If the Sanhedrin already exists, what does a king add – and how does it differ from the Knesset HaGedola?
Q. 1. Why is there a commandment to have a king if we have a sanhedrin 2. is there a difference between the Sanhedrin and the Anshei Knesset Hagedolah?
The king is in charge of national issues, like today’s government, e.g. taxes, security, welfare etc., while the Sanhedrin decided on questions of halacha, monetary and religious issues, etc. In addition to the different fields of responsibility, there also was a “checks and balance” system of accountability between them, which also included the third “side” of the system, which was the navi/prophet who had a “direct line” to G-d. The Sanhedrin and Anshei Knesset HaGedola are one and the same, just in times where there were 71 members they’re called the Sanhedrin, but after the aliya of Ezra, when there were 120 members, they’re called by the longer name. There is an opinion which says that of the 120, 71 members were the Sanhedrin, who were the official halachic authorities, while the others were other types of leaders.
Leave a Reply