Category: Q&A

  • Why Does a Blessing for a Child Use the Mother’s Name?

    If Judaism is or isn’t a patriarchal system, why is the mother’s name specifically used when blessing a sick child?

    Q. G-d bless her. I have a question, why is the name of the mother preferred in blessing the child? Is it not a patriarchal system in Judaism as we recall Abraham as the first father of the nation?

    Judaism is not a patriarchal system, but there is importance of both the father and of the mother, e.g. even one’s Judaism is decided by their mother! In prayer for the sick we wish to particularly evoke mercy and emotion, by us and as if it were, by G-d, as well, and these are considered more feminine traits, so the way of the world is to turn to the more feminine aspect (e.g. Tehilim 116, 16, “Please, O Lord, for I am Your servant; I am Your servant the son of Your maidservant…”). Similarly, our rabbis teach that the prayers of women, who tend to be more emotional, are especially effective.

  • What Were the Rituals Around Temple-Era Sacrifice?

    What actually happened before and after an animal sacrifice in Temple times, and what did the altar itself signify?

    Q. In ancient times (at temple periods) what are the rituals followed before and after animal sacrifice ? What is the significance of “Altar” in connection with animal sacrifice? Do believers walk around “Altar” before animal sacrifice?

    Entire books have been written on this super-broad topic, including the music, the uniforms, the timing, the animals etc. etc. I can just summarize the general major actions around the alter itself: the slaughtering was close to the alter; receiving the blood had to be done by a Kohen; he would then walk it right to the alter; and then he would sprinkle some of the blood on the alter (different amounts sprinkled on various places on the alter, depending on which sacrifice is being given); different parts of the animal were burnt upon the alter, and others eaten by the Kohanim or the sacrifice-bringers their friends or family, depending on which sacrifice is being given. Everything connected with the alter is done by a Kohen (tribe of priests), not by the civilian from other tribes who may have brought the sacrifice.

  • Is the Pledge of Allegiance a Form of Idol Worship?

    Does reciting a national pledge to a flag cross into avoda zara for a Jew?

    Q. Is saying the pledge of allegiance in the U.S. at school to the flag idol worship?

    No, it’s not idol worship, but just like his religious allegiance, so too a Jew’s national allegience is really towards the nation and State of Israel, and you should always keep that in mind. In general the welfare of Israel and that of America are almost always intertwined and overlap, but should the US government change direction (e.g. Obama, Jonathan Pollard, Mamdani…), it’s important to keep your Jewish nationalism as your real top and eternal priority and allegiance. Jews have only been in America for several generations, and we know that all exiles out of the Land of Israel are by definition temporary, and there’s no reason to think America will be any different.

  • Did Man Bring Evil Into the World Through His Own Actions?

    Continuing the discussion: did darkness at creation already carry something like evil, or did man introduce it?

    Q. So can we say that man brought evil to the world through his actions? G-d created light but was the darkness not similar to evil and indirectly showered on this world? Were other animals unable to talk to Adam? Is the snake an evil entity that was created? Was evil created to balance the world?

    G-d created the possibility to choose evil, as part of man’s free-will (not so much to “balance the world”, but to enable man to have independent free-will, similar to G-d), so you can say that man brought it to the world through his actions. No, darkness sometimes is used to symbolize evil, but it’s not evil, but just the absence of light. As far as I know, other animals were not able to speak, except obviously the original snake. Being that G-d is not only good but perfect, no creation is essentially evil, including the snake.

  • Tikkun Soferim – Did the Text of the Torah Get Changed?

    Continuing the discussion: who actually made the “scribal adjustments” known as tikkun soferim, and what were they?

    Q. I saw that Ezra and the anshei Knesset hagedolah changed some of the torah it’s called tikkun soferim and I didn’t mean that rambam is alone in his opinion (I’m a big fan of rambam) just he’s the most popular in that belief.

    The Tanchuma you are referring to mentions the anshei Knesset haGedola (and not Ezra). Many opinions revolt from the term “editing”, but rather that the Torah itself worded those psukim respectfully. In short, it’s a machloket. By the way, it’s highly suggested not to learn Judaism (or any other topic) seriously through Wikipedia, for often, as in this case, they are not exact, and they are especially not bound nor guided by Jewish traditions. It’s suggested to use them as an aid, when necessary, to awaken or ask questions, but surely take what the masses write there with at least “a grain of salt”, and surely not as Torah-true nor always academically accurate.

  • Did the Rambam ‘Edit’ the Torah’s Language About G-d?

    Clarifying a claim that the Rambam changed Torah wording so people wouldn’t think G-d has a body.

    Q. What I meant was how can he edit the Torah and the reason as to why he edited it was because he didnt want people to think that hashem has a body.

    It’s totally incorrect to think that the Rambam is not mainstream here, but to the contrary: all (!) agree that Hashem has no body, just the question is what is the punishment of one who disagrees, and also, how to explain certain midrashim, which, as most midrashim, are not meant to be taken literally, but what is the symbolism they mean to teach? It’s good advice, that before citing “maverick” opinions which in fact sound out of the ordinary, first ask about them, one at a time, rather than basing additional questions upon them. Thank you.

  • Which Sins Cost a Person Their Share in Olam Haba?

    What’s the actual list of transgressions the Rambam identifies as forfeiting one’s portion in the World to Come?

    Q. What concludes the list of people or Aveiros that a person does that they lose their portion in Olam Haba?

    See the Rambam at the following link, Hilchot Teshuva 3, 5-14: https://www.chabad.org/library/article_cdo/aid/911896/jewish/Teshuvah-Chapter-Three.htm who lists the 24 people who have no share in the world to come, but the most important is that which he writes at the end: that no matter what you did, if you sincerely regret it and resolve not to repeat it (as well as apologizing to one who was hurt), than you do have a share in Olam HaBa.

  • Why Is Rosh HaShana Two Days in Israel but Not just a Yom Tov Sheni?

    With no Sanhedrin to sanctify the new moon by testimony, why does Rosh Chodesh still sometimes run two days even in Israel?

    Q. B”H Shalom, why is it that Rosh HaShana is performed two days b’Aretz, but not as Yom Tov Shnei Shel Galuyot?  Toda raba in advance 🌷

    Because when the Sanhedrin declared the New Moon by hearing witnesses who saw it, they then sent messengers to notify the people that Rosh Chodesh was declared on this day or the next. By the holidays which fall in the middle of the month, it was no problem for the notifying messengers to reach even the furthest borders of Eretz Yisrael. But on Rosh Chodesh and Rosh HaShana, which are immediately at the beginning of the month, there was no way the messengers could get to notify everyone on time. In order to avoid confusion, we always observe 2 days on Rosh HaShana.

  • Is Belief in Hashem Counted as the First Mitzvah?

    Some list emunah in G-d as the very first of the 613 – is that actually accurate, and why might it not be a ‘mitzvah’ in the usual sense?

    Hello Rabbi, some count the first mitzva in their sifrei mitzvos as belief in Hashem. R. Hasdai Cresskas gives a really good reason why this incorrect, ie that to follow the command to believe in Hashem was given by Hashem, but to follow that command you have to already believe in Hashem. Or something along the lines. His point is that it is a loop. So my question is, what do the halakhists (like the Rambam) who hold this is a mitzva, what would they respond to Hassan Cressas? Answer: The Rambam writes explicitly, in order to answer your question, that the commandment is not to believe (for that person already believes, and if not, it doesn’t help to command him!), but to bring others (!) to believe. That’s also why the Shema Yisrael, is not worded as a declaration that I believe, but is literally a call to others to believe (“Listen Israel/Jews our G-d is One”). That’s why the Rambam, in that first mitzva, uses the word in Hebrew l’ha’amin (to get others to believe) and not l’amin (to believe), for if you really believe in G-d as the ultimate truth, you’ll want to get others to believe in Him as well. Lehavdil, it’s like on election day, that to vote for a candidate shows support (or non-support for his rival!), but if I really believe in a candidate, I will even join his election committee to convince others to vote for him, as well. Similarly, it hurts us when others curse our parents, for if I love them, I want others to love them as well.

  • What Does It Mean That G-d Divided the Waters?

    How should we understand Bereshit’s description of G-d separating the waters at creation?

    Q. What does it mean that G-d divided the waters in Bereshit? I imagine in the beginning there only being water (imagine space being all water), then G-d creating Earth caused the water to separate (Earth is a ball of air within space). Could space be all water?

    Your questions regarding the creation are very difficult to answer for we weren’t there. Yes, the Torah reveals partially what happened, yet the Talmud says that the Oral Traditions regarding creation, are passed down only to a selected few, of which, at least I and everyone I know, are not among them. Just about every other aspect of Torah is understandable to all, so we are all much better off dealing with them, and that’s what is done by almost all those who study Torah throughout the generations.