Category: Q&A

  • Olam Haba vs. the Messianic Age – What’s the Difference?

    Are the World to Come and the Messianic era the same thing, and what makes someone righteous enough to merit either?

    Q. Please Rabbi Is olam haba different from the messainic age. Who is a righteous person?

    Yes, Olam HaBa is the world to come, a world of souls, where the soul goes when it leaves the body after death in this world. On the other hand, the messianic age is in this world, when the Jewish people return from the exiles, the barren Land of Israel flourishes, we have a Jewish State, Jewish army, strengthen ourselves religiously, eventually rebuild the Temple in Jerusalem and the Messiah from the lineage of King David will come, etc. In fact, the process has been well underway for the past 100 years already, with most of the prophecies of redemption already coming true.

  • Was Sarah Right to Expel Hagar and Yishmael?

    Sarah’s request to send away Hagar and Yishmael looks harsh on its face – how do the sources actually judge it?

    Q. In parashat Vayera we see that Sarah asked Gd to expel Hagar and Ishmael so that Ishmael doesn’t inherit together with Itzhak. this seems like a bad thing to do in my opinion. what is the explanation? wasn’t it mean of Sarah to do so? even if Ishmael isn’t her son, she herself wanted Avraham to marry Hagar… it seems out of character for her to do such a harsh thing

    In fact there are midrashim which seem to criticize Sara. On the other hand, by this stage Yishmael is already making problems and fighting with Yitzchak, where a 13 year difference between fighting children is really a lot, and a problematic difference. Also remember that these are not just children, but Sara & Avraham already know that they are to be the future heads of nations, Yitzchak who will be the father of the Chosen People, and Yishmael who will be his nemesis! Nevertheless, Avraham also felt that it wasn’t right to expel them, until G-d told him that he should listen to Sara, for in this case, it’s the right thing to do, to insure Yitzchak’s proper education and clarify that only he will be Avraham’s spiritual & national continuation.

  • Would People Have Listened If Child Sacrifice Were Merely Discouraged?

    Continuing a discussion on why the Torah had to outright forbid, not just discourage, practices like child sacrifice.

    Q. So what if people wouldn’t do it, the religious would listen and also so what if it’s the normal thing people thought that back then child sacrifice was ok they’re both immoral not by today’s standards but by the children have birth defects

    The Torah is written for all and not just for individual religious people, who were around also before the Torah was given. Just like the Torah clearly prefers us not to eat meat, but b’dieved allows us, but nevertheless teaches us what is the ideal, so that we know towards what to strive and educate, until we eventually return to that level of Adam and Gan Eden. G-d knows exactly what to prohibit in His eternal Torah, and what would have been asking too much from primitive man in a primitive world.

  • What to Do When the Yetzer Hara Feels Fully in Control

    Practical guidance for someone who feels their negative inclination has completely overtaken their better judgment.

    Q. Also, what does one do if they find themselves (G’d forbid) where the Yetzer Hara completely controls the Yetzer Hatov. How does one get out of that?

    We believe very strongly in free-will, that you destine and are the one who decides your fate. When one avoids the negative aspects of social media and the internet (through the readily available filters), doesn’t over-indulge, but also doesn’t sit idly letting his mind wander, but rather is pro-active in good deeds, in active Torah study (with a study partner), in good healthy work and exercise, he will have a “healthy soul in a healthy body”. In short, “leave the problematic and (get busy to) do good”.

  • A Curious Diplomat Asks About Rumor that Jews were “Cannibals”!

    A Conservative convert working in diplomacy asks how Ezekiel’s Gog and Magog prophecy should really be read.

    Q. Shalom! Thank you for allowing my question here. I converted to judaism the conservative way about 20 years ago. I am in the German diplomatic service. My wife is Israeli and we have three kids. Shocked by the aftermath of oct 7th, I follow the rise, or better the increased visibility of antisemitism in Germany closely. 2 weeks ago the Jewish historian Prof. Dr. Michael Wolffsohn was holding a speech at the Berlin Parliament (not federal). It was an extensive speech and he mentioned Voltaire as a known anti-Semite. I was intrigued and researched a bit. Especially repulsing was the claim, that Jews practiced cannibalism. He based that loosely on Leviticus (Wajjiqra). I checked further and Voltaire seems to be referring to Lev. 27.29 and Ezekiel 39. I think the Ezekiel reference we can debunk rather quickly. In 39-17 it is clear, that not the Jews are eating their enemies, rather the called birds and wild animals. Correct? The Leviticus reference is more complicated. In 27.1-7 there seems to be some value for people given. It took me a while to find some interpretation. It seems to condemn those who vow their relatives in vain to god, to pay for those deeds. That gets clear in 27.8 since the settlement in a monetary solution seems to be a given. Is that a view you would support? 27.29 doesn’t make sense in this context though… Some commentary refers to the sworn enemies of the Jews in that regard, but I don’t see the connection. Ok – you can’t pay ransom for those sworn enemies. That I understand, but are they vowed to god? Why is there no word of it in the context of lev.27? Aside from my theological need of clarification I come to the conclusion that this Voltaire character was surely a pioneer in the age of enlightenment and that in itself brought some respite for the Jews in Europe in this time of nationalistic movements. Yet whatever excuses you find for his anti-Semitism, is just wrong. This cannibalism is only one of his rantings… He simply was an anti-Semite and not to point that out on every occasion, justifies and makes anti-Semitic public positions today socially acceptable. Very similar to Martin Luther btw. In Germany there was in 2017 the 500 year Anniversary of his achievements. Also then, most public speeches and displays completely skipped his late years of anti Semitic rantings… big mistake in my view. am yisrael chai! every jew has to fight for israel on his front. I try to do my part…

    Interesting questions which simply attest to Voltaire’s creative imaginary skills! The verses in Yechezkel (Ezekiel 39) are clearly poetic and satiric, that instead of us sacrificing animals to G-d (which was the norm in that period, about 2,700 years ago in the ancient Temple in Jerusalem and in most religions of the period), as if it were He (G-d) “sacrifices” the arrogant enemies of Israel and davka the birds and wild animals (as you correctly understood) shall eat their remains, doing to them what they wanted to do to Israel. Leviticus 27 at first refers to how much a person donates to the Temple when he swears to donate his worth (see verses 2 and 8). There is an entire Talmudic tractate called Masechet Erchin, on this topic. This was not an uncommon practice when a person wanted to implore G-d, say to save him from a certain danger, by “redeeming” his (or his loved one’s, or even his house’s) worth. You are correct that verse 28 says explicitly that it refers to a little different case where it’s not a regular vow but a “cherem”, i.e. designating the object itself (not its monetary worth) to the Temple or Kohanim (priests). Regarding the “person” mentioned there, it obviously refers to his Canaanite slave, for the chapter relates to one’s possessions, which (as opposed to other cultures at the time who said that men owned their wives, children and all slaves) only applied to Canaanite slaves. In this said case, the person swore to give this Canaanite slave to the Kohanim to work for them. Verse 29 is a third case, relatively rare, where the nation, or her representatives in the government or religious court, declare that a regular person did an extremely offensive, treacherous or disloyal act, which deserves to be put to death. A regular death penalty was relatively rare even in ancient Israel (some say just once in 70 years!) for it had to pass exceedingly demanding, technical and vigorous conditions of premeditated proof, previous religious warning by extremely knowledgeable witnesses who coincidentally happened to be there, etc.. But should that person think that maybe he can “redeem” himself monetarily in order to get free, comes the Torah and answers, no, we cannot be deceived to fall for that “trick”. Anyone who doesn’t understand the poetic style of the prophets like Yechezkel, should stay away from them, so as not to embarrass himself by suggesting the absurd! Anyone with even a minimal knowledge of Judaism knows that we will not eat even a drop of chicken’s blood which we may find in an egg, so how can one be so ignorant as to suggest that we eat humans or “use their blood for matzoh”?!! This just shows that you can’t look for logic when it comes to anti-Semitism. Accordingly, in general it’s a waste of time speaking to anti-Semites, but we do owe it to the objective and ignorant to explain what the Book of Books really meant, and why the People of the Book are generally respected by anyone objective. To a certain extent, it’s anachronistic to assume that Voltaire studied Judaism properly, and even if intelligent, either he assumed the mistaken boorish misconceptions of his anti-Semitic surroundings as fact, or his creative imagination got the better of him! Today on the other hand, it’s easy enough to “Google” such basic information about the Jews and Judaism, so anti-Semites today really have no excuse, but basically attest to their own lack of intellectual honesty and crude hate. Anyone siding with Hamas against Israel attests to his own immoral hate, boorish lack of knowledge and even laziness for not bothering to check the readily available facts, especially those filmed and presented proudly by the Hamas murderers themselves!

  • What Is the World to Come Like for Women?

    If men’s reward is pictured as learning Torah eternally, what is the parallel vision of Olam Haba for women?

    Q. I have a question, what is the promised heaven for women? I know guys study Torah with השם, bus since women don’t study Torah, what is their heaven ?

    The Talmud teaches that the tzadikim (men and women) sit together in the world to come and “enjoy the pleasure of the Shchina” (=G-dly presence). Sometimes this is likened to learning Torah but it’s more intensive, the pleasure of being with the ultimate and eternal pleasure. Today, when women also study Torah on a high level, they can also get some kind of taste of this spiritual pleasure already in this world, just as when we pray properly with fervor and concentration, which is also a taste of that eternal spiritual pleasure, as is Shabbat, in general.

  • Why Does Hashem Forbid Mixing Meat and Milk?

    What reasoning, if any, is offered for the prohibition on cooking meat together with milk?

    Q. Hi, what is the reason that HASHEM forbid cooking/eating Meat with Milk !?

    As all of the Torah commandments, we cannot know exactly why G-d commands them. We can just analyze some of the benefits which result from them. One of these benefits or teachings, according to Rav Kook, is that milk is really meant for the cow’s calves, but nevertheless, the Torah directs that man’s needs supersede those of animals, so it’s allowed. Similarly, for the same reason, we are permitted to eat meat (begrudgingly allowed only after the Flood of Noach), for man needs it. But to eat, cook or benefit from both allowances (meat and milk) together, is already too much, and we are taught to contain ourselves and not overdo the allowance, for the sake of the animals’ needs.

  • Guidance on Hitbonenut and Praying With Real Kavana

    Looking for a practical guide to the meditative Chassidic practice of hitbonenut, to bring real awe and love into prayer.

    Q. Is there a guide on Hitbonenut (similar to meditation) and praying with Kavanah as described a lot in Lessons in Tanya (so that I can feel real Yirah-awe and Ahavah-love in davening/prayer)?

    These are very important concepts and no rabbi belittles them whatsoever! Concentration (Kavana) is the essence of prayer and accordingly, your desire to improve it is fantastic. From personal experience with my students, the best way is for you to sit down, think for yourself and write down 15 practical ways for you to improve your kavana, and then implement them, one at a time, during 1 week, and then implement another one. The challenge is how to keep one’s prayer exciting and “fresh”, so to keep changing these implementations are very helpful. For example: listening to a song or Hassidic story before praying; praying while watching a beautiful sunset/sunrise; singing the prayers; saying the words slowly; alternatively, saying each word quickly (but with concentration) so that your mind doesn’t have time to wander; turn off your cell-phone; leave yourself enough time to pray properly, listening to an inspiring class before prayer, etc. etc. This strive for improvement must continue for the rest of your life, so as not to ever take for granted our pleasure of speaking with the Almighty. All the best!

  • Do Demons Exist, and What If You Encounter a “Possessed” Person?

    Does Jewish tradition take the existence of demons seriously, and what should one do if they meet someone “possessed”?

    Q. Shalom, do demons exist? and what we do if we met someone “possessed”?

    Demons, devils, angels (the Hebrew literally means: messenger), and satan (the Hebrew literally means: stumbling-block), like all creatures except man, have no free will, are not autonomous, and accordingly don’t have mitzvot, nor reward or punishment, heaven or hell or resurrection. They are simply “messengers” sent by G-d to do certain tasks, and just follow their “program”. They are sometimes seen and sometimes not, but definitely don’t have “wings” or pitchforks like in the Christian drawings, and in general are not central nor secondary or even tertiary in Judaism (just about the only people who ever ask about them are those who were raised among Christians)! “Satan” is another name for the “evil inclination” inside each one of us (Bava Batra 16a), and his role in Job is symbolic and literary (many posit that the entire Book of Job is an allegory, ibid, 15a). Accordingly, germs can also be considered “messengers” programmed to serve a certain purpose. If you meet someone who is “possessed”, you should probably send him to a psychologist.

  • Are Ashkenazi Jews Really Descended from the Hebrews?

    Does the claim that Ashkenazim are mostly white and Turkish in origin hold up?

    Q. So does this mean ashkenazi Jews aren’t really Hebrews and mostly white/Turkish?

    G-d forbid, that is a terrible mistake (generally consciously spread by anti-Semites who want to give the Land of Israel to others for political reasons)!!! Anyone who converted and joined the people of Israel and the Jewish religion at any stage in Jewish history, is 100% Jewish/Hebrew, and we don’t care what color he was or is!! But the question asked, was a technical one, what color were our Jewish fore-fathers, and being that we have an unbroken line of 3,300 years or 131 generations of Jewish tradition, we still know these facts, that they were brownish (to this day, many Ashkenazic Jews are darker than regular Caucasians).