Category: Q&A

  • Selling Home in Israel

    Over the years I have heard that one is not supposed to sell their first, or only, home in Israel. What is the source of this idea? Is it Halacha? Can one sell in order to buy another? Thank you.

    Shalom. There is a positive mitzvah to buy a house or land in the Land of Israel (Bamidbar 33, 53) and it’s so important that one can even ask a gentile to write a contract on Shabbat, in order to fulfill the mitzvah (Shulchan Aruch Or. Ch. 306, 11). Accordingly, one shouldn’t sell their property in Eretz Yisrael unless they intend to buy other property here, or unless their economic situation forces them to do so, and that’s the only way they can stay in Israel (the minimal aspect of Yishuv Eretz Yisrael is to live here, even if you don’t own property), or in order to start a business in Israel which is also Yishuv Eretz Yisrael. In general, one must be willing to sacrifice up to 10-20% of their possessions in order to fulfill most positive commandments, but the poskim cite that special mitzvot, like learning Torah or to live/settle in Israel, obligate one to give up everything they own, as long as they don’t have to beg for a living. For more details, see my article from Tchumin at: http://www.yeshiva.co/midrash/shiur.asp?id=20192 . Accordingly, there’s no problem to temporarily sell property in Israel (it doesn’t matter of it was your first house or not), as long as it’s not to a gentile, and it’s for the sake of settling the Land of Israel.   With Love of Israel,

    Rav Ari Shvat

  • Returning Loan which might be a Gift to Gentile

    A while ago someone (not Jewish) “lent” me a notebook, to use in class, because one day I did not have one. She did not say it was a gift. However, it is something you use to write on it, so you surely cannot give it back to the original owner in its original state. I used it only for that day, so some pages are still blank. Moreover, I am pretty sure she forgot of it. Do I still have the halachic obligation to give it back to that person?

    Shalom Ralph,
    Firstly, allow me to admire the fact that you are as meticulous and caring about mitzvot between man and his fellow, as between man and God, for both are religious obligations! You definitely should return the rest of the notebook, for the common practice is to lend pages to fellow students, but not to give an entire notebook. In addition, to not return it may inadvertently cause a chilul Hashem (a desecration of God’s Name), for Jews must set an example and be at least (!) as morally careful as is commonly accepted, that she shouldn’t go around saying, or even thinking, that Jews don’t act properly. To the contrary, by returning it you are doing a Kiddush Hashem (sanctifying His Name), by doing positive “public relations” for God and His People, in addition to cleaning your conscience, your soul, and your “bank account” from any non-kosher property.
    With Love of Israel,
    Rav Ari Shvat

  • Holocaust and Faith

    Dear Rabbi,

    I had a conversation with someone that disturbed and shocked me very deeply. I was told that I do not have true emuna.

    I had said that I could understand that people who survived the shoah asked where Gd was during the shoah. As a matter of fact, I ask myself this question, especially as I am setting up my family tree and record all the details of the deaths of my own family members in the great-grandparent, the grandparent and my parents’ generation. I often have to stop with the work as it really drains me and drives me to tears. And I ask myself, where was Hashem when all this happened?

    I also wonder why Gd allows severe illness to befall young children and teenagers. It is said that bad illness is a punishment for a major transgression in life. How can a child or teenager have committed such a transgression? They simply haven’t lived long enough for this.

    It is not that I do not believe in Hashem, if I did not believe, I would not daven twice a day, it is just that I cannot understand it, although I know that my limited mind cannot fathom the infinite. I just cannot understand how Hashem allows this and that it is all supposed to be for a greater good.

    My question is: Is voicing my feelings in this direction a sign that I cannot be trusted in emuna? Should I just accept everything as it comes and not think about it as to why and for what reason it has occurred? Is it permissible to ask Hashem why He let all this happen? I thank you for your answer.
    Jessica

    Shalom. Your question regarding “how can a good God allow ‘bad’ in the world?”, is the oldest of questions in monotheism, where we believe that God is not only good, but perfect. There are many things in life and in the world that we don’t understand, and this reality is basic humility. I don’t understand quantum physics, after 30 years I still sometimes don’t understand my spouse, and sometimes I don’t even understand myself, so how can I expect to understand God? “If I would understand Him, I would be Him” (R. Yosef Albo). Like a child compared to an adult, our vision is extremely limited compared to the objective all-knowingness of God. If we could see the entire past and the entire future (including the world to come), it would change our view of many incidents in life which seem to be bad, yet in the end, such challenges are exactly what build us. In addition, it’s important to stress, as you inferred, that there are many factors and different “tracks” in the world, aside from reward and punishment, and clearly not all difficulties or challenges are punishments, as is clear from the suffering of small children. Especially when remembering that man’s free will is a major factor in the “ground rules” of this world, and God prefers not to intervene whenever possible. Accordingly, a more practical question with more useful ramifications is: “Where was man during the Holocaust?”
    In addition, only after there is a giant question (such as yours) can there be a giant answer (teshuva, which in Hebrew, also means answer, return and repentance!).
    In fact, we see that Avraham (Breishit 18), Moshe (Shmot 32) and others in the Torah dared disagree even with God, albeit very respectfully, when it comes to ‘sticking up” to defend Israel, and even Sodom (see the many stories about R. Levi Yitzchak of Berditchev). God also wrote this in the Torah, as something that we are meant to emulate, as well. Accordingly, you not only can but you should (!) turn to God requesting Him to be as visibly kind as possible, to facilitate the masses to love, serve and emulate Him.
    Nevertheless, there’s definitely a difference between voicing this questioning in your private conversations with God (prayer- where it’s natural and even worthy in a true open “relationship”!), or even here in this educational forum, where it’s legitimate, positive and constructive, as opposed to voicing this out loud, especially around impressionable children (who may be old enough to understand the questions but not mature or patient enough to hear the answers…) where it may awaken questions or weaken the belief of others. This may have been the intention of your friend’s comment.
    In addition, our exile from Israel is called a desecration of God’s Name (you must see Ezek. 36), and the Holocaust was the climax of the exile, raising the greatest question, why does God not stand up for His people? The prophet Ezekiel continues that God always wanted to redeem His children, like a father who sent his child to his room as a temporary punishment, just waiting for him to improve and apologize. But after 2,000 years of waiting, and 2,000 years of “holding” Himself back, He declares that He will redeem us, even if we don’t deserve it, for as you point out, the “treading” upon Israel is a bad reflection on God, and raises strong questions (the Babylonians and Romans also asked after defeating us, “Jew- where is your God!”!) We actually say this every day in the central Shmoneh Esreh prayer, at the end of the very first blessing, “and He will bring redemption to His sons’ descendents, for His sake (!), out of love”. Even if we don’t understand the Holocaust, the questions: “Does God still exist” and “Is Israel still the Chosen People”, were answered just 3 years later in the miraculous War of Independence in Israel, the fulfillment of the Biblical promise of the Ingathering of the Exiles and the revival of the Land and State of Israel after 2,000 years. It was God’s way of saying: “Of course I’m still around and you are still My Chosen Children” (all of this is in Ezek., ibid), and that’s why He returned us to Israel, even if we don’t deserve it- exactly for this purpose, as an answer to you and all other questioners- especially those who question out of love for God and Israel.
    With Love of God and Israel,
    Rabbi Ari Shvat

  • Are Midrashim True?

    Shalom Rabbi
    From what I understand, Torah = truth, Midrash = commentary/ allegory/ interpretation or something supporting commentary, Rashi and many other commentators use Midrash as their “proof”. Are there various levels of Midrash in terms of “truth”/correctness, midrash = story only if a parable (didactic story). All of the above is created to assist my removing the “garments” of the Torah to live God’s words. So is midrash dvar Torah? I might create midrash, correct? It may not be as good as Rashi or could it? The only absolute is the Torah’s words themselves! Please comment. Shalom,

    The field of midrash is very complex and, as you correctly inferred, includes several different types. Interestingly, the Ramban sometimes disagrees strongly with the Ibn Ezra for veering in his commentary from the midrash of our sages, yet it’s not infrequent for the Ramban to do the same, differing with certain midrashim cited by Rashi! The answer to this apparent contradiction is that some, probably most, midrashim are not factual traditions but rather educational vehicles for teaching us philosophical or spiritual ideas, or how to act properly, while others apparently do come to fill-in ancient traditions. Unfortunately, it’s often difficult to tell whether a certain midrash is meant to be taken literally or not, but the following signs may help their identification. The first category (non-factual) may include midrashim where there are different contradicting opinions, or those many midrashim which “frame” our forefathers as doing sins they clearly didn’t do or exaggerating light offenses into serious ones, to serve as a “springboard” framework to educate others. Similarly, midrashim which seem esoteric would usually fall into this category. On the other hand, midrashim which don’t have an educational message, but are rather fact-filling traditions, like the names of Avraham’s or Shimshon’s respective mothers, may be meant factually. In short, all midrashim are true, yet not all are historically factual, and the best thing to do is to study them with a rabbi who is experienced in the field and constantly search for the deeper meaning.
    There are more than enough midrashim to keep you occupied for a lifetime and there’s no logic or need to invent new ones. On the other hand, one can surely develop his/her own divrei Torah, but would be wise to run it by several learned scholars before publicizing them, so as to prevent embarrassing mistakes. I expounded more on the topic of midrash, in my articles http://www.daat.ac.il/daat/tanach/maamarim/hazakaim-2.htm
    http://www.daat.ac.il/daat/mahshevt/vikuah/tokpam-2.htm
    With Love of Israel,
    Rav Ari Shvat

  • ADORNMENT and Jewelry cont’d

    Rabbi, thank you so much.
    But why did the English Bible say they put off their Jewelries instead of head crown? Its confusing
    2- why did God tell Rachel to take off her Jewelries in Gen. 35:1-4, if it’s not forbidden?

    There are two different stages, one was the sin where they took off their jewelry (nose rings and earrings) to give to make the Golden Calf (Ex. 32, 3), and the other was the punishment (!), where they were told to take off their crown (Rashi’s traditional translation, in Hebrew: “adi”, Ex. 33, 4-6). There are those who explain that this may include other adornments, as well, but all agree that they removed them temporarily (!) as a sign of mourning, as Jewish mourners do to this day, removing their jewelry for 7 days after the death of one of the 7 close relatives, and annually on Tish’a b’Av, the date commemorating the destruction of the Temple 1,943 years ago. This is temporary (!) removal of jewelry at specific times of sadness and/or punishment. This is clear from the fact that just 2 chapters later, Israel donates some of their jewelry to build the Tabernacle (35, 22). Again, they wore jewelry to beautify themselves for their husbands in general, and especially on the Sabbath (Saturday) and holidays, and not only is there nothing wrong with that, but as we see in the sources I brought in the previous answer, it’s commendable and was the non-stop Jewish custom and tradition, until this very day.
    2. Regarding Jacob, he told his household (not just Rachel) to remove all idolatry as they returned to the Land of Israel, including the jewelry spoils of the city of Shchem, which often were used for idolatry, and as archeologists found, often contained the shape of local idols.
    With Love of Israel,
    Rabbi Ari Shvat

  • Where is Miriam’s Punishment and Mourning?

    My chavruta and I are studying the parsha of the week, and something that keeps coming up is Miriam. We don’t seem to say much about her, why she was not destined to entire the land and why she was hardly mourned. If you could share some light on these matters, I would be most grateful

    Shalom. Just about that entire generation, aside from Joshua and Calev didn’t enter the Land of Israel, so Miriam was included together with everyone else, and it wasn’t necessarily a punishment. Similarly, the Ralbag feels that just as Aharon didn’t sin at Mei Meriva, nevertheless he was punished with Moshe, so too regarding Miriam, that there was a general decree (some say even before Mei Meriva, Sefer Birkat Yizchak) towards the three siblings who comprised the “old guard” of leadership, that a new leadership will lead Israel into the Land. R. Neventzahl suggests that Miriam’s slandering Moshe should have served as a lesson to the spies not to slander (Eretz Yisrael). Therefore, even though there’s no comparison between the severity of the two actions, her sin is somewhat similar to theirs, so just as the spies were punished not to enter the Land, so was Miriam.
    The Talmud (Baba Batra 17a) recounts that Miriam was one of 6 who didn’t die regularly, but were blessed with “a kiss of death”, like Moshe and Aharon, but the Torah doesn’t go into detail of her death, for reasons of modesty (“kissing” a woman has connotations). National mourning for Miriam isn’t mentioned, perhaps because it’s reserved for the few top select national leaders. Alternatively, the natural modesty of our mothers brings them to prefer staying out of the limelight, which is considered a great trait, and she (or God) may have accordingly requested to have a more private mourning.
    With Love of Israel, Rav Ari Shvat

  • Mechitza- Lady in Wheel-Chair in Men’s Section

    In the shul where I daven for the past year a lady in a wheel chair who is in the convalescent home next door to our shul is brought into the men’s section.
    The home/hospital has a minyan there that is wheel chair accessible with mechitza rather than a balcony like our shul.
    I asked the lady why doesn’t she daven in the home/hosipital & she said the davening there is not what she is used to, as it’s Sephardi/Edot HaMizrach.
    My question is doesn’t there need to be a mechitza put up?
    If I wanted a lady in the men’s section wheel chair or otherwise I would go to a conservative or reform place not an Orthodox shul. I am in a quandary what to do.

    Good question, which I understand your shul has no rabbi to ask! I conferred with HaRav Ya’akov Ariel, Chief Rabbi of Ramat Gan, and he suggested asking the gabbai of the shul to arrange a portable mechitza, for example, on top of the table in front of where the woman sits. In the meantime, he said that you don’t have to leave the shul every time she comes in, which would obviously offend her, for there is a mechitza in the shul, and her being there is considered occasional and temporary, and one may rely on the fact that there are chairs and tables in between her and the men.
    With Love of Israel,
    Rav Ari Shvat

  • Conservative Shul Davening

    2 questions about this

    1. If you are at a conservative shul for a chuppah and all the men davening are frum, can you use the sanctuary to daven?

    2. When the answer stated that conservative rabbis accept those that drive to shul as legitimate colleagues, the Chabad accept those that drive to shul and even give them Aliyah’s. Why is that accepted when it is no good when done by a conservative rabbi?

    Shalom
    1. Rav Soloveitchik, considered by all as relatively liberal, said one is not allowed to attend a chuppah, or even hear a shofar, in a conservative temple or sanctuary, so the rest of the question is also clearly prohibited.
    2. The Conservative “rabbi”, even if he personally may observe Shabbat, sees his fellow Conservative “rabbis” (!) who drive to temple as colleagues and legitimate peers with legitimate opinions, and not as far-removed Jews who need to be brought closer, as Chabad sees those Jews who unfortunately drive on Shabbat. The Conservative rabbinate unfortunately officially declares allowance for halachic desecration of Shabbat in the name of Judaism, which is significantly more halachically illegitimate, and historically severe and different from individuals who allow themselves, as individuals, to do so.
    With Love of Israel!   Rav Ari Shvat

  • interfaith dialogue with christians

    Hi there,

    I’m a Christian who was searching something else and came across this question. I’ve spent five years of my life studying Jewish theology, and it’s enriched my own Christian faith a lot. My goal isn’t to convert anybody or try and change anyone’s mind, but isn’t studying the theology of other faiths a good thing, even if for no other reason than to compare and contrast with one’s own?

    Having a lot of Jewish friends who are largely ignorant of what many Christians actually believe (evidenced, I would say, by the grouping of “Idol Worship and Christianity), I think it would be beneficial to at the very least hear the creed of the Christian faith on its own terms. I can say from my own experience, learning the way that Jews themselves expressed and understood Judaism and permitting them to teach me about their own faith rather than to try and superimpose my own ideas about it was the best exercise I could’ve done.

    Definitely not trying to be rude or confrontational, merely asking: would not both Jew and Christian hearing what each other has to say on their own terms at the very least foster greater friendship and partnership between members of the two (highly related) faiths? I realize that for most of Christian history the majority of Christians haven’t thought this way, and so skepticism is understood and honored as justifiable, but I’m living proof that there are Christians who are willing to learn from you, because we think you have something valuable to give and to offer. I guess I understand if you don’t feel the same way, but I felt like it was worth saying something. Respect and Blessings.

    Hi. It’s great hearing an open-minded gentile who isn’t out to “missionize” or convert Jews. Unfortunately, as long as convincing Jews to convert is a common or even central goal to many Christian groups and clergy throughout history and to this very day (sometimes even veiling their real intentions), I imagine you can understand and respect our policy not to get into confusing differentiations, and prefer a blanket policy of not holding inter-faith dialogue regarding theological issues. We’re not out to convert or convince others, and we expect a similar, tolerant common courtesy. On the other hand, dialogue on political, community, humanitarian or international issues and events are fine, and cooperation of all mankind can help greatly. For example, if you can help us Jews deal with the immoral crackpot Moslem leaders in Iran who not only inconsiderately deny the fact that 6,000,000 Jews were murdered by the Nazis in the Holocaust, but want to actually nuke us and kill another 7,000,000 Jews in modern Israel, it would be greatly appreciated, so we don’t have to do it ourselves and alone. This type of universal brotherhood is a lot more urgent!

  • Lashon Hara in Therapy

    If a person was hurt by someone, can they discuss the incident and speak lashon hara (slander, gossip) about the person with a therapist, especially if the therapist doesn’t know the person and he is obligated to keep all the details of the therapy personal and confidential. Thank you

    Yes, it is clearly allowed in such a situation, especially when the therapist doesn’t know the people involved.
    Rav Ari Shvat.