CAIN and TUVAL-CAIN: LESSONS IN LEADERSHIP- Preparing for Israel’s Elections- parshat Breishit

Written by

in

CAIN and TUVAL-CAIN: LESSONS IN LEADERSHIP- Preparing for Israel’s Elections- parshat Breishit

As the Jewish people approach elections, parshat Breishit is an opportunity to see the Torah’s take on proper leadership.

The opening chapters of Breishit are the origins of humanity, of all “Bnei Adam”, and teaches us that those who are stronger or more experienced, can use their advantage to either protect and benefit the vulnerable—or to exploit them. The first path creates civilization; the second creates violence and Darwinian Socialism.

Without being able to understand what the original world was supposed to be like before the sin, we find that the first human relationship in our world, between Adam and Eve is a relationship of hierarchy: “And toward your husband shall be your desire, and he shall rule over you” (Breishit 3:16). PRIMITIVE society ranked one based on his physical strength. Eve in turn, upon giving birth to a tiny helpless baby sees it as her opportunity to also own and control, naming him Kayin, “I have acquired (Kaniti) a person (together/like with) G-d”. Freud feels that most people see themselves as the “hero” of life, and those around him as objects, as “things” for your use. Accordingly, she then names her 2nd son Hevel, literally: “nothing”, which is even lower than “thing” (Kayin).

This is the atmosphere in which Cain was raised, so as the older brother, he also sees his little brother as a helper, like Eve is to Adam (“ezer kinegdo”). The contrast between the brothers is striking, as Cain exploits the passive land; while Hevel is a caring shepherd.

Accordingly, when the younger brother “shows up” Cain by G-d accepting davka “nothing’s” sacrifice, Cain’s face “falls”, he feels dethroned. The Talmud in Yoma (52b) says the following pasuk (4, 7) is one of 5 verses in the entire Torah that are most difficult to explain, but according to our theme, G-d is telling Cain: don’t feel you have fallen from your status (of first-born) just because Hevel’s sacrifice, not yours, was accepted. For as the older brother, you are the born leader (see Prof. Frank Salloway=Soloveichik, on the disproportionate success of firstborns!), “if you do well (to your younger brother) you will RISE (se’et, see Br. 43, 3), but if you don’t use your leadership to do well to him, your opening (first-born-ness/leadership) will constantly lurk and cause you to sin (by exploiting the more vulnerable). “He yearns for you(r help) and you shall rule over him”. It’s there for you to lead, so you need not feel threatened by Hevel, nor do you need to exploit him to prove your status.

“And Cain said to Hevel his brother, and when they were in the field, Cain rose and killed his brother Hevel”. All ask, what did Cain tell Hevel, what did he say that caused the first murder? Chizkuni, Shadal and Nechama Leibowitz explain that if it doesn’t say afterwards what he told him, apparently the answer is what is written right beforehand (e.g. Shmot 19, 24-25). Cain told Hevel, “I just received G-d’s official “hechsher”/permission to rule over you”, and as the farmer, he forced him out to his FIELD to be his “cheap labor” (the basis of all agricultural economies), and apparently while whipping his younger brother to work faster, he killed him.

G-d asks Cain, “where is Hevel your BROTHER (not your servant!)”, and Cain’s answer, “I don’t know, am I my brother’s keeper”, receives a thundering silent answer from Hashem, : YES- that’s precisely the job of the experienced leader (Kayin in Arabic means: knower)! “Brother” means that Hevel is not Cain’s servant, competitor, or resource. He is his responsibility to aid.

Cain is then educationally punished that he will no longer even rule over the land, but will wander, forced to experience himself what it means to be vulnerable and without protection. Cain complains: all animals can now kill me! G-d gives him a protective sign, teaching Cain and all “Bnei Adam”, demonstrating how leaders are supposed to care for the more vulnerable.

The immediate story of Cain’s descendent Lemech is accordingly understood: His children are credited with major human innovations: Yaval develops pastoral civilization, Yuval music, and Tuval-Cain metalworking. Especially Tuval-Cain’s mastery of bronze to create arrow-heads (displayed in all museums as the beginning of the Bronze Age), enabling the weaker (he’s the youngest) man to control even lions & elephants, older brothers and even parents, those who previously dominated them. This can be great for self-defense (as in the IDF), or conversely easily intensify the cycle of violence (Jihad). Worth noting, their names were probably originally Yaval, Yuval and Tuval (Benno Ya’akov: reminders of “Hevel”, the more refined/sensitive brother), but his invention of arrows apparently added his ancestor’s (and ideological predecessor’s) nickname: Tuval-CAIN.

Lemech’s wives are angry, but it’s not clear why? (Abarbanel termed as non-understandable, but now, bezH according to our theme, it makes sense:) Lemech protests that he “killed a man because he wounded me, a CHILD for my injury” (23). Apparently Tuval-Cain (their most logical child candidate to be the perpetrator, especially with his added nickname!) tried using his arrows to control his stronger/experienced father, and Lemech excuses: “I just killed him (even perhaps accidentally) in self-defense! He then invokes the protection granted to Cain: “If Cain shall be avenged sevenfold, then Lemech seventy-sevenfold,” for mine was just self-defense, not like Cain’s or Tuval-Cain’s exploiting of power.

In short, G-d’s, Adam’s, Eve’s, Cain’s and Tuval-Cains’s leadership, as political leadership of all “Bnei Adam”, and especially in Am Yisrael, “the Kingdom of Kohanim and Holy Nation”, is meant to altruistically help, benefit and aid the less powerful and more vulnerable subjects and citizens, the followers, not to exploit and gain power. This Imitateo Dei, copying G-d’s leadership of altruism, is clearly shown in Rav Kook’s signet stamp which sealed all of his letters: “Chief Rabbi, a servant to the Holy People on the Holy Land”. Yes. If you are a leader, older, stronger or wiser, you are your brother’s keeper. Shabbat Shalom!

Rav Ari Shvat (Chwat)

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *