Is the Babylonian Talmud’s greater authority just a historical accident, or does it rest on something more substantive?
Q. Why is the Talmud Bavli more authoritative than the Talmud Yerushalmi? I heard a rabbi who says that it is only for historical reasons that the Bavli is more prominent, not halachic reasons, so he has a problem with saying the Bavli is more authoritative.
Being that the Bavli was compiled significantly later than the Yerushalmi, the Bavli is based upon the Yerushalmi and then they added significant improvements and clarifications. Accordingly, the Bavli is the basis for the rishonim and achronim, which inevitably made it the basis for the poskim (halachic authorities). On the other hand, where the Yerushalmi is clearer than the Bavli, many, like the Rambam, will prefer it over an “unclear” Bavli.
Leave a Reply