Author: Ari Shvat

  • Why Did Yechezkel Describe the Merkava?

    What’s the purpose behind Yechezkel’s vision of the Divine chariot?

    Q. One more question and that’s it why would Yechezkel talk of the merkava? what’s the point?

    The deeper meaning or “secrets” of the Torah and Judaism, are understood by those select students of kabbala, and it’s written for them to study in depth. In general, the basic idea that we can all understand, is that the nation of Israel is the chariot (=merkava) who’s role is to transport (=bring) G-dliness to each and every field of creation. This is as opposed to Jerusalem, which is called G-d’s throne, which is stationary and eternal, as opposed to Israel which is His chariot.

  • How Do We Relate to Disputes Like Reincarnation in Jewish Thought?

    When major authorities disagree on something as basic as reincarnation, how should a Jew navigate believing either side?

    Q. When there is a debate in Jewish thought, e.g. most opinions believe there is such a thing as reincarnation but the rambam and rav sadia gaon believe there isn’t ,is that a situation where it is elu velu or is one wrong?

    It’s a good example of “elu va’elu” (that both opinions are legitimate Torah opinions), e.g. before studying each one, we must say Birchat HaTorah. In the end, we’ll see who is correct (or both, for perhaps there is a certain amount of reincarnation in certain cases), but in the meantime, both give important Torah messages. On the one hand, even if a person makes terribly wrong and bad decisions, he can always get another chance, yet the main point is this world, and we shouldn’t “push off” that improvement and correction for “another life”, but do it today!

  • Observing Yom Tov as a Money Manager With Live Trades

    How does an Orthodox Jew in finance manage Yom Tov restrictions when markets keep moving without them?

    Q. How does one observe a Yom tov’s prohibitions if he is a money manager / stock market investor who must supervise and possibly trade investments on any day the market is open. Failure to do so could result in financial harm to yourself and others. Is it possible to do the bare minimum of work and still adhere to the halakha?

    There are thousands of orthodox Jews in such positions and apparently there is a way to divide the responsibilities so that gentile partners/workers fill that job on Yom Tov. You should consult with them. If you don’t know anyone like that, or if you are personally in the process of becoming observant, I suggest you speak to a local rabbi who knows you and can hear the entire situation, and direct you accordingly and properly.

  • Why Is the Talmud Bavli More Authoritative Than the Yerushalmi?

    Is the Babylonian Talmud’s greater authority just a historical accident, or does it rest on something more substantive?

    Q. Why is the Talmud Bavli more authoritative than the  Talmud Yerushalmi? I heard a rabbi who says that it is only for historical reasons that the Bavli is more prominent, not halachic reasons, so he has a problem with saying the Bavli is more authoritative.

    Being that the Bavli was compiled significantly later than the Yerushalmi, the Bavli is based upon the Yerushalmi and then they added significant improvements and clarifications. Accordingly, the Bavli is the basis for the rishonim and achronim, which inevitably made it the basis for the poskim (halachic authorities). On the other hand, where the Yerushalmi is clearer than the Bavli, many, like the Rambam, will prefer it over an “unclear” Bavli.

  • Does Moving Somewhere New Change Which Minhagim You Follow?

    If relocating theoretically shifts which customs apply, why do Ashkenazim and Sephardim keep their distinct minhagim anyway?

    Q. Does the halacha state that when one moves, he takes on the new minhagim instead of his old ones? If so, why should people keep Ashkenazi or Sefaradi minhagim in Israel since they are not in those lands anymore?

    That’s theoretically true, but we don’t yet have a Sanhedrin to decide which custom should be accepted by everyone “across the board”. Kibbutz Galuyot, the gathering of the exiles, by definition, demands addressing this question, and the Sanhedrin shoule be revived asap, but until then, we basically continue our previous customs, unless there is, as you inferred, a clear “Israeli custom”, e.g. finishing Arvit during the week with “Shomer Amo Yisrael La’ad” and omitting “Baruch Hashem l’Olam…” as was accepted in the diaspora; accepting Shabbat 24 minutes before sunset (not 18) except Y’rushalayim and Petach Tikva which do 40 minutes; obviously doing 1 day of Yom Tov; saying “Sim Shalom” instead of “Shalom Rav” at Shabbat Mincha, etc. Regarding pronunciation, in most places in Israel, the Sefaradic pronunciation has been accepted, unless in your shul there are many varied customs.

  • Can Public Prayer Be Used as a Form of Protest?

    Is it appropriate for Jews to hold a deliberately public prayer service as a form of protest?

    Q. Is it allowed when groups of Jews use prayer to protest something in public? Meaning we deliberately hold a public prayer service like shacharit in order to protest something. The event could actually lead to more fights. As much as I would want to do it, it seems wrong to use a prayer service to protest, whether people call it a protest or not, it’s exactly what it is.

    There is no black-and-white answer to such a question, and anyone organizing such an event must confer with rabbinic authorities who are also involved in communal or national leadership, to weigh all of the factors, benefits and drawbacks involved. In general, the Living-Torah sees protests, especially regarding our beloved and G-dly Jewish State and Land, when appropriate, not only as legitimate but obligatory and spiritual, just as prayer! In the words of the saintly R. Yisrael Salanter: “The physical needs of my Jewish brother/brethren are my spiritual needs!”.

  • How to Start Learning the Four Layers of Torah (“Pardes”)

    A practical starting point for approaching pshat, remez, drash, and sod, beyond just diving into Talmud and Zohar.

    Q. Shalom. I would like to study on the four layers of Torah (“Pardes”) how do I start and what text should I read apart from Talmud, Zohar and Midrash?

    As most serious topics, it’s logical to work your way up from the basics upward. I suggest starting with The Living Torah of Rabbi Aryeh Kaplan, and simultaneously learning basic Jewish halacha (Peninei Halacha of R. Eliezer Melamed has been translated into English) and philosophy (first Kuzari and then Rambam). Afterwards, as you wrote, the Talmud, Midrash and afterwards Kabbalah, which today is usually begun with Hassidut and Rav Kook (but R. Kaplan has some very good gateways into the Zohar as well). That’s in a nutshell.

  • Is Praying at the Graves of Tzaddikim Forbidden?

    The Rambam reportedly opposes it – so how do so many Jews maintain the widespread custom of praying at gravesites?

    Q. Is it forbidden to pray at the graves of tzadikim? I hear there is a prohibition by the Rambam. If so then how is it that so many Jews pray right on the graves? Literally leaning on it.

    There is a difference of opinion on this topic, and albeit the Rambam who opposes it, there are not a few sources in Chazal which mention the custom (e.g. Sotah 34b, that Calev prayed by the Ma’arat haMachpela in Hevron), and this is the generally accepted custom (some even explain the Rambam accordingly, as well!). The main point is not to pray TO the Tzadikim but rather to pray to Hashem to answer us in the merit of those Tzadikim. Even the Rambam himself (Hil. Ta’anit 4, 18) mentions the benefit and custom of praying by a cemetery, as a way to remember death and utilize it as a means to improve ourselves.

  • The Background of a Fast Called Over Current Events in Israel

    What’s the halachic basis for calling a fast day in response to a national crisis, and should one join it?

    Q. Hi Rav, I have heard some people talk about fasting tomorrow in light of events in Israel, what is the background to this and is it something I should do? Thanks

    When the Jewish nation is in trouble, we pray, add Tehilim and sometimes even fast. It’s called for Thur. because many have the custom of fasting before Rosh Chodesh, calling it Yom Kippur Katan, and when this comes out on Shabbat, it’s moved up to Thurs. This call comes from many leading rabbis but not from the Chief Rabbis, which would be more obligating. They wrote that if it’s difficult, to try fasting at least half the day until chatzot (halachic midday, whenever that comes out in your locale). Such voluntary fasts are very good, especially if they lead to strengthening one’s spirituality and character traits, unless it may harm one’s Torah study that day, or if one is a payed employee where the fast may be at the expense of one’s working properly, which is a monetary problem.

  • If G-d Knows Everything, Why Forbid Rather Than Just Warn?

    If Hashem already knows the outcome, why command a prohibition instead of simply calling something unhealthy?

    Q. If Hashem knows everything, why not just say that something is unhealthy or wrong, rather than forbidden?

    Man never understands the entire picture, but as we wrote previously, if the way of the entire world was to marry within the clan, the Torah prohibits that which is most unhealthy, but, in order to be relevant to the ancient world, had to allow something. So apparently G-d allowed that which is comparatively less harmful, otherwise people might have simply not listened at all, and would have married even closer relatives.