Yefat Toar and the Modern Soldier

Written by

in

How does the Torah’s law of the ‘beautiful captive’ explain itself morally, and would anything like it apply to soldiers today?

Q. How can we explain the ashes yefas toar and do the same laws apply to the soldier’s of the IDF?

When mankind was primitive, unfortunately raping the enemy’s women was part of war, as it was still in our generation where Russian soldiers raped hundreds of thousands of German women, and 3.7% of German children born in those years had been results of these atrocities. Fairly recently it was still systematic and legal in the Bosnian war and to a certain extent even done by American soldiers in Vietnam. In order to prevent and minimize this disgusting phenomena, the Torah, already 3,000 years ahead if its time, prevented even primitive Jews from being like 99.9% of mankind at the time, and set several difficult conditions in order to minimize this. Remember, the eternal Torah had to be relevant 3,000 years ago, as well as 3,000 years from now. Today, obviously it’s against the law in just about every army, and how much more so, in the Israeli army, where even taking the smallest of spoils is grounds for court-martialing.

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *