Why Are Some Mixture Prohibitions Only Rabbinic for Noahides?

Written by

in

If Noahides are forbidden from crossbreeding animals, why do other kilayim-type laws not apply to them the same way?

Q. Actually Rav Ari, I have a question. If מפי קבלה Noachides are also forbidden to mix different breed of animals. How come other mixture related laws such as שטענז Shaatnez is not forbidden to them ? שבת שלום

Firstly, the Rambam, Aruch HaShulchan and Gra and the more accepted opinion is in fact that Bnei Noach are forbidden to mix different animals and vegetation (although the Ritva, Rosh and others disagree). This prohibition is based upon Breishit 1, 12, that G-d created each part of creation essentially “according to its kind”. But when a person takes 2 parts of that essential creation and simply weaves the 2 together as in sha’atnez, that is not a chemical or essential “changing” the way of creation like breeding does, which essentially and genetically/chemically makes a new and different creation.

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *