Category: Q&A

  • Who Were the Donmeh?

    What is the history behind the Donmeh, the followers of the false messiah Shabtai Tzvi who outwardly converted to Islam?

    Q. Any information regarding the Donmeh? Who are the Donmeh?

    The Donmeh, who were followers of the false messiah Shabtai Zvi who converted to Islam, have been removed from the Jewish community for many generations, and have often intermarried and assimilated with non-Jews (including many who’s spouses underwent non-kosher conversion). This need for them to undergo a full conversion is also clearly in their interest as well, especially those who followed their custom of taking each other’s wives, where if they were Jewish, their offspring would be considered mamzerim (bastards) and wouldn’t be allowed to marry Jews. But as gentiles, requiring full conversion, they are allowed to marry Jews.

  • How Do We Actually Ask G-d for What We Need?

    If everything ultimately comes from G-d either way, what’s the point – and the proper way – of asking Him for our needs?

    Q. What does it mean that we ask Hashem for our needs? I understand that we understand that all is from G-d and whatever we have is from him but how can we ask for things?

    Remember that G-d is like our Father. Parents know there are 3 categories: there are basic necessities which they will buy their child- no matter how he acts; on the other extreme there are things they won’t (!) buy him no matter what (e.g. a horse in the middle of Tel Aviv or lhavdil, Manhattan!); and in the middle category- there are some things which a parent will buy the child if he acts/asks nicely or gets good marks in school, etc. We pray to G-d regarding that 3rd middle category, which He may grant us if we ask nicely/enough/ act properly etc.

  • If Nothing G-d Does Is in Vain, What About Unrepented Sin?

    If Hashem never acts in vain, how does that square with people who never end up doing teshuva?

    Q. There is a general understanding that nothing Hashem does is in vain. There is also a common understanding that if we don’t shape up in time, Hashem will just bring about the arrival of Moshiach himself. If that were to happen though, wouldn’t that make our entire post Adam and Eve reality an ‘in vain’ existence?

    Of course it’s not in vain, for the clarifications that arise out of the messianic age will encourage us to act better and more G-dly. Also, free-will is such a basic premise for man, that the even the possibility of acting right is surely worth it, even if we choose not to do so. In addition, G-d doesn’t just bring the redemption out of “hopelessness” as you inferred, but to keep His covenant with our forefathers (which is a lesson for us to keep our word), and also because the exile of Israel is a negative reflection on Him, and accordingly may lessen our (and the gentiles) motivation to follow His Torah and ways. Also, when He redeems us out of love, even though we don’t deserve it, it educates us to act the same, to show love and kindness to others, even if it’s undeserved. There’s much more on the topic, but that’s in a nutshell.

  • Why Did Prophecy Stop?

    Do prophets still exist today, and if not, why did prophecy come to an end?

    Q. Do prophets exist today ? Why or why not?

    G-d decided, about 2,500 years ago, to cease prophecy and super-natural miracles, thus enabling us more “free will”. Just like the individual, as he matures, is capable of more independence, and is granted it by his caring parent, so too regarding mankind. Nevertheless, there is still, even today, a lower level called “Ru’ach HaKodesh” where a rare super-righteous person, like R. Mordechai Eliahu, is sometimes granted special knowledge or vision from above. There are no full-time miracle-makers, prophets or healers as when the Tanach was written (anyone who claims to be is a charlatan, and stay away!), but rather we are meant to function through rational decisions for which we are held accountable, and prayer (which is a personal encounter!), asking G-d to please intervene (preferably in an undetectable way, not supernaturally). There are documented cases of visions, often dreams, which Rav M. Eliahu, Rav Aryeh Levine, the Lubavitcher rebbe, R. Ya’akov Abu-Chatzeira (Baba Sali) and a few others had and acted upon, which cannot be explained other than Divine intervention, but they are the rare exception (see for example the documented cases of R. Aryeh Levine concerning the identification of the 35 slaughtered members of the Hagana in Gush Etzion (the “Lamed-Heh”) and the case of Avraham Stavsky’s widow who needed chalitza, in Simcha Raz, “A Tzaddik in Our Time”). Most of these cases involve national events, but there are cases of individual situations, as well. G-d reveals Himself more on the national level. The nation of Israel has seen many a natural-miracle, like the victories of the IDF in the War of Independence, the Six Day War, recovering and winning the Yom Kippur War, the rescue at Entebbe, the beeper attack, etc. In fact the eternal survival of Israel against all odds, is a miracle. Similarly, today we have something even greater than prophecy, and that’s when ancient prophecies actually come true (even greater than when they were just predicted some 3,000 years ago)! We were told that G-d will eventually gather the exiles and bring us back to Israel, our State, language and army will be revived, as will the desert of Israel, all of which has been fulfilled through G-d’s naturally directing the history of Israel together with the efforts of man, as well. In short, there are still undoubtedly occasional (even documented) cases of Divine intervention, especially on the national level of Israel, but it is preferable to live life within the regular rules of nature through observing Torah and mitzvot, because to be G-dly is even greater than to speak to Him.

  • Why Do Animals Suffer If They Have No Free Will?

    If animals can’t choose their fate the way humans can, why does the natural world involve so much of their suffering?

    Q. Why is the animal world full of chaos, if they don’t have free will why do they have to suffer?

    We obviously don’t understand G-d and why He created each detail the way that He did, but one thing is for sure: the Creation is many things but surely not chaotic! The exact ecological cycle is so precise and synchronized that its order is clear to all when we learned it in elementary school science. Like many things in life, if one just sees the small picture of the cat chasing the mouse, it looks chaotic, but a mature person knows to step back and see the whole picture where everything is davka in perfect order!

  • How Will the Dead Be Physically Resurrected?

    If a body was completely destroyed, how could the Revival of the Dead actually restore it?

    Q. The 13th principle of faith of the Rambam is the dead will be brought back to life. How will the dead be brought back to life if those whose bodies were completely destroyed in a battle, fire or plane crash ?

    The Revival of the Dead will obviously be miraculous and tradition teaches that even the sick, old or “destroyed” will also be healed. Tradition teaches that there is a bone called the “Luz” which always survives, and from that the dead will be revived (sounds something like cloning, but we’ll see how it will be done when the time comes, for it actually may be fulfilled via medical developments which are also G-dly revealed!).

  • Why Is the Torah’s Language on Cross-Dressing Deliberately Vague?

    The prohibition on wearing the other sex’s clothing uses terms that shift with culture – why leave it undefined?

    Q. In sefer Devarim where it speaks about the prohibition of cross dressing the terms for male and female clothing are different and on top of that the terms used for the clothing is not gender specific.

    The Torah is purposely ambiguous on this prohibition, because the definition of male and female dress differs from place to place and from time to time. Especially today in the western world, where there is a conscious and ideological statement involved, wishing to blur the gender differences, one should be especially careful regarding this prohibition, for it has direct and indirect influence on the already and unfortunately weakened family unit and clarity of identity, something very problematic for Jewish identity in the western world.

  • If Kingship Belongs to Yehuda, Why Did Shmuel Choose Shaul?

    The monarchy is promised to the tribe of Yehuda – so why was Israel’s first king, Shaul, chosen from Binyamin?

    Q. Why if the kingship is in Yehudah did Shmuel pick shaul?

    The Ramban explains that in the very source that teaches the kingdom belongs to Judah, the wording is “The (ruler’s) staff shall not leave (!) Judah” (Breishit 49, 10), that once kingship comes to Yehudah it should not be taken away. On the other hand, Shaul was appointed by G-d Himself (through his prophet Shmuel, who was directed to anoint him), despite coming from the tribe of Benjamin, because the kingship is not “leaving” or being “taken away” from Judah, for David had not yet received it.

  • Rav Kook on Animal Suffering and a Perfected Order

    Continuing the question of animal suffering, and what Rav Kook’s writings on vegetarianism actually contribute to it.

    Q. But why does the order have to be full of pain, I’m not talking about humans who have free will but animals who don’t have a destiny and can’t change their lives. why do they suffer even at a small level, you can answer that predators are lowering the population and that it’s in perfect order, is the answer to the problem is that we don’t know. I hope this doesn’t sound condescending.

    Rav Kook deals at length with your questions, and you should study his “Vision of Vegetarianism” (part of which has recently been translated into English). Nevertheless, in short, he explains that just as the prophets suffered unpopularity, and even were sometimes assassinated as a direct outcome of their rebuking, so too, the Jewish people have paid a heavy price for our role as the “Nation of Prophets”, the “Conscience of Mankind” and the “Light to the Nations”. Similarly the rest of mankind and in fact all of creation is based upon the framework of Free Will for mankind, to choose between good and bad. Part of which is to hear rebuke, and see examples in life, in history and in the animal world as well, which educate man to differentiate between right/moral and wrong/evil when he sees it.

  • Original Sin vs. the Yetzer Hara – What’s the Real Difference?

    Clarifying where Judaism’s concept of the evil inclination actually diverges from the Christian idea of original sin.

    Q. I engaged in a conversation with a Christian and wasn’t quite able to make a clear distinction between their notion of “original sin” and our notion of the two impulses. Our position is that man has two impulses the yetzer hara and the yetzer ha-tov. Man isn’t necessarily born evil, he simply has an inclination to do evil which can be tamed by performance of the mitzvot. He (the Christian) responded by claiming that it’s inconsistent because we Jews acknowledge that man is flawed by nature, but leave open the possibility that man can become “perfect” by our performance of the mitzvot, that the messiah we wait for will be a man claiming to be perfect and the Sanhedrin we establish will be led by “perfect” men. We both recognized that there are NO perfect men. I have to be honest, I didn’t know how to respond. How would the rabbinical literature respond to this.

    Please excuse me, but there are several inaccuracies mentioned here. For reasons of clarification, we sometimes refer to 2 “different” drives, but in fact there is no drive which is inherently “bad”, and surely no “original sin”. Man has a G-dly soul which is inherently good! In fact, everything G-d created is good unless man, with his free will (which is also good), misuses it. Eating is a good drive, but if you over-do it, you turn it into a yetzer-ra, a negative inclination. Same thing with sleep, sexual attraction or really everything is good, unless one takes it out of its proper proportion. In other words, man is not flawed by nature, but we have Free Will to choose bad, if we sometimes wish. Nevertheless, as soon as we sincerely regret, apologize and resolve to improve, that is as perfect as man can get: the strive for perfection is as perfect as you and I, Moshe Rabbenu and the future messiah/Sanhedrin (and your friend!), can get. Only G-d is perfect, and messiah, who will be a man, will not be perfect and neither will the Sanhedrin who are mortal flesh and blood (what he mentioned to the contrary is a totally Christian and anti-Jewish idea, but it is true what you both agreed in the end that “there are NO perfect men”).