Tracing the Neturei Karta / Satmar source about Jewish sovereignty back to its actual origin, and what it does and doesn’t say.
Q. In the wake of events that began a few months ago I’ve been doing a deep dive on the psychology of antisemitism. I found a speech by neturai karta a few years back and in the speech they mention that the Torah states “it is a basic part of our belief to accept willingly the decree of exile and not to try and fight against it or to end it by our own hands.” My curiosity and question is what is the Torah source of such a commandment? Is it in the gemara rather?
The source of the Satmar Rebbe is not in the Torah, but an aggadita [=legend] in the gemara in Ketuvot 111a, and one must know firstly, the rule is, that one doesn’t learn halacha regarding aggadita (Rambam, Moreh N’vuchim end of intro.; Nodeh B’Yehuda, Y.D. 161), simply because it’s not meant to be taken literally. The legend (aggadita) there is not halachic, but a story with a moral, and it’s application to Zionism is one particular extrapolation of the Satmar and Neturei Karta, but there are many other alternative explanations there as well. It says there that upon going to exile we “promised” not to rebel against the gentile nations, and not to “rise up on the wall”, and the gentiles swore that they won’t oppress us too much. Rashi explains that not to “rise up on the wall” means that we promised not to rise up as one and take the Land of Israel by force before it’s time. The Satmar rebbe considers this an anti-Zionist source, but there are many reasons why almost all rabbis disagree with him on this. R. Shlomo Aviner compiled a very comprehensive booklet on the topic (I believe it’s reprinted in his She’elat Shlomo), including 13 answers why all mainstream poskim, from the rishonim through the Shulchan Aruch and until today, disagree with the Satmar. For example: 1. Not only is it not cited by the halachic authorities, but to the contrary, they bring that it’s a mitzvah to make aliya and to conquer the Land of Israel in all generations (Pitchei Teshuva Ev. H. 75, 6) and so replies the Avnei Nezer to the Satmar Rebbe’s claim. The Rambam (Hil. Mlachim 11, 2) who brings the Bar Kochba rebellion supported by R. Akiva and “all of the sages of his time”, as the prototype for the way of the rise of mashiach, clearly feels that the oaths are not halachic, for they precisely rebelled against the Romans and tried taking the Land by force. Another proof is that the gmara in Yoma 9b, contradicts that agadita and says that we davka must (!) “rise up as a wall”, and that we were even punished for not doing so in the time of Ezra, to build the 2nd Temple. If that’s not enough, see Shir HaShirim Rabba 8, 9 (3), where R. Zeira, the author of the aforementioned “three oaths” in Ktuvot, changes his mind explicitly, and adopts the contradicting opinion mentioned in Yoma! 2. Many cite Rav Meir Simcha of Dvinsk (the famed Meshech Chochma and author of the Or Same’ach), in his letter to the Keren Hayesod where he simply dismisses the oaths as aggada, and stresses, especially after the Balfour Decleration in 1917, ratified internationally in San Remo, where the nations of the world officially recognized the right of the Jews to establish a national homeland in Palestine, “it removes all ‘fear’ of those oaths”. We already mentioned that Rashi explained not to take the land by force, but once the nations gave us permission, it’s obviously no problem. 3. That Rashi, the source of the Satmar’s understanding, stresses that it’s only a problem if the Jews come all at once, but in actuality, we have been coming gradually over the last century, and the process is still underway. 4. The famed R. Shlomo Kluger explains that if the gentiles don’t observe their oath, we are exempt from ours. Nobody who learned about the Holocaust can take the gentile’s oath seriously, as if they didn’t “oppress us too much”, so we clearly are no longer obligated by our oath, and it is no longer “before its time”. 5. The Vilna Gaon explains that not to “rise up on the wall” means we swore not to rebuild the walls of Yrushalayim and the Beit haMikdash, and it has nothing to do with declaring a state. 6. Rav Soloveichik in his article Kol Dodi Dofek explains that G-d is clearly calling us back to the Land of Israel, and that’s how we know that it’s no longer “before its time”. The Holocaust and assimilation forced us back to Israel, including even many anti-zionists, whether they liked it or not, had no choice but to make aliya, and then fight in self-defense from the invading Arab armies in the subsequent wars. We clearly are not allowed to let them kill us, as pikuach nefesh overrides everything. According to many statisticians, today, most Jews in the world already live in Israel, for the first time in almost 3,000 years, since the exile of the 10 tribes. Already, about 70% of orthodox Jews live here, and it’s the Torah center and the Gedolei hador all live here. It’s already clear, the Jewish future is in Israel. In addition, Midrash Tanchuma (Shoftim 10) tells us that once we return for the third time, with 600,000 Jews (Yalkut Shimoni 1038), there will not be another exile. Being that there are more than 10 times (!) that amount today in Israel, we are clearly back to stay, and this is the third and final return. The Talmud doesn’t say anything about waiting for mashiach, but to wait until “its time”. G-d’s running of history has clearly taught us, that it’s time to come home. 7. Rav Ya’akov Moshe Charlap (Memaynai HaYshua, p. 245), former rav of Sha’arei Chessed and a major student of Rav Kook, explains that the moral or idea of the aggada was to stress that the national revival of Israel is actually an international event and of universal, not just national, importance. We therefore prefer for the return to Israel to be in cooperation and supported by the other nations, as it was in the time of Cyrus of Persia, who supported the building of the 2nd Beit haMikdash. That’s what the Balfour Declaration and the United Nations decision were all about. In short, someone looking for an excuse not to make Aliya, must look elsewhere!