Category: Q&A

  • Why not Identify the Holocaust as Sign of Redemption?

    Why isn’t the holocaust labeled as the third redemption? There were 6 million Jews murdered. Also, is there any sign of what may happen 70 years after the Jews got Israel back in 1948?

    It was very observant of you to notice that I consciously omitted the Holocaust as one of the signs of redemption even though it is mentioned [e.g. Midrash T’hilim 20: just as when we see a graveyard we know that the state (= civilization) will soon be seen, so too when we see many troubles befalling us, know that the redemption is soon to come]. I omitted it because this was the only sign that the false messiahs always cited, since it wasn’t uncommon for there to be serious problems over the 1,900 years of exile. After terrible pogroms, these charlatans would claim, “it can’t get any worse- so I am the messiah!” Even though it’s hard to imagine something happening worse than the Holocaust (especially now that Jews can always run to Israel for refuge), nevertheless, we learn from Jewish history that one should never say “it can’t get worse!” Accordingly, the other signs are much more positive (both meanings implied!) and conclusive. Nevertheless, as opposed to the 3 historical signs mentioned in the previous response (Israel returning to fruition; gathering the exiles; the State of Israel), about which the Talmud commands us to constantly search for their fulfillment and subsequently publicize (Shabbat 31a), conversely, they teach us not to deal with exact calculations (Sanhedrin 97b) for obvious reasons.

  • Why so many aren’t Getting Married Today?

    Why is it that today, so many people are not getting married? Has something gone wrong with our concept of love?

    There are at least 7 major changes in western society that need to be identified as part of the problem many people have today in finding their soul-mate:
    1. Unfortunately, the modern technological world which God revealed to man to be used beneficially, is often misused. Just like modern atomic energy can either cure cancer or bomb, indiscriminately killing masses, so too computers are unbelievably beneficial, yet internet, Facebook and pornography can unfortunately produce loners who mistakenly think they have friends, or are so distracted from life, they don’t even realize what they are missing.
    2. Similarly, in a society where one chooses a spouse out of the “romantic” feeling screened in Hollywood, there will inevitably be a disproportionate amount of disappointed marriages and divorce (because the romance wears off), and an exaggerated number of single people “waiting for the magic” to happen. I’m not saying that we should all go back to the “matchmaking” system, but if by a certain age one hasn’t yet found their soul-mate, they should unabashedly take advantage of some form of assistance (today there’s even international computer dating to expand one’s potential social field!).
    3. This problem is compounded by the extremely co-ed society which to a large extent “immunizes” the super-strong chemistry that is naturally found between men and women when they discover the opposite gender for the first time at the age of 18, and for the purpose of marriage. Halacha calls for more separation between the sexes, thus facilitating that special “chemistry”, to feel the magic.
    4. God granted mankind the will of free choice, which is so strong that it can even overcome nature. Man can choose to overcome his natural fear because sometimes he needs to charge the enemy, or overcome his instinct to eat because he medically or aesthetically needs to diet. This super-strong will, can also be misused to overcome our Godly good nature, as well. Just as there are anorexics who overcome the natural healthy instinct to eat, to do counterproductive and exaggerated diets, so too, western society and especially feminism, sometimes produces women who overcome their natural desire for motherhood, mistakenly delaying marriage, by thinking that dedication to their career will bring them even more satisfaction. Rav Kook stresses that in general, when healthy, we should follow our healthy nature, and the tool to “overcome” one’s nature and instincts should be used sparingly and only under rare necessary circumstances.
    5. Feminism sometimes confuses people, to mistakenly think that financial independence also lessens the need for companionship.
    6. The self-centeredness of the “Me Generation” in western society runs counter to the Godly ideal of altruism and giving, which is what marriage expresses, helping us achieve our potential to be “givers”. Accordingly, the idea of compromise, giving-love and altruism, the building blocks of marriage, must be consciously developed today, whereas once they were taken for granted.

    7. Our high standard of living and globalization have “spoiled” us to be accustomed not to compromise, and strive for better in everything, including a spouse. Although we intellectually know we ourselves are not perfect, many often “hold out” thinking the “next candidate will be even better”, forgetting that everyone has faults, and we should focus on the major issues and compromise on the secondary.
    We can meet these challenges, but we must first identify the problems.    With Love of Israel, Rav Ari Shvat

  • Ingathering of the Jewish exiles & Those who Don’t Come

    Are only those exiled Jews who set foot on the Land of Israel after their exile the only ones to return to Israel? Are those who died en route to the Land of Israel or those who resolved to return but change their minds en route and went another way also among those who returned to the Land of Israel?

    To date, more than 7,000,000 Jews have returned to the Land of Israel, and statistically, within 6 years, the majority of the Jews in the world will be living in the Holy Land for the first time since the exile of the 10 tribes about 2,700 years ago. Only God can judge those who don’t physically return, for only He knows whether they sincerely tried their best or were just looking for excuses. Even those with legitimate excuses are nonetheless, missing out on this historic event, the fortune to participate in the national revival of the Chosen People, and the writing of the most glorious chapter in our exceptional history.   With Love of Israel, Rav Ari Shvat

  • Reincarnation in Judaism?

    Is the concept of reincarnation contrary to the doctrinal teachings of Orthodox Judaism?

    There is a difference of opinion among our greatest rabbis whether there is reincarnation or not. R. Sa’adya Gaon, R. Yosef Albo, and R. Chasdai Kreskas for example, believe that after life, one goes to the World to Come where his soul enjoys those spiritual pleasures until, if he merits, he reawakens in the Revival of the Dead. They believe there is no reincarnation coming back to this world, as we know it. In contrast, although not mentioned in the Talmud, many of our greatest mainstream rabbis, including the Ramban, R. B’chaye, R. Yizchak Abravanel, and the Zohar explicitly speak of reincarnation, where one may be given the choice to return to this world to “try again”, and improve himself and his free will, rather than undergoing the difficult intensive educational punishment of hell (gehinom) for 12 months. They see this as an occasional answer to the age-old question of why bad things sometimes happen to good people. Like a child compared to an adult, man, compared to G-d, clearly doesn’t see the entire picture of what happened before (maybe in a previous life), nor after (in the World to Come), and accordingly often can’t see the justice or benefit derived from a certain occurrence or life, which is now hidden from him. Sometimes he may even request a little assistance, to return with a certain limitation or handicap which may have prevented him, in a previous life/lives, from improving a particular given field (such as speech, not to slander, etc.). That being said, everyone agrees with the Rambam that it’s much more important to focus on improving ourselves in this world rather than thinking about future worlds or future lives.

  • Intermarriage and Racism

    How is the Jewish insistence that a Jew may not marry a gentile anything but racism? If for the sake of the person him/herself, isn’t it more important that they marry a kind spouse, assuming they probably are not very religious to begin with? And if for the children’s sake, in many cases the children will still be aware of their Jewish lineage and practice some Jewish traditions, and in others, aren’t they no different from purely secular Jews?
    Plus, any group forbidding marriage to Jews would be called anti-semitic, so it seems very weird that Judaism can hold this rule in one direction.

    We also believe that in 99.9% of the cases, intermarriage between nations is great! If the president of the U.S. had Russian grandchildren there would be a lot more peace in the world, and whites marrying blacks means and breeds that much more tolerance. On the other hand, even as the world unites into one big family, learns an international language and adopts a global international culture, it needs to be decided what language and what culture it’s going to be! If the movies, music and fashions spreading from Hollywood to the entire world were to be that of values and idealistic priorities, mankind would be in good shape. On the other hand, the present western culture which is influencing the world is spreading violence and adultery and is causing more harm than good. The Islamic option may be more family oriented but is even more violent! God’s solution, as suggested in the Torah, is that just as every family needs a “responsible adult”, referred to in the Torah as the “firstborn” (b’chor), who’s job is to set the tone when the father is not “around”, so too our “invisible” Father appointed Israel as “My firstborn” (Shmot 4, 22) of the united family of humanity. Our role as “a light for the nations” (Isa. 42, 6), which brought monotheism and morality to the world, is to benefit all mankind, as Hashem directed Avraham, “through (your nation) all of the nations will be blessed” (Breishit 12, 3), both morally and economically (through peace and cooperation)!
    That unique national role brings a lot of responsibility (613 mitzvot as opposed to 7!), and entails suffering and endless anti-Semitism (to date, I imagine most nations wouldn’t want to have traded places with us!). True, it may be convenient for the individual Jew to shirk this historic and moral role, but part of this national and universal responsibility is not to assimilate, not to dilute the message. In human nature, the minority doesn’t influence but is influenced, so the only way the world can benefit from the Torah and morals of the pure and original monotheism is to differentiate that small Chosen Nation. Differentiation is not separation (!) from the rest of mankind, but it enables that desired positive universal influence, rather than diluting the idea through assimilation. If an individual Jew is so assimilated that he doesn’t care about all this, that tragedy doesn’t change the fact that it would be a moral tragedy to mankind if there would be no Jewish people. Accordingly, we must support almost all intermarriage, but for the same moral reason, the entire world should oppose all Jewish intermarriage in the strongest terms.

  • How’s Obliterating Amalek Different from Arab Jihad?

    Question: If we are commanded by Hashem to kill Amalek, then how is that any different then the Arabs who claim that Allah told them to kill Jews?

    True the concept of erasing Amalek, today, sounds cruel. On the other hand, the eternal Torah, had to be relevant not only today, but 3300 years ago, as well. To judge methods of national survival 3300 (!) years ago with a modern measuring-stick is anachronistic and simply irrelevant. The same loving G-d who commanded us the super-moral mitzvot, also commanded us peace-loving and “slave-mentality” Jews who just left Egypt, that sometimes we must “toughen up” to “fight fire with fire” in self-defense and retaliation, and is the same G-d who historically “lost” Amalek somewhere along the line, because He doesn’t want that “mitzvah” to be preoccupying modern man. He made sure that Amalek no longer exists, but the only thing that remains is the obligation, once a year, to remember that sometimes we “nice guys” who would do anything not to kill, have to artificially “get tough”, otherwise our anti-Semitic enemies will surely take advantage of us (it still took us thousands of missiles down south and the Oct. 7th/Simchat Torah massacre until we finally retaliated!). Like a loving Father teaches his naive daughter not to let others take advantage of her. Self-defense, retaliation and deterring the enemies of peace is life-giving and moral, and the exact opposite (!) of Islamic terror which brags about how many innocent citizens they killed, and even names their streets after those evil “heroes” of terrorism. The world has difficulty understanding why the Arabs in Gaza could be the aggressors, if they consistently suffer more casualties, because thank G-d, the world doesn’t understand the mindset (and illogic) of religious Jihad!   With Love of Israel, Rav Ari Shvat

     

  • Are Converts to Judaism 100% Jewish?

    Are converts to Judaism 100 % Jewish? Or is it because they are born to a non-Jewish father and non-Jewish member they are not 100 % Jewish despite their conversion to Judaism?

    Definitely! Converts are 100% Jewish, and even say the prayers where the wording may have caused you to think otherwise (e.g. they also say: “The God of OUR fathers, Abraham Isaac and Jacob…”, “who took US out of Egypt”, “MY father (Jacob)…”, “You gave us the Land”, etc.). They count for a quorum of ten men, necessary for prayer, and there is actually a prohibition to differentiate in any way between a convert and one born Jewish, and the commandment to love the convert is mentioned more times than any other mitzvah in the Torah! The Talmud goes so far as to say that the soul of the convert stood at Mt. Sinai with the rest of Israel, already 3,300 years ago. In short, the convert is considered as if he was “born-again”, but this time as a Jew. Many rabbis actually say that the convert has an advantage because he chose Judaism out of his own free will, and wasn’t just born into it.
    On the other hand, as opposed to Christianity and Islam, Judaism is not interested at all in convincing people to convert, and those who were born gentiles should stay gentiles, observing the 7 mitzvot of Noah, entitling them to a share in the world to come (it’s also much easier than being Jewish!). All the best!
    Rabbi Ari Shvat

  • How is Man made in the Image of God?

    When scripture says man is made in the image of God what is it talking about. In what way is man made in the image of God? Obviously it can’t be his shape because God is spirit and He has no shape. And if not, then what is it in man that we can say that he is made in the image of God?

    Your question touches upon one of the central points of man’s essence and our role in this world. When the Torah teaches us that God created man, “and He breathed into (man’s) nostrils the living soul” (Genesis 2, 7), this metaphor is explained by our rabbis: “anyone who ‘breathes into’ blows in that which He has inside Himself” (e.g. one blows into a balloon the air which one has in his lungs). Accordingly, that soul, which is man’s essence, is what God breathed into man, as if it were, a “spark” of God Himself. That soul is also called “the image of God” (ibid, 1, 27), or literally the “shadow” of God (in Hebrew: tzel/em). Just like a shadow copies or imitates the person’s actions, but is clearly not the person, so too man is meant to emulate or copy God (“imitateo Dei”), even though we are clearly not Him. In short, every person has a unique spark of God, and we are all capable of and meant to reveal our Godly selves, which is our true essential self (we are not our bodies which are constantly changing, but rather our souls= our Godly spark= our unique individual image of God=our shadow of God). Similarly, when I want to “come close” to God, if He has no physical body, the only possibility is to be similar to His ways (e.g. like a counterfeit bill can “be close”= similar, to the original). How can we copy or “be the image” of God? By emulating God’s 13 attributes in our daily lives towards our families, neighbors, and nation: “The Lord, the Lord, mighty, merciful, and gracious, patient and abundant in love and truth etc. etc. (Exodus 34, 6-7). In other words, man’s role is to be Godly by revealing his Godly self=image=soul=essence through God’s Torah and her teachings.
    With Love of Israel!
    Rav Ari Shvat

  • Sources for not making Aliya? Examining Rambam’s opinion

    Hi on what basis do people justify staying in Chu”l and not making aliyah. Do some say the Rambam doesn’t hold that there is a mitzvah to live in Eretz Yisrael? Do some say that there is no mitzvah to conquer Eretz Yisrael?
    I recently bought sefer hachinuch – is this based on rambam mitzvot or ramban? I cant seem to find there the mitzvah to live/settle/conquer Eretz Yisrael?

    Shalom,
    Your question on the Sefer HaChinuch is the same as your question regarding the Rambam for he copied his list from the Rambam. Regarding the Rambam, the fallacy that he may not hold that there’s a mizva to live in Israel is based upon the fact the he doesn’t list it among his count of the 613 mitzvot. The question is usually raised by those looking for an excuse to justify their not making aliya, and if that’s the best they can come up with, it proves the point better than anything!
    The Vilna Gaon says there are several thousand (!) mitzvot m’doraita, and the technical question of how to settle that with the mesorah (oral tradition) that counts 613 (Makot 23b) provides some interesting pilpulim but there’s no nafka-mina  (practical ramification) whatsoever (מעלות התורה, עמ’ סו במהד’ י-ם, תשנ”א). Everyone agrees there must be a menora in the Beit HaMikdash, but there’s no difference whether it’s 1 of the 613 or included in the mitzva of “v’asu li mikdash” (see Sefer Hamitzvot, shoresh 12). Everyone agrees one must believe in God, but many don’t consider it one of the 613 (see Ramban on mizva 1).
    Only R. Y. DeLeon, who is not considered by any accounts a posek, in his commentary “Megilat Esther”, suggests that maybe the reason the Rambam doesn’t count mitzvat yishuv haAretz as a mitzva is because it’s not applicable during the exile (and the Rambam only counts mitzvot which apply in all times, Sefer HaMitzvot, shoresh 3). This is only one of many possible reasons suggested- although for those living in America it is obviously popular! It is clearly wrong (something I would never say about any opinion of a rishon on any issue, but R. Y. DeLeon (the Megilat Esther) can hardly be considered a halachic authority, surely not a rishon- there is not even one (!) halacha in his name brought in the entire Shulchan Aruch and not everyone who lived in the period of the rishonim has that status). The mistake of the Megilat Esther is self-evident in the Rambam himself in hil. Avadim 8, 8, where the Rambam takes the trouble to state explicitly that the mitzvah to live in Eretz Yisrael is in all generations, also during galut, even if the Land is in the hands of the gentiles!
    Additionally, in hil. M’lachim 5, 12, the Rambam says “a person should always live in Eretz Yisrael, even in a city of gentiles, and not in chu”l (outside of Israel) even in a Jewish city”. The Rambam should have sufficed with his opening statement (“a person should always live in Eretz Yisrael), yet again he goes out of his way to give an example (“even in a city of gentiles, and not in chu”l even in a Jewish city”, clearly referring to the period of exile), where we (or the Megilat Esther!) may have thought otherwise!
    Another unquestionable proof regarding the Rambam’s opinion is in hil. Mlachim 7, 14, that the only p’tur (exemption) from the Israeli army (in milchemet r’shut- an optional war) for one who planted a vineyard (and didn’t redeem it in the fourth year) or one who built a house (and has yet to dedicate it) is if they ‘re in Israel. As usual, the Rambam takes his halachot straight from the Talmudic sources, in this case from the Y’rushalmi Sotah 8, 4, which explains the reason is because only in ER.Y. is planting a vine and building a house a mitzva, that of yishuv Er.Y. This exemption from the army is a halacha m’doraita (Torah level commandment), and there is no other way to explain the Rambam but that he holds mitzvat yishuv Er.Y. is a mitzvah d’oraita (from the Torah).
    I personally think that it is not kavod to R. Y. DeLeon even to quote his opinion which he clearly did not check up in the Mishneh Torah, where the Rambam’s consistent opinion (see also hil. M’chira 14, 8; hil Shmita 4, 27; hil. Shabbat 6, 10-11; hil. Ishut 13, 19 and more) is that it’s a mitzva D’oraita in all times, explicitly contradicting R. Y. DeLeon suggested explanation of the Rambam.
    [Ironically, today with the advent of the State of Israel, even R. Y. DeLeon (the “Megilat Esther”) who was often cited as the opinion who justifies living in chu”l, apparently holds that the mitzvah has returned! For he opines that according to the Rambam there is no mitzvah until the Land is in our hands (Megilat Esther: “… after we were exiled, this mitzvah is not practiced until the coming of the Machiach… that conquering the Land is a mitzvah when we are not subjected to non-Jewish rule”. And as the Rambam himself writes, hil. Tshuva 9, 2; Milachim 12, 2, we know we are in the days of mashiach if we have an independent state, and we’re not under foreign rule. In other words, today, even the dissenting “Megilat Esther” would agree that there’s a mitzvah today to live in Israel, for even if the mashiach has yet to come, we are already in what the Rambam terms (ibid) “the days of Mashiach” for we “are not subjected to non-Jewish rule”!].
    There are many other alternative suggestions why the Rambam doesn’t count yishuv Eretz Yisrael among the 613 mitzvot,
    1. The Chatam Sofer (Resp. Yoreh De’ah, 234): the obligation to live in Aretz is based on the exceptional kedusha (holiness) here, and there is therefore no need to call it “just” a mizva.
    2. The Avnei Nezer (Resp. Orach Chaim, vol. II, 535, 8) says its included in the mitzva of kibbush haAretz (“haCharem Tacharimem”).
    3. Rav Kook quotes the Or haChayim (end of p. Nitzavim), that living in Israel encompasses all of the mitzvot in the Torah, or “is equated with all of the mitzvot in the Torah” (Sifre Dvarim 12), and need not be counted as “only” one individual mitzvah (shoresh 4).
    4. Eretz Chemda (R. Shaul Yisraeli, p.33): it’s included in “v’achalta v’savata uverachta et Hashem Elokecha al haAretz haTova” if we thank Hashem for (literally: “on”) the Land which He gave us, we obviously must be here!
    5. The Gadol of Minsk: Shoresh 2 of the Rambam’s rules for what he counts in the 613 and what not: Inferred Mitzvot aren’t among the 613. Anyone who reads the Tanach sees that it is obviously addressing Am Yisrael who is living in Eretz Yisrael.
    6. Rav Yissachar Teichtel, Em haBanim Smecha (p. 151): It’s a basic necessity for our national survival to have Eretz Yisrael, just as there’s no mitzva to breathe because it’s simply a necessity, and the Rambam himself (Sefer haMitzvot, aseh 153) infers this point.
    The Pitchei Tshuva (Even haEzer 75, 5) points out that the Shulchan Aruch as well as “all the poskim Rishonim vAchronim” hold like the Ramban in this issue, that aliya is a mitzvah in all time periods. In other words, the sugya has already been decided several hundred years ago. In my opinion it’s even unwise and uneducational to spend so much time on the rejected minority opinion of this Megilat Esther because it lends legitimacy to this lone view as if it were a legitimate halachic opinion which can be relied upon (see the klalei psika of the Shach on Yoreh De’ah 110, that such a minority opinion isn’t even considered an opinion). Since when do we learn halacha l’ma’aseh from R. Y. DeLeon (or even the Rambam, for that matter)? Since their time (about 750 years ago), the universally accepted Shulchan Aruch and Rama have been published and are the definitive halachic decision. They hold that aliya is a mitzvah in all times (Even haEzer 75,3, Orach Chaim 248,4). The only time you’ll hear someone pasken like a rejected da’at yachid against the Shulchan Aruch regarding any mitzvah m’doraita (!) is when he’s fishing for that yearned-for excuse to live in America.
    Regarding your question whether it’s a mitzvah to conquer the Land of Israel today, we’ve already cited the Pitchei Tshuva (Even haEzer 75, 5) that the Shulchan Aruch as well as “all the poskim Rishonim vAchronim” hold like the Ramban in this issue, that it’s a mitzvah to settle and conquer the Land in all times and if one sees the Rambam’s Perush HaMishnayot (on Sotah 8, 6 and the Tiferet Yisrael there) this seems to be the opinion of the Rambam, as well.
    Regarding the excuse that aliya might lower their standard of living, I already elaborated in my article in Tchumin (vol. 22), and found that all the rishonim and achronim agree that parnassa can only be an excuse if one must beg for a living in Israel (see http://www.daat.ac.il/daat/israel/maamarim/teruts-2.htm).
    In short, the legendary Ya’avetz (R. Ya’akov Emdin, Sulam Beit-El, p. 14) summarized the issue well when he wrote (more than 200 years ago) “it is truly a recurrent riddle on the holy people of Israel. Regarding other mitzvot they are extremely strict… spend great sums and make the effort to observe them as meticulously as possible. But why are they lazy and degrade this beloved mitzvah (of aliya), the peg upon which the entire Torah hangs?!”. Similarly, R. Yehuda HaLevy in his Sefer HaKuzari has an answer for all of the king’s hundreds of questions on Judaism, but when asked why doesn’t the rabbi himself make aliya, the answer is simply, “You have found my point of embarrassment” (Kuzari 2, 24).
    I know someone who for years claimed that he didn’t make aliya because his parents needed his help. Only after his elderly parents (!) made aliya and he stayed in America, did it turn out that it was just an excuse. When people don’t make aliya it’s not because of any sources, but usually just because they don’t have the guts to make the change.
    With Love of Israel!
    Rav Ari Shvat

  • Fasting on a Yahrzeit in Adar on Friday

    Rabbi:

    The yahrzeit of my father falls in Adar. We observe it in both Adar I and Adar II in a leap year. We (the sons), also fast on the yahrzeit.
    I have two questions. First, is it proper to fast in both months of Adar during the leap year, and second, if the yahrzeit falls on a Friday, what is the practice for a private fast on a Friday?
    (Thank you)

    Shalom. I checked with Rav Ya’akov Ariel, the Chief Rabbi of Ramat Gan, and he agreed that being that observing the yahrtzeit on both Adars is only a chumrah (personal stringency) and that Ashkenazim really observe yahrtzeits in the first Adar, so one should fast only in the first Adar (for that’s a relatively difficult custom). You can commemorate the date in the second Adar by saying kaddish, and if you wish, giving tzedaka and/or learning some extra Torah in your father’s memory and/or giving a “tikun”/kiddush.
    If a personal fast like this falls on Friday, the Rama says you only fast until you come out of shul at night, even if it’s an early minyan (he adds that it’s good, if you remember, to have this in mind when you accept the fast on the previous afternoon mincha, but in any event you can be lenient and need not wait until night, if you have an early minyan for kabbalat Shabbat and ma’ariv, Rama, Or. Ch. 249, 3). [This is different from if Asara b’Tevet or a public fast comes out erev Shabbat.]
    I’m sure your father has much nachas in heaven from children who are so careful in their observance of mitzvot and customs!
    With Love of Israel,
    Rav Ari Shvat