Some list emunah in G-d as the very first of the 613 – is that actually accurate, and why might it not be a ‘mitzvah’ in the usual sense?
Hello Rabbi, some count the first mitzva in their sifrei mitzvos as belief in Hashem. R. Hasdai Cresskas gives a really good reason why this incorrect, ie that to follow the command to believe in Hashem was given by Hashem, but to follow that command you have to already believe in Hashem. Or something along the lines. His point is that it is a loop. So my question is, what do the halakhists (like the Rambam) who hold this is a mitzva, what would they respond to Hassan Cressas? Answer: The Rambam writes explicitly, in order to answer your question, that the commandment is not to believe (for that person already believes, and if not, it doesn’t help to command him!), but to bring others (!) to believe. That’s also why the Shema Yisrael, is not worded as a declaration that I believe, but is literally a call to others to believe (“Listen Israel/Jews our G-d is One”). That’s why the Rambam, in that first mitzva, uses the word in Hebrew l’ha’amin (to get others to believe) and not l’amin (to believe), for if you really believe in G-d as the ultimate truth, you’ll want to get others to believe in Him as well. Lehavdil, it’s like on election day, that to vote for a candidate shows support (or non-support for his rival!), but if I really believe in a candidate, I will even join his election committee to convince others to vote for him, as well. Similarly, it hurts us when others curse our parents, for if I love them, I want others to love them as well.
Leave a Reply