y’sodei HaTorah 5, 3; Shulchan Aruch YD 157, 1), forcing us to strengthen that particular mitzva. Current international anti-Israel protests “from the river to the sea”, are precisely G-d-sent to focus world Jewry upon Israel as the top priority of our generation. “In the advent of (this, our) messianic age, the central point is Eretz Yisrael”. Accordingly, it’s no surprise that in today’s age of world-wide religious freedom, Jews can observe Shabbat and lay tefillin even in Russia or Iran. The ONLY mitzva which any nation wishes to deny us is the Moslem “Jihad” (Holy War”) and universal anti-Israel pressures against the return of the nation of Israel to Eretz Yisrael. Tefilin doesn’t bother them but the Israeli flag does, focusing for us that Aliya is “THE MITZVA” of our times. Our Father wants us Home!
All I can add is to admire all of you who already had the guts to move your family-tree to its final destination, doing this binary spiritual upgrade by making Aliya, or those who are SINCERELY actually planning to be part of this great historic and spiritual process. Many of you have already personally passed the Lech L’cha test of Avraham Avinu answering in the affirmative, and deserve to be associated as continuing in the path of our fore-father in that SINGLE TEST which remains for us to this very day. For those who have yet to do so, it’s not too late! Lech L’cha!
Shabbat Shalom, Rav Ari Shvat (Chwat)