Category: Q&A

  • What is Hell?

    Is hell a real place people go after they die? How do I prevent myself from going there?

    The most important thing is to be a good “Godly” person, and not just to act properly in order to get reward or avoid punishment, whether in this world or the world-to-come. Nevertheless, if you’re curious, we have many traditions passed down regarding the world-to-come, Gan Eden (heaven) and “gehinom” (hell). According to all, it’s not a physical place (as other religions may think), but a spiritual one, without bodies, just souls, who come to be perfected or educated in a way they didn’t succeed to do so in this world, the world of free-will. The rabbis picture the world-to-come, like what we would call today a movie theater where video-clips of one’s life are played for each of us, and we get pleasure from our positive acts and are “burning” with embarrassment from our regrettable choices (played simultaneously with what we could have and should have chosen at the time). In that unadulterated world, we can get a deeper and objective understanding of right and wrong, good and bad.
    According to a Chassidic tradition, heaven and hell are really the same place (logical, for in a world where there’s no “place”, we’re all in the same “place”!), just that for one person it’s paradise, and for the other, it’s “boring as hell”. Our soul doesn’t change when we die, but continues exactly as the person we were when we “left off” at the time of death. For someone whose definition of fun is their car, internet, money, computer and smart-phone, when he gets to the world-to-come it’s clearly going to be super-boring, because there is none of the above! On the other hand, somebody who gets pleasure from goodness, Torah study, ideological thought and discussion, love and spirituality- for him that place is Heaven, for he can get constant spiritual pleasure, without worldly distractions like needing to work or sleep, with no disturbances like sickness or pain. A good way to test yourself to see which category you belong to, is to ask yourself honestly: Do I enjoy Shabbat (which is considered a taste of the world-to-come, and where many of the aforementioned pleasures are in fact prohibited) or not? Do I have independent pleasure being with myself (my Godly soul), or do I need outside stimulants and distractions to entertain me? It’s important to stress, that it’s not too late to improve yourself in these fields, to become the type of person you would like to be.
    We don’t know exactly how it will be until we get there, nevertheless, like everything in life, we should utilize these ideas to motivate us towards self-improvement and being better people in this world. With Love of Israel,
    Rav Ari Shvat

  • “Outdated” Mitzvot?

    Dear Rabbi, I received a lengthy e-mail written by a cynical professor who asked questions about the Torah which sometimes appears to be outdated, and would like some answers to fulfill the writings of the ethics of the fathers:ודע מה שתשיב לאפיקורוס ולקדש שם שמים, “know how to answer”. Thank you!

    The issue regarding mitzvot which seem to be outdated, is an old question. In fact, the t’filin found by archeologists at Massada from 2,000 years ago, were not “in style” or seen as “up-to-date” in the gentile world, then either! Were it not for the G-dly commandment, we wouldn’t have dreamt ourselves of wearing these black boxes and straps, even then! The eternal mitzvot are, by definition, above time. In fact, many of the most popular mitzvot today among newly observant intellectual Jews, are those which at first glance, seem outdated. Only after you begin to observe, you’re amazed at the beauty, logic and benefit of these eternal truths. Davka the example which the cynical professor gave of physically separating during the menstrual period, is a classic case in point (many secular couples I’ve married have adopted that, some even eventually becoming totally observant).
    Regarding the mitzvot which seem to contradict modern morality, we must remember that “eternity” means not only that the Torah must apply to the modern world, but also the reverse: that it had to be relevant 3,300 years ago, as well! In a both morally and technically primitive world, before the cotton gin and tractor, whose economy was based upon agriculture and slaves, slavery was not seen by anyone as a moral problem at the time of the giving of the Torah. In a period where it was legal among gentiles to kill one’s slave, in order to be relevant and slowly raise the level of their primitive morality, the most the Torah could, and did command, was to treat slaves in a relatively high and honorable way. Our rabbis summarize those laws, that “He who bought a slave, has acquired a master for himself”. It was davka a result of these laws that mankind (first Judaism, and then Christianity, and eventually the entire modern world), slowly but surely began to see slavery in a negative light, until its eventual abolishment in most countries. The Torah doesn’t obligate slavery, yet begrudgingly allowed it, when it was necessary and morally accepted and economically necessary, within exacting moral constrictions.
    A good analogy is that it would be an exaggerated demand for the Torah to prohibit eating meat even today, although it’s clearly more moral to be a vegetarian. The many “hints” to this affect (e.g. slaughtering painlessly, many detailed halachot which define the prohibition to hurt animals, not making a “shehecheyanu” bracha or even saying “titchadesh” on leather…) slowly and eventually raise mankind until we will be abhorred with the concept, and will voluntarily mature to be vegetarians, returning to the pre-Noah ideal. The Torah obligates only the minimum, and to “jump the gun” and “over-obligate” morality before its proper time, would be artificial, irrelevant and accordingly, counterproductive. In consequent generations, the rabbis and mankind are meant to continuously add additional obligations, at the pace of advancement of mankind, continuing the direction of the “arrow” which the Torah “shot” long ago.
    In addition, we must remember that the same G-d who created our moral “conscience”, is the same One who gave us the Torah, and is the same One who also slowly guides history. In the example of vegetarianism, the “historical” G-d reveals, at the appropriate time, modern technology (e.g. inventing meat-substitutes, refrigeration…), dietetics (encouraging vegetarianism), hygiene (we are more and more disgusted by blood…), military weapons (wars fought today from afar, by pushing buttons, make us more sensitive and squeamish regarding any killing), and even internet and transportation (enabling universal NGO’s to function and publicize their humanist and animal-loving agendas), etc. So too, that same “historical” G-d “vanished” Amelek naturally, because that’s not the obligation which should be pre-occupying us at this stage of mankind! Similarly, explains Rav Kook, it’s not a coincidence that we don’t have the death-penalty or animal sacrifice today, because it’s not in our best moral interest at this time. Accordingly, G-d removed these topics from the practical agenda, through technical, halachic and historical obstacles.
    In addition, the oral law which is “built in” to the essence of the written law (Dvarim 17), is exactly for this purpose, obligating rabbis to explain mitzvot and make them relevant in each and every respective generation. More than 1,000 years ago, the rabbis basically abolished yibum, and today, the G-d of “history” made even chalitza essentially obsolete (currently, couples don’t marry unless they want children, modern methods of fertility can solve 95% of the problems, and men don’t die as young as they used to). Nevertheless, if by chance, there is ever any mitzvah which may truly seem “out-of-date”, the Sanhedrin (Supreme Rabbinical Court) is almost always empowered to alter it, either temporarily or long-range. If Israel has already returned to the Land, revived our State, language, and army, then reviving the Sanhedrin should be relatively easy. For more elaboration, see my 2 lectures on this topic on this blog.
    With Love of Israel, Rabbi Ari Shvat

  • Secular newspapers and their pictures

    Rabbi,I have a problem. I enjoy knowing what’s going on in the world and in Israel. That’s why I read ’Yisroel hayom' and simular newspapers.Unfortunately,I quite often come across inappropriate images of women. Does the fact that there are such pictures forebid me from reading these papers?After all my intention is to read the news and not to see these stuyot?Thanks for your time.

    Shalom,
    It’s definitely important to know what’s going on with Am Yisrael, especially because we’re in the center of the world news so often, and we must know what we can do to help (e.g. if there’s danger of war, if we should apply political pressure on the Prime Minister of Israel or President of the U.S., or volunteering to look for a missing child, donating money or clothing, if there’s a fire, etc.), and also what to daven (pray) for. For this reason, the Netziv and many other rabbanim regularly read news journals. On the other hand, one isn’t allowed to do a mitzvah through doing something wrong (“mitzvah haba’a al y’dei aveira”). Even if you are accustomed to looking away when seeing immodest dress in the street, it’s almost impossible to avoid when your task at hand is to purposely look at the paper. In addition, the editors and advertisers deliberately choose especially attractive and provocative pictures, so it’s even more problematic. Listening to the radio news is one solution. Even better, thank G-d, today there are religious or kosher radio stations, websites and newspapers like Arutz Sheva and Makor Rishon, which are fine in this regard, and hopefully also regarding lashon hara (slandering), which is no less problematic, often even more (here, the radio doesn't help, except for its brevity!). Regarding the laws of lashon hara and the news, see my article “Newspapers and Reporting- Mitzva or Prohibition?”, which can be found through Google.
    With Love of Israel,
    Rav Ari Shvat

  • Woman as business partner

    Is there any halachic/hashkafic parameter that prevents a married man from starting a new business with a single women. The pair would have to work closely for long hours and would share experiences of accomplishment, success and failure throughout their working relationship. This seems inappropriate to me but I was wondering if I am over-reacting.

    Without a doubt, it is clearly wrong, both hashkafa and halacha-wise, for any man, especially a married one, to have a close relationship with a woman, other than his wife. The Shulchan Aruch states explicitly: “one must distance himself from women very, very much!” (Even HaEzer 21, 1), and working alone, side by side in a pleasant and friendly atmosphere (as a work-environment should be), is clearly not “distancing”, and surely not “very, very much”. This is not just a suggestion for a happy marriage, but an actual prohibition. Even working alone together with a female secretary for long hours, is a problem (even if they are careful in observing the laws of yichud, never to be alone in a room, just a man and a woman, if there’s no probability of somebody else entering by surprise), so how much more so, one shouldn’t have a partnership as equals, working closely for many hours. Inevitably, part of that special man-woman relationship and chemistry, the joking, laughing and unique friendship which should be totally reserved for one’s soul-mate, will be “spent” on another, “competing” woman, and will undoubtedly come at the expense of his spouse. In fact, I heard from someone close to the police department, that they have a problem dealing with many “affairs” which arose out of having a man and woman on duty together, sometimes, when at least one of them was married.
    A happy marriage and healthy family life, is a lot more important than making money, especially when there are many kosher ways of making a living, like finding a male business partner. May the zchut of shalom bayit grant you parnassa tova in the best possible way!
    With Love of Israel,
    Rav Ari Shvat

  • Rav Kook/three oaths

    Hi
    I’ve been researching the three oaths.. and would like to know Rav Kook’s opinion of them? Thank You
    If it is too long to write it will be useful if you could direct me to a link

    Shalom Michael,
    Rav A.Y. Kook dealt briefly with the “three oaths”, in Otzrot HaReIya, II, ch. 37 in his article regarding the re-founding of the Sanhedrin, and wrote 19 years before the Balfour Declaration, that we will receive permission from the nations of the world, like we did in the time of Koresh (Cyrus), to build the second Beit HaMikdash, and that will “solve” the problem of the oaths. His son, Rav Zvi Yehuda Kook writes about them in L’N’tivot Yisrael II, p. 115-116, and it’s common knowledge that almost everything he taught or wrote is in agreement with his father. It’s even brought in Tov Ro’ee on Ktuvot there, which is supposed to be the chidushim of Rav Kook, senior. I imagine you have seen Rav Shlomo Aviner’s very comprehensive booklet on the
    topic (it’s reprinted in his Responsa She’elat Shlomo), including some 13 answers to the Satmar Rebbe, and Rav Moshe Tzuriel wrote a kuntres on the topic, as well. I might add that the Rambam (Hil. Mlachim 11, 2) who brings the Bar Kochba rebellion supported by R. Akiva and his many students as the prototype for the way of the rise of mashiach, clearly feels that the oaths are not halachic. Many cite Rav Meir Simcha of Dvinsk, the Meshech
    Chochma and Or Same’ach, in his letter to the Keren Hayesod where he simply dismisses the oaths as aggada, and especially after the Balfour Decleration ratified internationally in San Remo, “it removes all ‘fear’ of those oaths”. I might just add that Rav Ya’akov Moshe Charlap (Memaynai HaYshua, p. 245), another major student of Rav Kook, explains that the idea of the aggada was to stress that the national revival of Israel is actually an international event and of universal importance, and therefore we prefer for it to be in cooperation with the other nations. In addition, many don’t realize that Rav Soloveichik’s famed article Kol Dodi Dofek is an answer to the three oaths.
    In short, many people look for excuses why not to make aliya, but this surely isn’t a legitimate one! If chazal teach us that “Living in Israel is equated with the rest of the mitzvot combined” even when there is no Beit HaMikdash (as seen in Sifre Dvarim 12, which takes place about 60 years after the churban), and even when Israel is in exile (and the land is in gentile hands, Tosefta Avodah Zara 5, 2), than obviously the sources speak for themselves.
    We need to strengthen the priorities and courage of the Jews in exile to make the move, and it really doesn’t depend on this or that aggadic source, which everyone knows is not legit and is just an excuse (especially when those quoting it are not at all Satmar Hassidim on any other issue!). With Love of Israel,
    Rav Ari Shvat

  • Writing an English Sefer Torah

    I have a great English handwriting, Thank G-d.
    I would like to write a Torah on expensive paper in English.
    Can I make it in scroll form ? (not in book form).
    Or may this scroll form confuse people into thinking that this is a kosher Torah.
    Also….
    Do I fulfill the mitzva of writing a Torah.

    Shalom.
    It’s great that you want to use your G-d-given talents for G-dly acts and making the mitzvot beautiful and honorable. Nevertheless, the rabbis tell us that there was “darkness for three days” when the Torah was translated, for although translations are allowed if one doesn’t know Hebrew, it’s clearly not an ideal and should be done minimally and surely not ceremoniously (R. Y. E. Henkin, Tshuvot Ibra, 56, 2; R. Moshe Feinstein Y.D. iv, 38; for more sources, see my article in Tchumin, http://www.rambish.org.il/results.asp?SearchFunction=find&SearchCode=F2_WAU&SearchRequest=94&SearchSort=publish_year&UserAction=&jump=1).
    Regarding the question if you would be fulfilling the mitzvah of writing a Sefer Torah, the Rambam (1, 19, see also Sha’agat Aryeh (Turei Aven on Megilla 8a) clearly says no, but theoretically, the Ran (Megilla 8a, Shabbat 115b) seems to think its okay (if it’s on parchment, and fulfills all of the many complicated requirements), although it’s not clear how he would suggest writing G-d’s name, or the “kri u’chtiv” (where it’s written one way and read another way), and those questions would apparently render the Torah non-acceptable (R. Sh.Z. Auerbach, Minchat Shlomo, II, 4).  Similarly, there are many varied translations of the Torah, all of which “lock” you into one particular/partial explanation of each original Hebrew passage, and none of them are certified or officially recognized.

    According to the Rosh who holds that even buying any book of Torah study is included in the mitzvah, so seemingly, laboring to write the Torah, even in English, would be fulfilling the mitzvah, if it would actually be used for study. On the other hand, many hold that the real mitzvah is to write a genuine kosher Torah in Hebrew (Taz and Shach, Yoreh Deah 240), than if you are investing so much money on parchment etc., it would halachically be much better to pay a scribe to write a kosher Torah and fulfill the mitzvah according to all opinions.
    I might add an additional factor that you may want to consider: your descendents will all eventually be Hebrew (and not English) speakers, and if you’re investing so much time and effort, I would suggest taking that into account.
    In short, you can learn from a translation if need be, but it should remain a temporary necessity and not turned into a ceremonious ideal.
    With Love of Israel,
    Rav Ari Shvat

  • Bible- would G-d exchange His People

    Would G-d change up his covenant for another nation.
    G-d Bless

    Shalom John,

    No, there are countless verses which say explicitly that G-d has an eternal covenant with Israel. See for example, Gen. 17, 7; ibid, 19; Jer. 31; ibid 32; Ezek. 16, 60; Psl. 105, 10 et al. How much more so after we have witnessed the revival of the Jewish Nation and State, the Holy Language, the Holy army, and Holy land only 3 short years after the Holocaust, the lowest point in Jewish (and human) history, one has to be blind or consciously in denial, not to see that G-d hasn’t, forbid, left His people of Israel!

  • Coffee urn for Pesach

    Can a coffee urn or pump that was used for chometz be used for pesach

    Shalom!
    If you are sure that it was just used during the year for water and non-flavored coffee and no chametz, then it's enough to clean it with soap and water, and then it can be used for Pesach. But if you mean it was used with actual chametz, for example if you warmed challot on the urn, then it's a problem.
    Chag Kasher v'Same'ach,
    Rav Ari Shvat

  • Kingdom of Moshiach

    I’m a bit confused over how Moshiach will be named King.

    0. Is there a “Coat of Arms” for the House of David?
    1. Will there be something like a “coronation” ceremony?
    2. Will he (and his family, if he has one) live in something like a “castle” or a mansion, or simply a humble house or apt?
    3. Is it said that he will be rich or will he be poor?
    4. Will there be a fully functional Monarchy where only King Moshiach is in control of Israel or will there be something like a shared governance like how Britain has the Queen as well as the Prime Minister?
    5. Will the current government of Israel cease to exist with the emergence of The King? If Moshiach is to reign supreme over all of Israel, than wouldn’t it stand to reason that the current government would be rendered useless?
    6. If there is no more need for a government the way it is, would they (the gov’t) try to selfishly stop the emergence of Moshiach or even try to assassinate him?
    7. Once Moshiach is here, what does that mean for Jews and Noachides around the world who have not been fortunate enough to afford to make it to Israel yet?
    8. If the Palestinian Authority succeeds in gaining UN support for a “state” of their own, and move in to “claim” territory, then what will happen to them once Moshiach emerges?
    9. Does the Temple come before Moshiach or vice versa?
    10. Once Temple is rebuilt, and Moshiach emerges, what becomes of the Mosques on the Temple Mount? Would we have them removed or let them stay? Would HaShem perhaps level it?

    Firstly, allow me to admire your interest in the details of the messianic age- for it shows true, even pragmatic, belief, something very important for Noachides, as well. In general, it is important to look ahead, to keep constant eye-contact on the eventual goal, nevertheless, the Rambam (Maimonides) stresses that the main point is to live a G-dly life in the present, and that way, slowly but surely, we will merit and bring that better and ideal future.
    That being said, regarding your questions:
    0. Our tannaic rabbis (in Bamidbar Rabba 2, written about 1800 years ago), recount the tradition that each of the 12 tribes had a flag with the symbol which their forefather received in the blessing from their father Jacob at the end of Breishit (Genesis). Accordingly, David, from the tribe of Judah probably used the flag with his tribal symbol, the lion, which, as the medieval commentator Rabbi Isaac Abarbanel explains, was given the symbol (“King of the Jungle”) befitting a king, on a sky-blue backdrop (either consciously or ironically, very similar to the Israeli flag suggested by the first president, Chaim Weitzman). Especially after the secession of the ten tribes who rebelled and left the kingdom of Judea to found the Kingdom of Israel (which were subsequently exiled and lost), it is logical that the flag of Judah took on that much more significance and this could be a type of coat-of-arms or flag.
    1. There will definitely be a coronation ceremony for that is the literal meaning of the term mashiach (=transliterated as messiah=the anointed one), although his succeeding son would not need such a service. It will probably be by the Shiloach fountain, found about a 10 minute walk from the Temple, right by where David’s palace has been uncovered by archeologists, and where his great-great grandfather David was himself anointed.
    2. With all his humility, as the head and international representative of the Chosen People of Israel, he must command respect and live respectfully according to the norms accepted in the modern world. As I wrote in the past, he must be addressed respectfully as is accepted in each generation, and as is the custom in the Jewish world (for example, in yeshivas today), he would clearly be spoken to in the third person (“What does the King feel about…?”, and not “What do you feel about…?). No one is allowed to sit on his throne, ride on his horse (or motorcade), nor use his utensils, even after his death. His wife can’t remarry. He is the only one allowed to sit in the Temple in Jerusalem. He must be immaculately groomed, and has his hair cut every day: “see the king in his beauty” (Isaiah 33, 17). In addition, one must stand when the King enters a room, and bow before him, and he may not even voluntarily forego this, or any of the other aforementioned honors, for they are not personal tributes, but represent the honor of Israel. On the other hand, in his heart, he must be extremely humble and he must not act arrogantly towards Israel, just according to the necessary protocol, “so that he shouldn’t be haughty before his brothers” (Dvarim 17, 20). He must be merciful to small and great alike, and must serve Israel responsibly, and address them as brothers.
    3. He must find the delicate balance, between the obligated necessary wealth needed to command respect and receive the gentile leaders, run the army and state of the world super-power, but he isn’t allowed to amass more wealth than is necessary, for this can lead to arrogance (Dvarim 17, 17). He cannot amass extraneous personal wealth in his treasury, and if he does so, the Sanhedrin must punish him (see next paragraph).
    4. The government will clearly not be a dictatorship, and he must confer with advisors and specialists in each respective field (the Hebrew word for king- melech- is from the verb “confer”, differentiated from the Hebrew word for dictator- moshel, as stressed by the Malbim and Vilna Gaon). The checks and balance system for example, calls for the king to answer to the rabbinical Sanhedrin. His pastime should be spent studying the Torah, and he obviously must be in constant contact with the Sanhedrin and Torah scholars, even though he possesses the power to enact special laws, even applying the death penalty to masses (for the national or international needs), even temporarily circumventing the Torah itself, when necessary. Similarly, he must respect and listen to the prophet, and should stand before the High Priest, nevertheless, the Priest must tell him to sit (unless he has come to ask the Priest to confer with G-d via his breastplate) and himself should stand in honor of the king. Similarly the king must honor Torah scholars, especially the heads of the Sanhedrin (Rabbinical Supreme Court), and must stand before them, and seat them by him. The above is true in privacy, but in public when seen by the people, the king may not stand in honor of anyone, may not speak gently, and may not refer to anyone by any respective title, only by their name, so that all will revere him.
    5. The Maharal (Gvurot Hashem 18) and the Malbim (on Micah 4, 8), explain that the messianic kingdom will be preceded by “the first government” which will be a small, non-religious republic (like what we call today: democracy) out of which will eventually grow the religious spiritual kingdom of the messiah. The Talmud (Megilla 17a) written about 1,500 years ago, recounts the tradition that after a long exile (it was about 1,900 years), there will be an agricultural revival of the Holy Land, followed by the ingathering of the exiles (statistically, by the year 2032, most of world Jewry will reside in Israel, for the first time since the exile of the ten tribes almost 3,000 years ago). The third stage will be the return of the Jewish State to religious law. Just as in the first stages, of the Holy Land and the mass Jewish immigration, this transition will also be gradual, with the people, and subsequently the State of Israel, becoming more and more religious and spiritual. This is  already taking place, and is extremely noteworthy when taking into account the difficult changes involved in one’s eating and dress, and withdrawing from most activities every Sabbath (Saturday), as required by Jewish observance.
    6. We don’t know exactly how it will come about, but we pray that the transition will be natural and peaceful. In fact, the democratic process is ideal for such changes to be made according to the pace chosen by the electorate. The legendary Chief Rabbi A.I. Kook explained in this context, that true improvement is the result of educating each generation better and better, and certainly not through religious coercion which causes animosity rather than identification. As long as man has (thank G-d) free will, inevitably some will be disappointed with any change, but that’s what democracy is about. Assassination or any sudden artificial intervention or upheaval is good for the childish imagination, but in reality, almost always cause more harm than good. The democratic and educational process is by far the most natural, real and long-lasting, and that’s exactly what we (and G-d) all want.
    7. Regarding Jews, the State of Israel already offers free airfare and a generous “basket” of benefits which have already aided more than a million Jews to come home, even from economically problematic countries like Russia, Ethiopia, Algeria, Iraq, Cuba, etc. Regarding the masses of Noachides who will want to visit, I’m not familiar with any sources, but my educated guess is that at that time, the world will be so enamored with the Holy Land, it shouldn’t be complicated to establish scholarship or loan funds for the less fortunate and youth.
    8. The entire world, even Moslems, will believe in peace and international brotherhood. International economic and/or military sanctions will eventually clarify to all, that violence is counterproductive and will not be tolerated by the civilized and moral world. Unfortunately, the leadership of our enemies have yet to mature and still primitively believe in the law of the jungle. Their educational system and even street names glorify suicide bombers according to the number of innocent Jewish citizens which they murdered, and the only way to rectify that is to stand strong and together in order to deter them. The world should definitely not condone their present behavior.
    9. Some sources (like the aforementioned Megilla 17a) say that the third Temple in Jerusalem precedes the coming of Mashiach, while the Talmud in Sanhedrin 98a indicates that if there is a mass Jewish return and repentance, than the Mashiach may come first, but if we choose the slower and more natural path (which seems to be the present situation), the Temple will be man-made and will pave the way for Mashiach.
    10. The Bible, Talmud and early rabbinical sources obviously don’t refer to what to do with the mosque, because it’s only been around for about 1,300 years and that’s relatively recent as far as Judaism is concerned. What is clear is that although G-d can do anything, already in the Book of Esther, about 2,500 years ago, He clearly prefers not doing super-natural miracles, but rather working through nature (like the Six-Day War in ‘67), thus enabling us to believe in Him through our free will and not through miraculous coercion. My educated guess is that being that the messiah is for the entire universe, the Moslems themselves will want to participate and help us build the Temple, to atone for their multitude of violent crimes and terrorism which they will surely regret. Unfortunately, in the foreseeable future, no Israeli government (and hopefully no individual) would risk opening up a world war by leveling the mosque, so it seems more likely that the incessant Arab shelling and bombing which has been going on for almost 65 years, may somehow blow it up by mistake. As we well know, the L-rd works in many ways and we can’t know for sure, but as in the time of Haman, G-d often helps the evil destroy itself (Yalkut Shimoni, Yirm. 319), so that we don’t have to get involved in international problems.

  • Reduced pleasure after churban

    I don’t remember where it is, but I’ve heard about a Gemara or a Medrish which says that physical pleasures used to be stronger during the times of the Beit Hamikdash. If there is such a source, please let me know where it is and maybe an understanding of why that happened. Thank you.

    Shalom Yonasan,
    The sources you are looking for are in Midrash T’hilim 7, 9, “From the day of the destruction of the Beit haMikdash, there is no day without curse, the dew of blessing does not fall, the taste and “oil” of fruit was taken away,… the (pleasure of) taste and smell were also taken…”; Sanhedrin 75a, “From the day of the destruction of the Beit haMikdash, the taste of sex was diminished”.
    The idea is that in Judaism the spiritual and the physical work together, and when one suffers, so does the other. Just like when a person is physically sick, it’s difficult to achieve a spiritual high, and when an elderly person feels no spiritual meaning to his life, it may be reflected in a disheveled physical appearance and dress, so too on a national level, when Eretz Yisrael, Y’rushalayim, and the Beit HaMikdash are in ruins, the physical and spiritual pleasure are both lowered. The reason being that the real physical pleasures were created to accompany spirituality: the fruit of Israel is holy, the physical beauty of the Beit HaMikdash is spiritual, etc. Similarly, the kabbala talks at length about the spirituality of the proper physical union between man and wife which enhances physical pleasure, as well. On the other hand, when the physical lacks the spiritual, than it’s not “the real pleasure” intended in creation. The proper harmonizing of the spiritual and the physical produce more than the sum of those two parts, so when they’re separated, each one cannot really exist properly, independent of the other. Simply put, when our spirituality and physicality suffer, our spirituality and our physicality suffer!
    May we speedily see the Aliya of all of the Jews to Eretz Yisrael, and with that additional kedusha, the spiritual and physical will return speedily in our days!
    Rav Ari Shvat

    .