Category: Weekly Letters

  • UPDATING LECH L’CHA for TODAY- parshat Lech L’cha

    UPDATING LECH L’CHA for TODAY

    Lech L’CHA (“for you”) is worded as a private and subjective command to every Jew in each generation to make Aliya. In fact, such a multi-faceted and all-encompassing move is inevitably going to be unique for every person in his time period, but it’s important to identify & summarize the differences in what is our “Lech L’cha, what has changed in our era, in order not to be locked-in to previous misconceptions.

    Rav Yisrael Yehoshua (Trunk) of Kutno, one of the leading poskim in his famous Responsa (Yeshu’ot Malko YD 66, wrote a classic update to this question in 1891/תרנ”א, which is obviously also in need of a modern revision.

    1. He wrote already 135 years ago that the excuse of not making Aliya because of DANGER no longer applies. This was WAY BEFORE the Jewish army and IDF became the most formidable military force in the Middle East (see details of our decimating of Iran BH, considered the strongest Arab army). Of course there’s still some danger, but already then, it wasn’t considered enough to exempt from Aliyah.

    2. He writes that similarly the excuse of ECONOMIC hardships already no longer applies (more than a century ago!). How much more so when just this week, the OECD projected Israel’s economy as the foreseen WORLD LEADER in economic growth. The US News ranked Israel this year as the 10^th^ “most powerful” (economically & militarily) country in the world (not bad, out of 193!), and surely the strongest “pound for pound”. For those who may still think of using this excuse, see my article translated to English from the Torah journal Tchumin, to check if you are intellectually honest regarding your observance:

    part 1: https://www.yeshiva.co/midrash/20192

    part 2: https://www.yeshiva.co/midrash/20193

    part 3: https://www.yeshiva.co/midrash/20194

    3. He concedes that the real mitzva would be to settle the Land if it were to be under Jewish, not Turkish, rule, as the mitzva is “והורשתם את הארץ וישבתם בה”, “inherit/rule the Land and settle her” (Bam. 33, 53). Here too, the STATE of Israel founded more than 75 years ago, has halachically changed and completed the cited void.

    4. R. Trunk celebrates in 1891/תרנ”א that there are already 20,000 Jews in Eretz Yisrael (based on Yevamot 64 that the Shchina rests upon 22,000 Jews), including even secular Jews who have returned (exact opposite of the Satmar Rov, who feels that Zionism can’t be part of the Ge’ula process if secular are involved!), which proves that this is G-dly and the historic movement of “Atchalta d’GE’ULA”. How much more so today when not 10 times, not 100 times, but more than 300 times that many, comprising MOST of the Jewish people in the world, have come home. Rav Zvi Yehuda Kook replied almost 60 years ago after the Six Day War, “Some talk about Atchalta D’Geula, but one who opens his eyes will see we are already in the middle of the Ge’ula process, no longer in the beginning or hallway (“פרוזדור”), but we’re already into the main hall (“טרקלין”)!”. What would he say today, if he were to see the additional 60 years of spiritual and economic development.

    5. The Yeshu’ot Malko obviously didn’t yet see that Israel today is the TORAH CENTER of the world Jewry, home of the most yeshivot, poskim and Batei Din. From all sects throughout the world, when one wants to learn high-level Torah, they come to Israel. As Prof. Ch.H. Ben-Sasson described, the world’s Torah Center began in Israel, then moved eastward to Bavel, then westward to Kirwan (Morrocco Geonim) and to Ashkenaz, then began returning eastward to Spain, Lithuania, and from now on has returned to Israel, its final destination.

    6. The only place our Avodat Hashem is b’SIMCHA is Eretz Yisrael (Zohar Bamidbar 118a), where we feel at home and have the home-court advantage. No embarrassment to walk with a kipa, tzitzit or lulav, for here it’s the norm. No need to worry about anti-Semitism rearing her ugly head (in present or future), for here, we are the majority. Accordingly, here we say Birkat Kohanim every day, not just on Yom Tov (see Darkei Moshe Or.Ch. 128, 21 and Netziv Res. Meishiv Davar ii, 104).

    7. The famed rabbi of Jerusalem’s Sha’arei Chessed neighborhood, Rav Ya’akov Moshe Charlap zt’l (close student of Rav Kook), wrote (Mimaynei HaY’shua p. 196) that the gentiles are messengers of G-d to help us identify “The Mitzva” of each generation. In particular periods, they prohibited learning Torah or Brit Mila, Mikveh or Kiddush HaChodesh, raising those mitzvot in each respective generation to “yehareg v’al ya’avor” (that we must even give our lives to fulfill, Sanhedrin 74a; Rambam Y’sodei HaTorah 5, 3; Shulchan Aruch YD 157, 1), forcing us to strengthen that particular mitzva. Current international anti-Israel protests “from the river to the sea”, are precisely G-d-sent to focus world Jewry upon Israel as the top priority of our generation. “In the advent of (this, our) messianic age, the central point is Eretz Yisrael”. Accordingly, it’s no surprise that in today’s age of world-wide religious freedom, Jews can observe Shabbat and lay tefillin even in Russia or Iran. The ONLY mitzva which any nation wishes to deny us is the Moslem “Jihad” (Holy War”) and universal anti-Israel pressures against the return of the nation of Israel to Eretz Yisrael. Tefilin doesn’t bother them but the Israeli flag does, focusing for us that Aliya is “THE MITZVA” of our times. Our Father wants us Home!

    All I can add is to admire all of you who already had the guts to move your family-tree to its final destination, doing this binary spiritual upgrade by making Aliya, or those who are SINCERELY actually planning to be part of this great historic and spiritual process. Many of you have already personally passed the Lech L’cha test of Avraham Avinu answering in the affirmative, and deserve to be associated as continuing in the path of our fore-father in that SINGLE TEST which remains for us to this very day. For those who have yet to do so, it’s not too late! Lech L’cha!

    Shabbat Shalom, Rav Ari Shvat (Chwat)

  • ALIYA and LEAVING the “DERECH”?

    ALIYA and LEAVING the “DERECH”?

    Q. What would you respond to someone who says they don’t want to make Aliyah because their kids will “go off the derech”?

    A. From my experience, whenever the topic of Aliya comes up, almost everyone looks for excuses, whether they are true or not, for any significant move, even for a great mitzvah, takes guts! Cognitive dissonance brings us to logically or even religiously justify that which is convenient and easier, but that doesn’t mean it’s correct! To the contrary. The classic mussar works (like Mesilat Yesharim, ch. 3) already point out that presenting one’s Yetzer Hara (e.g. to stay in Chu”l) as a Yetzer HaTov (e.g. “I want to keep my kids on the derech”) is one of the “oldest tricks”, for it confuses bad for good and good for bad, and easily soothes our conscience from making any significant necessary change.

    It’s very unfortunate your friend claims to feels that way (perhaps he’s influenced by the stereotype which may have been the case 60 years ago when the anti-religious ran the country, or by the secular Israelis who live in America…), for living in Israel is itself a mitzva like Shabbat or laying tefilin, and it’s like saying: “Observing Shabbat or tefillin may make you less religious”. Chazal teach “one should always live in Eretz Yisrael, even in a city of idolators and not in chutz laAretz- even in a city of Jews, which teaches living in Israel is equated with all of the other mitzvot combined” (Tosefta A.Z 5, 2), which should be enough to neutralize any such excuse. It also enables one to do so many more other mitzvot which don’t apply outside, also agricultural, and today, social and national, as well. In fact, every single second you are in the Land if Israel is another mitzva (Sefer HaChareidim, ch. 59). In other words, it’s not BECAUSE (!) of the Land of Israel that some people seemingly become less religious, but it’s DESPITE (!) the Holy Land. Those same people would by definition immediately be less religious living away from the Shchina and her many more mitzvot.

    I don’t know your friend or his circles, but my personal experience of over 35 years of educating 18 year olds in many various gap-year yeshiva programs in Israel, have clearly shown the exact opposite. Students staying in Israel generally marry more Torah-oriented spouses and build here strong homes of Torah, living in stronger Torah communities, compared with their friends who don’t make aliya.

    Statistics also contradict your friend’s feelings or limited circle impressions. In different studies done in America (by PEW and the OU), the outcomes range from 33%-56% of those who are raised orthodox there, don’t stay so, while in Israel (done by HLMS), the studies found that less leave (from 21%-43%). The varied numbers are based upon how wide the definition of “orthodox” is and whom they are surveying. The 21% number is among Torani yeshiva high school students, while the 43% number counts all those who were enrolled in public religious high schools (which includes those from non-religious families who may send to just to pacify grandparents; to distance from the more problematic youth in the regular public schools; many traditional families who aren’t really orthodox; and tens of thousands of olim from Ethiopia and the former Soviet Union who, in order to convert, their families must send them to religious schooling). Accordingly, if you were to compare truly parallel groups/yeshivas/families, say yeshiva Torani families in Israel and the U.S., or marginally religious families in both places, the “retention” group in Israel is probably much higher.

    Also, a study on this topic in the States, found that those who leave the Derech while on college campuses etc. generally “evaporate” from vision and simply aren’t seen anymore in the community, for they leave home to distant places, don’t show up in shul etc. On the other hand, in Israel, thank G-d, even those who “leave the Derech”, “stick around” in their families, homes etc. Israel is a very small country and much more family-oriented than western culture (in addition to the high price of rent which encourages many to continue living at home), so those who don’t stay religious are accordingly much more visible here, which surely contributes to your friend’s “optical illusion”.

    It’s also important to understand the significant difference in the cause of those who leave the Derech. In Israel, the pressure of army life (which is also an important mitzva in unto itself!) makes regular functioning difficult in most other spheres during those three “abnormal” years, and once there is that drop, it may also continue in the future. Nevertheless, it’s worth pointing out that over the past 3 years, as a direct result of the war with Hamas, 35% of the young (aged 16-35) in Israel have come closer to Judaism, usually davka in the IDF! In any event, here the solution is obvious, to insure that our boys do their army service in the Hesder or Haredi frameworks, where halachic observance is actually built into the system and there is a positive and supportive peer pressure during that period. On the other hand, in the U.S. peer pressure of being like the non-Jewish and non-religious norm and majority (99.8%!), continues throughout life and follows you wherever you may go.

    Also, even those who do leave the Derech in Israel will still marry Jews (even the 300,000 non-Jewish olim from the former Soviet Union are only about 3% of the population), still eat kosher, don’t work on Shabbat and celebrate the Jewish holidays. Very often, they return even more to tradition when they must decide what education is best for their children. In the context of Israel, “assimilation” is even good, for the Jews from Russia, Ukraine, etc. come from gentile or Christian cultures, and come to the Jewish State and inevitably become more “Jewish”.

    Contrarily, in America, it’s logical for those who leave the Derech to marry gentiles (who are 98% of the population there!) where the prospect of their and their children’s return are miniscule, not to mention that half of those grandchildren aren’t even Jewish. Ba’alei Teshuva are visible but statistically insignificant in America. How much more so when today, the Torah center of the world is in Israel, and young people come from all over the world to study in yeshiva, davka in the Land of Israel, this is the place to raise our children.

    It’s true, religion in Galut is more simplistic, black and white: just “don’t mix with the goyim”. In Israel Judaism isn’t just Shabbat & Kashrut, for we’re obligated to love and help our brothers and serve in the army with them, even if they’re non-observant. Also, some Israelis may feel they are good Jews by serving in the army and being part of the Jewish people (which is true, although partial), without the difficulties of Shabbat and Kashrut. So would we suggest that our children not give tzedakah because non-religious also do so?! It makes sense to observe ALL of the mitzvot because one is not at the expense of the other, but compliments and completes the package deal of the “Torah Temima”, the complete Torah. In a globalized world, there’s no insulation, even among Haredim. Hashem has decided that we are ready today for the more beautiful and encompassing complex Torah, and He gives us the tools to meet those challenges. In galut, like in a dark home, the more furniture around, the more we will trip so we just avoid them, but in Israel (likened by Yirmiyahu to a light room), the more furniture adds to the beauty, that’s the Living Torah revealing G-dliness in everything, including modernism, secular studies, army, work, politics etc.. Even if one decides to opt to be less open, it’s better to live in Givat Shaul and not send your son to the IDF than to live in America (where he’s not in the army anyway!) and also misses out every second on all of the mitzvot and spiritual advantages of Eretz Yisrael and Am Yisrael.

    I will concede that specifically among Anglo olim to whom you refer, the children are often raised in pro-active and “gutsy” homes, precisely that which enabled those parents to “rebel” against the gashmiut and physical pleasures of their own upbringing in America and “make the move”. This environment may logically also have a tendency to raise children who also “change course” in the opposite direction! In other words, those who leave are sometimes an expression of their environmental upbringing, and such parents would raise such children wherever they would be. The solution: consider what type of spouse to marry.

    Ironically, also sometimes Anglo parents are more permissive, and even go out of their way to make a conscious effort to live in Anglo communities in Israel, and keep American language and culture in their homes, often reminiscing or praising American products and culture, despite (!) being in Israel. Also, some Anglo parents here may wrongly justify investing less effort into educating their kids, thinking that here they have less to worry about because the “streets are Jewish”. On the other hand in America, parents MUST make a conscious effort to do the opposite, always stress the Jewish environment in the home. In short, America is not the solution but rather the problem, and the answer is to try and keep “America” out of our homes in Israel, as well.

    One can also build a case for the phenomena that the “post-high school experience” and “rebellion” of one’s religious teen coming from America to Israel to learn in yeshiva is the exact opposite of his Israeli teen counterpart. Many Israeli teens want to experience “something else” and “be different than their parents” by traveling abroad outside of Israel after the army. But the alternative, of “playing reverse psychology” by staying in America is not only a dangerous risk (where again, the stakes are much more extreme and higher), but according to that, every generation forever should do a zig-zag and do the opposite of what they know is good for themselves?! This is precisely what Yishayahu told Hizkiah (Brachot 10a), “don’t try and figure out the equations of G-d. Do what you are supposed to do, and Hashem will do that which He sees fit”. The mitzvot are called “L’tov Lach” (Dvarim 10, 13), for your benefit, and that clearly should be our decision.

    Even if theoretically (!) your friend were to be correct in saying it is more problematic to raise children in Israel, as above, our sages already taught that it’s better to even live in a city of idolaters (!) in the Land of Israel, rather than in a city of religious Jews outside of Israel (Tosefta, ibid; K’tuvot 110b, Shulchan Aruch Ev.H. 75). To understand that surprising statement, see my elaboration at: https://www.yeshiva.co/midrash/10931 . In other words, our sages clearly are already relating to your friend’s question (even BEFORE Israel was the world’s Torah center)!

    In short, in today’s world, there’s no guarantee anywhere regarding your children’s future spirituality. Free-will has shifted into a higher gear, but when you make the decision to make Aliya, you are at least ensuring that they and their children will be Jewish, will be living among Am Yisrael, will be around in Y’mot HaMashiach, will be doing that many more mitzvot (by definition of being here) and will be in contact with more idealistic and impressive Torah personalities and the world Torah center. Not to mention that you will be following the guidance of our sages who already answered your friend’s question 1,800 years ago, even when the atmosphere in Israel was idolatress! You and your children will also be an active part of the most glorious chapter in Jewish history: the gathering of the exiles and the redemption! BTW, even those adamant to stay in America, the G-d of history is sending them Home anyway, for anti-Semitism there is closing that option.

    Shlomo Zalman Shragai, was one of the leaders of the religious-Zionist Mizrachi around the time of the founding of the nascent State of Israel, who headed the Aliya department of the Jewish Agency. He saw that at the time, the anti-religious Zionists who ran the country often directed young dati olim from Morrocco to anti-religious kibbutzim. He asked the famed R. Zvi Pesach Frank, rav of Yerushalayim, whether in fact it was proper to bring them on aliya under such circumstances? R. Frank answered: “definitely! You will see that those who stay in chu”l will not only assimilate but will be totally lost to Am Yisrael”, and that’s precisely what happened. B’Hatzlacha Rabba u’LeHitra’ot BaAretz! Rav Ari Shvat (Chwat)

  • CAIN and TUVAL-CAIN: LESSONS IN LEADERSHIP- Preparing for Israel’s Elections- parshat Breishit

    CAIN and TUVAL-CAIN: LESSONS IN LEADERSHIP- Preparing for Israel’s Elections- parshat Breishit

    As the Jewish people approach elections, parshat Breishit is an opportunity to see the Torah’s take on proper leadership.

    The opening chapters of Breishit are the origins of humanity, of all “Bnei Adam”, and teaches us that those who are stronger or more experienced, can use their advantage to either protect and benefit the vulnerable—or to exploit them. The first path creates civilization; the second creates violence and Darwinian Socialism.

    Without being able to understand what the original world was supposed to be like before the sin, we find that the first human relationship in our world, between Adam and Eve is a relationship of hierarchy: “And toward your husband shall be your desire, and he shall rule over you” (Breishit 3:16). PRIMITIVE society ranked one based on his physical strength. Eve in turn, upon giving birth to a tiny helpless baby sees it as her opportunity to also own and control, naming him Kayin, “I have acquired (Kaniti) a person (together/like with) G-d”. Freud feels that most people see themselves as the “hero” of life, and those around him as objects, as “things” for your use. Accordingly, she then names her 2nd son Hevel, literally: “nothing”, which is even lower than “thing” (Kayin).

    This is the atmosphere in which Cain was raised, so as the older brother, he also sees his little brother as a helper, like Eve is to Adam (“ezer kinegdo”). The contrast between the brothers is striking, as Cain exploits the passive land; while Hevel is a caring shepherd.

    Accordingly, when the younger brother “shows up” Cain by G-d accepting davka “nothing’s” sacrifice, Cain’s face “falls”, he feels dethroned. The Talmud in Yoma (52b) says the following pasuk (4, 7) is one of 5 verses in the entire Torah that are most difficult to explain, but according to our theme, G-d is telling Cain: don’t feel you have fallen from your status (of first-born) just because Hevel’s sacrifice, not yours, was accepted. For as the older brother, you are the born leader (see Prof. Frank Salloway=Soloveichik, on the disproportionate success of firstborns!), “if you do well (to your younger brother) you will RISE (se’et, see Br. 43, 3), but if you don’t use your leadership to do well to him, your opening (first-born-ness/leadership) will constantly lurk and cause you to sin (by exploiting the more vulnerable). “He yearns for you(r help) and you shall rule over him”. It’s there for you to lead, so you need not feel threatened by Hevel, nor do you need to exploit him to prove your status.

    “And Cain said to Hevel his brother, and when they were in the field, Cain rose and killed his brother Hevel”. All ask, what did Cain tell Hevel, what did he say that caused the first murder? Chizkuni, Shadal and Nechama Leibowitz explain that if it doesn’t say afterwards what he told him, apparently the answer is what is written right beforehand (e.g. Shmot 19, 24-25). Cain told Hevel, “I just received G-d’s official “hechsher”/permission to rule over you”, and as the farmer, he forced him out to his FIELD to be his “cheap labor” (the basis of all agricultural economies), and apparently while whipping his younger brother to work faster, he killed him.

    G-d asks Cain, “where is Hevel your BROTHER (not your servant!)”, and Cain’s answer, “I don’t know, am I my brother’s keeper”, receives a thundering silent answer from Hashem, : YES- that’s precisely the job of the experienced leader (Kayin in Arabic means: knower)! “Brother” means that Hevel is not Cain’s servant, competitor, or resource. He is his responsibility to aid.

    Cain is then educationally punished that he will no longer even rule over the land, but will wander, forced to experience himself what it means to be vulnerable and without protection. Cain complains: all animals can now kill me! G-d gives him a protective sign, teaching Cain and all “Bnei Adam”, demonstrating how leaders are supposed to care for the more vulnerable.

    The immediate story of Cain’s descendent Lemech is accordingly understood: His children are credited with major human innovations: Yaval develops pastoral civilization, Yuval music, and Tuval-Cain metalworking. Especially Tuval-Cain’s mastery of bronze to create arrow-heads (displayed in all museums as the beginning of the Bronze Age), enabling the weaker (he’s the youngest) man to control even lions & elephants, older brothers and even parents, those who previously dominated them. This can be great for self-defense (as in the IDF), or conversely easily intensify the cycle of violence (Jihad). Worth noting, their names were probably originally Yaval, Yuval and Tuval (Benno Ya’akov: reminders of “Hevel”, the more refined/sensitive brother), but his invention of arrows apparently added his ancestor’s (and ideological predecessor’s) nickname: Tuval-CAIN.

    Lemech’s wives are angry, but it’s not clear why? (Abarbanel termed as non-understandable, but now, bezH according to our theme, it makes sense:) Lemech protests that he “killed a man because he wounded me, a CHILD for my injury” (23). Apparently Tuval-Cain (their most logical child candidate to be the perpetrator, especially with his added nickname!) tried using his arrows to control his stronger/experienced father, and Lemech excuses: “I just killed him (even perhaps accidentally) in self-defense! He then invokes the protection granted to Cain: “If Cain shall be avenged sevenfold, then Lemech seventy-sevenfold,” for mine was just self-defense, not like Cain’s or Tuval-Cain’s exploiting of power.

    In short, G-d’s, Adam’s, Eve’s, Cain’s and Tuval-Cains’s leadership, as political leadership of all “Bnei Adam”, and especially in Am Yisrael, “the Kingdom of Kohanim and Holy Nation”, is meant to altruistically help, benefit and aid the less powerful and more vulnerable subjects and citizens, the followers, not to exploit and gain power. This Imitateo Dei, copying G-d’s leadership of altruism, is clearly shown in Rav Kook’s signet stamp which sealed all of his letters: “Chief Rabbi, a servant to the Holy People on the Holy Land”. Yes. If you are a leader, older, stronger or wiser, you are your brother’s keeper. Shabbat Shalom!

    Rav Ari Shvat (Chwat)

  • “FLYDUBAI and HOSHANA RABBA- ANI VAHU HOSHIA NA- I and HIM SAVE US!

    “FLYDUBAI and HOSHANA RABBA- ANI VAHU HOSHIA NA- I and HIM SAVE US!

    Every year, I teach that we should have in mind while saying Hallel on Sukkot, to also have kavana to thank Hashem for the miraculous “turn-around” victory of the Yom Kippur War in 1973/תשל”ד, which took place during Sukkot. The Israeli TV series “Sha’at Ne’ila” revolved around how Israeli convicts, movie-stars, upper and lower class, religious and secular, Ashkenazi and Sefaradi, veterans and new olim all molded together to save Am Yisrael in our darkest time since the Shoa. Over 2,650 fell (yes, even more than in our present war), most in the first five days!

    Yesterday, I announced that we must also have in mind this year to thank Hashem for the uncountable victories of the past 3 years, as well as THIS YEAR’S SUKKA (=G-dly protection) and miraculous end of the unsuccessful FlyDubai hijacking. Seconds separated between survival & extreme tragedy, and what could very easily have changed our mood and ruined Zman Simchatenu.

    Rav Kook writes (Ein Aya, Brachot ch. 9), that G-d runs His world on many levels, including various ALMOST deaths. Like a dream or sickness, any time we are “faced with death”, even if it was just a fleeting dream, it’s meant to wake us from our slumber and appreciate. Hallel, praising him “על חסדך ועל אמיתך”, “for His kindness & TRUTHS” (=G-d doesn’t need our kavod, but admiring His kindness & salvations, strengthen our resolve to follow His Torah truths and ideals, Imitateo Dei, צלם אלהים).

    As we say in Hallel, לא אמות כי אחיה ואספר מעשי י-ה. יסור יסרני י-ה ולמוות לא נתנני”, “I shall not die but I shall live and tell the deeds of G-d. He sent me challenges, but did not deliver me to death”.

    The Dubna Maggid asks on Hallel: “”הללו את ה’ כל גוים.. כי גבר עלינו חסדו, “Let all the nations Praise G-d… for His abundant kindness to us”: why should THEY thank Him for His kindness to Israel?! He answers with a mashal of a gentile who elaborately planned to kill a Jew, but was foiled, even without the Jew’s knowing that he was endangered. The terrorist co-pilot in jail in Saudi Arabia, knows better than we do, what he had planned!

    So even if by chance, the NY Times writes that it wasn’t a terrorist hijacking but simply an “altercation” between co-pilots over perhaps a girlfriend (while yelling “Allahu Achbar”!), or Trump’s suggestion that the stabber who wanted to kill 174 Jews was just “Wacko” (as are all suicidal terrorists, problem is that in the Middle-East that’s the norm!), the fact that it could have been a hijacking and could have been a Jewish calamity is what we thank Hashem for. The bottom line is that He prevented whatever could have been. We must especially thank Him for training us to be brave Israelis (emulating His truths) who, disproportionately to any other flight in the world, have the guts and pro-activeness to make colossal life-saving decisions within seconds, under the ultimate pressure, and extreme lack of balance.

    This is perhaps the true pshat in today’s Hoshanot, “Ani vaHu Hoshia Na”, “I and Him, Save Us”. We don’t just pray to Him, but we also pray to and for ourselves that we should emulate and educate our children to have that instinctive altruism with which He created the world. President Trump seemed amused about Yaniv Hayon, our PLUMBER who confidently worked with G-d like Superman (he learned from a pilot on a TV show!) to save 174 lives, but we in Israel are totally accustomed already 78 years to our plumbers, teachers, garbage-men, rabbis, farmers & doctors being Hashem’s shlichim (you must see the song on YouTube: גיבורי על, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EjCVg_aYfp8&list=RDEjCVg_aYfp8&start_radio=1), meriting to be G-dly in a way that the Chafetz Chaim and Rambam didn’t have such opportunities!

    I’m not criticizing but truly feel sorry for anyone who didn’t serve in the IDF, and didn’t develop, or at least encourage his children to develop, his G-dly selfless potential to become instinctive, even stronger and overcoming that strongest of natural instincts to freeze, shriek or flee to “save your own self”. Yes, many jokes, cartoons and clips are flying around social media (joking to relieve pressure is also a healthy G-dly nature) about the 4 Israeli heroes who acted like David HaMelech with Hashem, but that is the ultimate DREAM of ANY FATHER: for His children to be like Himself, as well as to be independent, self-confident, self-aware, self-sufficient and above all, idealistic and altruistic as the 13 Traits of Himself. Rather than freezing or just shrieking “Shma Yisrael”, BezH G-dly brothers like this can insure our having a Pitka Tava, a successful year, especially when “the chips are down”. Ani vaHu Hoshiah Na! Rav Ari Shvat (Chwat)

  • “TREE TASTES LIKE THE FRUIT 2″- Sukkot/Etrog as a Microcosm of Eretz Yisrael

    “TREE TASTES LIKE THE FRUIT”- Sukkot/Etrog as a Microcosm of Eretz Yisrael

    Rav Kook points out (Orot HaTeshuva 6, 7) that just as most of the tree is roots, trunk, branches and leaves, despite the fact that the goal of an apple tree is her fruit, similarly most of life is preparations (e.g. eating, sleep, dress, work, cooking, changing diapers), and often one doesn’t even achieve his goal. Does that mean that he wasted his life?! The existential question is, if most of life is “tree” (= a ‘means’ to achieve a goal), and I want to have meaning in life, I have no choice but to find a way to have “taste” in the tree, not just in the fruit. This was the original plan in Eden (where Hashem commanded “let there be fruit trees that produce fruit”, but the earth didn’t listen and just grew “trees that produce fruit”, Yalkut Shimoni Breishit 1), and is meant to be the ideal lifestyle, as expressed in the Etrog where the tree still tastes like her fruit (the last remnant of the ideal world, Sukkah 35a). The Vilna Gaon says that living in Eretz Yisrael is like living one’s entire life in a Sukkah (Kol HaTor, p. 470), where even the secular/mundane/”tree” is not just preparation and ‘means’, but also has meaning/taste/holiness, and all that you do is a mitzva!

    Usually eating, walking, work, speaking, sleep etc. are just a ‘means’ to achieve some higher goal in life, but in the sukkah, whatever you do there is a mitzva. Similarly in Eretz Yisrael, there is spiritual value in producing and eating her holy fruit and all really all occupations (Chatam Sofer, Suka 35); in walking 4 steps (Mishna Brura 248, 28); in speaking her Holy Language of Hebrew (Sifre, Dvarim 11,19), and even serving in her army is a Milchemet Mitzva (Rambam hil. Milachim 5, 1).

    Rav Kook (Ma’amarei HaReiya, p. 235) points out that Yom Kippur, when we pretend to act like angels and distance ourselves from physical pleasure, is extreme “shock treatment” for the spiritually sick, who temporarily need bitter medicine in order to return to health. But the final mitzvah of Yom Kippur is to go out and build a sukkah, return to living a daily life of kedusha. Similarly, the Mesilat Yesharim (ch. 26) explains that Tahara (refraining from physical pleasure to the bare minimum), is a lower level than Kedusha (revealing G-dliness in the physical world). Accordingly, Rav Kook explains why we have over 50 Shabbatot and many Yom Tovs over the year, and only one Yom Kippur. This is the Living Torah of Eretz Yisrael which embodies Kedusha (ibid, p. 179), as opposed to the Torah of Chutz laAretz which makes do with Tahara (as does Christianity). Accordingly, we understand why the Talmud Yerushalmi written in Eretz Yisrael, considers the “preparation” for a mitzvah (like writing a mezuza, building a sukkah or tying tzitzit) as an additional mitzvah (even deserving its own bracha: e.g. “לעשות סוכה”), as opposed to the Talmud Bavli (Tosafot, M’nachot 42b) written in Chutz laAretz, which does not consider the preparation a mitzvah.

    Rav Kook similarly explains why the Simchat Beit HaSho’eva (literally: “the party of the water-drawing”) on Sukkot is not called “Simchat Nisuch HaMayim” (the party of the pouring of the water), even though the mitzva was to pour the water on the alter on Sukkot, and the “drawing” of the water was just a “PREPARATION”. Similarly, the Torah mentions the preparation of building a sukka (“תעשה”) and acquiring the 4 species (“”ולקחתם) even though they aren’t “officially” part of the mitzva, where in contrast, it doesn’t say “you shall BAKE matzot”. These 2 mitzvot are also unique that the preparation involves much effort, time and money, but the mitzva itself is short and simple (just enter the sukka or pick up the species). Similarly, these 2 mitzvot are the FIRST 2 of 5 examples listed in the Talmud (Shabbat 133b) of HIDDUR mitzva (from the root: HADAR, the name for the etrog, Vayikra 23, 40!), as THE prime samples of doing mitzvot physically beautiful (details of Hiddur ALL (!) mitzvot are found in hil. Etrog, Or.Ch. 656). Even today, there are no other mitzvot where we invest so much DECORATION, and examination for no BLEMISHES, despite that usually physical beauty is just means/”tree”/preparation and not a goal/”fruit”!

    For this holiday teaches that the preparations/tree in life are also important, not just the fruit/goal. This is all befitting for Chag HaAsif, where we worked an entire agricultural year, plowing, planting, irrigating, fertilizing, pruning etc. in PREPARATION for gathering the fruit, the produce. Sukkot teaches us that even if chalila there was a drought and not that much fruit, we did not waste a year, for in Eretz Yisrael, there is “taste/meaning/ideal in the tree (e.g. the work), just as in the fruit!” This is a throw-back and “throw forward” to the ideal world. Accordingly, the Abravanel (Dvarim 16) says that just as Pesach celebrates Am Yisrael, and Shavu’ot- Torat Yisrael, Sukkot represents a microcosm of Eretz Yisrael. This also explains why only Sukkot is called “Zman Simchatenu”, because all pleasure is considered holy! Chag Same’ach and we should hear Besorot Tovot from all Yisrael!! (Refuah Shleima to all, including Neria Dov son of Yechiel and Chani (Weiss) Leiter seriously wounded yesterday by terrorists), Rav Ari Shvat (Chwat)

  • “THE WORLD THAT WASN’T FINISHED”- P. Netzavim-Vayelech

    THE WORLD THAT WASN’T FINISHED- p. Netzavim-Vayelech

    This week’s parsha regarding Teshuva (Dvarim 29, 2) is perfectly timed on the yearly calendar.

    Q. If G-d is perfect, why didn’t He just create a perfect, finished world in a single instant? A. The seven days were never about time, they were G-d’s opening statement: this is a world built to climb, not a world built finished. Rav Kook’s answer, distilled from Orot HaTshuva (5, 3), reframes the entire story of the universe — and of every person in it — as one long, deliberate climb toward the light.

    The Gift Hidden Inside “Imperfection”- G-d purposely wanted to create a world of gradually climbing stages, where man, slowly but surely, is a partner with G-d in choosing to improve himself and the world. G-d is so perfect that He wanted to give man the opportunity to have free will — INDEPENDENT like G-d Himself — and chose to leave us room to choose to be “G-dly,” to give to the world the way G-d gives to the world. The greatest gift G-d gave us is that we can be G-dly. Accordingly, He didn’t create a perfect world in one shot. He showed us from the very first verse that this is a world of EVOLUTION — of gradual development and improvement, moving at the rate of our own choosing to do good. And with real choice comes real risk: ups and downs along the way, essential to make free will actually free. The Whole World Is Still Climbing- Once you see that the world itself is built on evolution and improvement, the pattern shows up everywhere you look. ATHLETICS Sports records keep falling — every generation runs faster, jumps higher, lifts more. BIOLOGY Each generation, on average, grows taller and stronger than the one before it. TECHNOLOGY COMMERCE Trial, error, and competition push innovation forward without pause. Even the shampoo in your shower is “New and Improved” — because improvement sells. Just as an individual gradually matures — physically, emotionally, intellectually — mankind as a whole is maturing too. Not only in body, but in conscience. The Moral Climb We still have a long way to go — Rav Kook never pretended otherwise. But the direction of travel is visible: slavery, racism, chauvinism, and imperialism are no longer acceptable in the way they once were taken for granted. That shift didn’t happen overnight, and it isn’t finished. It is, itself, evidence of the very evolutionary design built into creation from Day One. “So is the Ge’ula of Israel, like a sunrise, slowly but surely” (Yerushalmi Brachot 1, 1).

    The Natural Next Step- Which leads to the quiet, almost obvious conclusion Rav Kook is really after. If everything — the cosmos, the body, the record books, the moral order — is slowly, steadily improving, then a person eventually turns the mirror on himself and says the only thing left to say: “The most natural thing for me to do is to improve, as well.” That single sentence is teshuva. Not a punishment,— but the most natural act in a universe built entirely out of gradual return to the light. That’s Rav Kook’s Orot HaTshuva — in a nutshell.

  • Rosh HaShana- Yom Kippur- Women Floor-Bowing

    FLOOR-BOWING FOR WOMEN

    Question: On Rosh Hashana and Yom Kippur when the congregation bows down on the floor during Aleynu, and the Service of the Kohen Gadol, should women bow, as well?

    Like many questions, this should really be addressed to your local rabbi. In general, one should do like the local custom, so if the women in your shul bow or refrain from doing so, that’s what you should be doing. It’s definitely wrong for only individuals to bow, for it’s “yuhara” (the prohibition of “showing off” religiously).

    Several reasons are offered to explain why in many shuls, women don’t bow:

    a. R. Chaim Soloveichik of Brisk said that the prostration is in memory of what we used to do in the Beit HaMikdash (Temple). Accordingly, women, who were not in the Azara section there, didn’t bow, so also today, there’s no reason for them to do so. b. Some feel that even if there are no men watching, it’s not a tzanua (modest) position for women. c. Sometimes the women’s section was just too small and there was no room for everyone to prostrate!

    It’s important to note, that when bowing onto the floor, you should place a towel or talit to separate between your face (not your knees!) and the ground, for it’s forbidden to bow down on the floor outside the Beit Hamikdash. Regarding those who wish to put under their knees so as not to get dirty, it’s okay, but don’t think that that’s enough. Ktiva vaChatima Tova!

  • “Pursuit is Perfection” – P. HaAzinu- Shabbat Shuva-

    PURSUIT is PERFECTION – p. Ha’azinu, Shabbat Shuva

    Rav Kook (Orot HaTshuva 5, 6) deals with the question of the seemingly hopelessness of Tshuva. For G-d Himself knows that He created us with free will, which inevitably means we will sometimes make mistakes and choose wrong. This can easily be frustrating, freezing us into inaction and ye’ush (loss of hope). If one sins even once, does he chalila have no choice but suicide?! Moreover, our G-dly conscience demands justice, righteousness and perfection, but we all know this is impossible, so what’s the solution?

    Rav Kook answers that precisely because of this problem, the answer (literally: tshuva) is natural, that the world has a “built-in” push towards evolution, to constantly drive to improve, continuously advancing even if we know we will never “arrive”. Perfection (shlemut) itself is in fact impossible for except by Him, there’s always room to improve (even Moshe Rabbenu only rose to the 49^th^ level, Rosh HaShana 21b). The SINCERE STRIVE for perfection (hishtalmut) for us is the best we can ever do. Both we and obviously G-d know if we are GENUINE or not, so one can’t “cop-out” and not try his hardest, but we also both know when we are giving our best. Regarding mitzvot where we hurt others, this obviously includes asking their forgiveness (Rambam Tshuva 2, 9), as we’ve written previously from R. Yisrael Salanter, at least on Yom Kippur where we all ask forgiveness from all, thus not needing to detail our offence and consequently hurt that person again.

    This paragraph in Orot HaTshuva, is undoubtedly what R. Hanan Porat (the super-impressive halutzic and religious-kibbutz leader, Torah scholar and one of the closest students of R. Zvi Yehuda Kook) had in mind, when he famously answered in his final TV interview, “I’m not scared at all of death, for I can honestly say that I sincerely tried to be good”. This is what R. Zusia of Anipole meant when he said, “they won’t ask me why I wasn’t Moshe Rabbenu, but “why I wasn’t Zusia?” This is precisely what we mean in Shema every day, that we love G-d “b’chol m’odecha” (literally: “with all of our very”).

    V’erastich li l’olam (Hoshea 2, 21, “and I will BETROTH you to Me forever”) recognizes that we can never consummate our love for Hashem, like a couple who are not yet married, but their love is constantly growing. The Rambam (ibid, 10, 3), explains that this is what all Shir HaShirim (Song of Songs) is about, that the lovers (we and Hashem) never get married, but eternally increase/improve our love for each other. “Tzama licha nafshi” (Tehilim 63, 2, “my soul thirsts for You”), with that desire which can NEVER be quenched. Our other relationship with G-d is that of a reassuring Father, not wanting us to be quaking, miserable and nervous wrecks (Midot haReiya, HaKavod 3), but rather constantly encouraging and cheering us to get the most out of the outstanding never-ending potential He gave us.

    The Talmud (Shabbat 89b) deals with the famous pasuk we mention many times during the Yom Kippur prayer, “Im y’hiyu cha’teichem kashanim kasheleg yalbinu” (“if your sins will be like reds, they will be whitened like snow,” Yishayahu 1, 18). Our sages ask, why is it written kashanim (literally: like “reds”), not k’shani (like red)? And answer that “shanim” also has the connotation of the Hebrew word for “years”. Rav Kook (Ein Aya 9, 131) explains their intention, that this whitening evolutionary process of improvement is not an answer to incidental unfortunate sins, but rather is “built-in” to mankind for YEARS since the beginning. It’s just up to us to decide how apparent that improvement will be, whether hopefully, that arrow will climb steeply and steadily towards our perfect G-d, or whether the pace will be slower and less vertical. So Rav Kook explains (5, 6*) that “tshuva preceded the world” (Psachim 54a), for it’s “built-in” as part of the plan.

    In short, not perfection (shlemut) but the strive for perfection (hishtalmut) is our perfection. As soon as we sincerely choose to “hop onto the train” of teshuva, that’s as perfect as we are going to get in this world, even if there are inevitable ups and downs along the way. So “just do it”! Gmar Chatima Tova, Rav Ari Shvat (Chwat)

  • weekly letters- NEVER EXTREME EXCEPT ISRAEL- p. R’eh

    NEVER EXTREME EXCEPT ISRAEL- parshat Re’eh

    Q. How can we understand certain surprisingly extreme statements of our sages against those who live outside of the Land of Israel, like “whoever lives outside of Eretz Yisrael has no G-d… is like one worshiping idols” (Ketuvot 110b)? It seems offensive!

    A. The answer to such questions is usually found in its context. The Talmud there begins by saying, “A person should always live in the Land of Israel, even in a city which is mostly idolators, rather than in Chutz LaAretz, even in a city which is mostly Jewish, for whoever lives outside of Eretz Yisrael has no G-d, etc”. A parallel source (Tosefta Av.Z. 5, 2) cites this (with minor changes) and continues, “teaching us that living in Eretz Yisrael is equated with the rest of the mitzvot combined”.

    Chazal explicitly bring the strongest “havi-amina” (=”competition”, reason we might have thought otherwise): for during 2,000 years of exile, the Torah atmosphere in Bavel, and afterwards in Morrocco and Europe, outside of the Land of Israel was stronger, while contrarily in the Land of Israel there was a predominantly gentile, even idolatrous atmosphere. Nevertheless, despite the importance of one’s surrounding influence, it’s “ALWAYS better to live in the Land of Israel” (cited as halacha, Rambam, Melachim 5, 12), for the Divine presence here is the strongest and superior spiritual influence. The mussar classics stress that the strongest test is when your Yetzer HaRa disguises itself as your Yetzer HaTov. “Of course my spiritual surroundings are of utmost importance”. Question is, maybe I should let Chazal (and not my cognitive dissonance!) define and decide what is the best “spiritual surroundings”…

    Your question is correctly based upon the Rambam’s (and Judaism’s!) principle that “the middle path” is correct regarding every topic, and extremism is almost always problematic and wrong (Hil. De’ot, see Rav Kook, Orot,…). Nevertheless the Rambam himself continues there that regarding the traits of arrogance and anger (which are obviously closely connected), one must “run” to the opposite extreme.

    This is generally understood for 2 (obviously connected) reasons:

    1. When there’s so much pulling me in the other direction (our tendency is to be egocentric and anger easily), and consequently:

    2. The definition of WHERE is the middle is unclear, for we get confused and must make a conscious effort to “bend over backwards” to end up in the real middle.

    Rav Tzvi Yehuda Kook often said, “הוודאי שמו כן תהילתו”, “His Name is definite and so is His praise”, explaining that the Torah is meant to be certain and totally clear, leaving no room for excuses and unclarity in the face of the Yetzer HaRa.

    Accordingly we shouldn’t be surprised that in those 2 aforementioned examples, Chazal also teach that one who gets angry is like an idolator (Shabbat 105b), as well as one who is arrogant (Sotah 5a).

    Similarly, we all know that there are so many reasons pulling a person to stay in America: knowing the system, the language, our close family, a higher standard of living, fear-of-the-unknown or change etc. The status quo is the way “I always pictured myself” like my parents, in the lifestyle and communities in which I grew up. It’s easy to legitimize living in Chutz LaAretz when “my rabbi also lives here”, and COGNITIVE DISSONANCE (in Hebrew, the Yetzer haRa) justifies it from any possible angle. Comes Rashi and stresses no, it is not legitimate, there is “a SIN to live in Chutz LaAretz” (Berachot 57a). Your rabbi may have an excuse, but you (almost always) don’t.

    Interestingly, this week’s parsha begins that we all have free-will to do good or bad (11, 26-28). The Rambam is well-known for his stressing the strength of this free-will, that we can overcome almost any obstacle in life to be who we want (midat Gevura). If so, why does he say that it’s important to choose spiritual surroundings for EVERYONE is influenced? The answer is that yes, you are inevitably influenced by your surroundings, but you have free-will to choose by whom or by what to be influenced! Our topic stresses that spiritual influence is not just your community, but in Israel, it is your G-d and His holiness which influences even via the air we breathe and fruit we eat! For 2,000 years, when Israel was in the hands of gentiles, we had to choose between the 2 (and the answer was still: Israel), but today BH the Torah, yeshiva and rabbinical center of the world is also in Israel, so how much more so Israel is the clear answer.

    In short, as great educators, the goal of our sages apparently is to SHOCK you, for you can’t just read such a statement and continue without stopping to think. Galut has such a strong pull, that they bring in a GAME-CHANGER that will break the status quo. Their goal is precisely to GRAB your attention, and (based on your question) they clearly succeeded!

  • “TESHUVA IN COURT OF LAW?!”-Parshat Shoftim

    TESHUVA IN COURT OF LAW?” Parshat Shoftim-Chodesh Elul

    Shoftim always falls during Elul, and the question is why?

    Elul is the month of mercy and teshuva, when the King is most approachable, “leaving the castle to go out to the field”. Nevertheless, this sharply CONTRASTS the Human Court and Jewish State which is meant to do justice. Only Hashem can see into our hearts (Shmuel I 16, 7), but if every criminal could tell the Beit Din, “I sincerely regret, please forgive and don’t punish me”, we wouldn’t be able to run a country.

    Rav Kook, the game-changing rabbi who was the first to see the rejuvenation of the original and authentic Torah in religious- Zionism (whose Yahrtzeit falls tomorrow on 3 Elul), stresses that Judaism reveals G-dliness everywhere, not just in the life of the individual, but even in the many spheres of the nation, which are an essential part of the original and renewed Jewish State (Orot HaKodesh 2, p. 488).

    Rav David Cohen, the famed Nazir zt”l, once asked his close rebbe, Rav Kook, if there is so much overlap between CHABAD thought (Rav Kook’s mother family was Lubavitch) and his own teaching (of religious Zionism), so what’s is the difference? His teacher answered decisively, “One must differentiate between thoughts between an individual and G-d, as opposed to between Klal Yisrael and Hashem. We’re out to build a NATION” (Kol Tzofai’ch, p. 127). Judaism isn’t just for individuals, but “We are preoccupied with the salvation/renewal of Knesset Yisrael” (intr. to Orot HaKodesh, p. 21).

    G-d runs Am Yisrael and history, but He gave us free-will and the Torah guidelines, not just to run our own lives, but to establish the most just and righteous human nation (“”אשר יצוה את בניו ואת ביתו אחריו ושמרו דרך ה’ לעשות צדקה ומשפט” ,Breishit 18, 19, see Orot, p. 104), “A Light for the nations” (Yeshaya 49, 6), national & universal, not just individuals.

    The Gazan tunnels and mass murder and kidnappings showed that abandoning Gaza was a tragic mistake and that Jewish settlements are very important not just for the mitzvah but for national security, but Yishuv Eretz Yisrael and punishing terror can’t be done by vigilantes, and must be done by the Jewish State, Knesset Yisrael, otherwise it will lead to anarchy and won’t be that State of exemplary Light.

    As Israel approaches elections, it’s important to remember Rav Kook’s teacher, the Netziv (HaAmek Davar, Dvarim 17, 14-16), who wrote that if people prefer that the Jewish State should be democratic and without a king, then in these generations that is what’s necessary and best (for it’s even pikuch nefesh to have a form of government that the people don’t want). Democracy means that each side must accept the democratic outcome. It also means that each of the 3 houses of rule (executive, judicial and legislative) must each respect and work with the others RESPECTIVELY. Demonstrations and protests are also an important part of democracy, but the framework of checks and balances must be maintained. How to define the balance? Elections, but the Supreme Court must also respect the outcome. No one person is ever perfect, but Am Yisrael, as a whole is! (Orot, p. 146).

    It’s worth noting that the justice must be found in every tribe, “שֹׁפְטִים וְשֹׁטְרִים, תִּתֶּן-לְךָ בְּכָל-שְׁעָרֶיךָ, אשר ה’ אלקיך נותן לך לִשְׁבָטֶיךָ — (Dvarim 16, 18) Every tribe represents a different ideology (Orot HaKodesh 4, p. 508) and might have a little different shade of justice, but G-d’s objective and eternal justice obligates and unites us all (the 70 Jews who went down to found Israel in Egypt, and the 70 nations of the world).

    In addition, we say 3 times a day, “”לברך את עמך ישראל בכל עת ובכל שעה בשלומיך, that Hashem should “bless Your Nation of Israel in all times with Your Shalom”. This means even during election time, when parties are busy “putting down” each other, and weakening our Achdut, we are reminded that we’re all out for that one goal, to build the ideal Jewish State, which inevitably is going to balance the various legitimate ideologies, and fix the Sinat Chinam which destroyed our 2nd Commonwealth.

    Similarly, our parsha teaches that the Sanhedrin must be in Yerushalayim (17, 10), the national capitol. The meaning is obvious: that all of the various ideologies, the religious, judicial and national capitols, the right, left and religious, must cooperate together, which is the goal of Am Yisrael, “ממלכת כהנים וגוי קדוש”” (Shmot 19, 6), for “we’re out to build a(n ideal) nation”. With this Tzedek, we will in fact inherit and run the Land of Israel, “צדק צדק תרדוף למען תחיה וירשת את הארץ”, 16, 20). Shabbat Shalom and Chodesh Tov, Rav Ari Shvat (Chwat)