Category: Q&A

  • Could There Be Another Exile?

    An ancient tradition about a third and final return, and the population numbers that suggest it’s already happened.

    Q. Is it possible that Zionism is just another false messiah? Especially with the nuclear threat from Iran, shouldn’t we be worried about another exile?

    Our rabbis cite an ancient tradition that Israel will not return to the Holy Land until the third and final redemption. The first was from Egypt, the second from Babylon, and the third will be the last (Tanchuma Shoftim 9). If those 42,360 Jews from Babylon were considered a “return”, so how much more so, today, when more than 100 times (!) that number have come home (7,300,000), that we are undoubtedly witnessing the third, and accordingly, the final return, and that we’re here to stay. Elsewhere, the number mentioned in the final return is 600,000 army-aged men (Yalkut Shimoni, Hoshea 518), and we passed that number in the Six Day War, when 670,000 men participated.

    Our rabbis actually deal explicitly with the modern threat which you mentioned, and tell us not to fear (Sanhedrin 106a). To the contrary, Iran should start worrying: “Woe to the nation who tries to prevent the Father from redeeming His son (Israel). Woe to the fool who interferes with the Lion (G-d) who wishes to mate with His beloved lioness (Israel, after such a long 2,000 year separation)!”

  • What Does It Mean When Chanukah and Thanksgiving Overlap?

    A case against celebrating Thanksgiving at all, built on why exile was never meant to feel like home.

    Q. What’s the meaning of this year’s rare overlap of Hanukkah and Thanksgiving?

    The issue of Jews celebrating Thanksgiving is problematic. Our presence in exile is a punishment and no reason to party (“because of our sins we were exiled”). The Meshech Chochma warned well before the Holocaust, those who feel that Berlin is their Jerusalem, a terrible storm will eventually uproot them and remind them not to feel “too German” or “too American”. Moslems and Christians can be Americans, for they are religions and not nationalities. Contrarily, even an atheist is still Jewish, for Israel/Judaism is also our nationality, not just our religion. America may consider Jews as “one of them” from their point of view, but that clearly doesn’t change Judaism’s objective and eternal definition of our identity. Moshe was not buried in Israel as a punishment for identifying himself as an Egyptian instead of Israeli (Dvarim Rabba 82, 8), even though he truly grew up in Egypt and never was in Israel, because all Jews wherever they are, should always identify themselves as Hebrews from the Land of Israel. Accordingly, most poskim (aside from R. Soloveitchik) feel like R. Moshe Feinstein (Or.Ch. v, 20), R. Hutner, R. Menashe Klein that one shouldn’t celebrate Thanksgiving at all, for America is not our home, and her holidays are not ours.

    Just as there’s no significance that Xmas often overlaps with Chanuka, even more so with the rarity of Th.G., except for the significance that, like the Jonathan Pollard case, it’s an opportunity to help Jews clarify their real identity, their real homeland, and their real holidays, when tremendous “thanksgiving” to G-d is truly necessary and obligatory, for example, Israel Independence Day- when G-d expressly gave the Jewish nation our real and permanent homeland.

  • Must a Forgotten Loan Be Returned to a Non-Jewish Owner?

    A scrupulous question about a borrowed notebook, and why the answer is also about kiddush Hashem.

    Q. A while ago someone (not Jewish) “lent” me a notebook, to use in class, because one day I did not have one. She did not say it was a gift, however, it is something you use to write on it, so you surely can’t give it back to the original owner in its original state. I used it only for that day, so some pages are still blank. Moreover, I am pretty sure she forgot about it. Do I still have the halachic obligation to give it back to that person?

    Firstly, allow me to admire the fact that you are as meticulous and caring about mitzvot between man and his fellow, as between man and G-d, for both are religious obligations! You definitely should return the rest of the notebook, for the common practice is to lend pages to fellow students, but not to give an entire notebook. In addition, to not return it may inadvertently cause a chilul Hashem (a desecration of G-d’s Name), for Jews must set an example and be at least (!) as morally careful as is commonly accepted, that she shouldn’t go around saying, or even thinking, that Jews don’t act properly. To the contrary, by returning it, you are doing a Kiddush Hashem (sanctifying His Name), by doing positive “public relations” for G-d and His People, in addition to cleaning your conscience, your soul, and your home from any non-kosher property.

  • Do ‘Sheidim’ and Demons Really Exist?

    The Talmud mentions them, the Rambam rationalizes them — and either way, only G-d and man have free will.

    Q. I saw a few books mentioning Shedim (demons) and even the Gemara mentions them. I always thought that demons was a primitive superstition but then, it seems our sages believed in them! Maybe I have a misunderstanding of what Shedim are?

    Shalom! There are many things in life beyond that which is seen by the naked eye, and among them are what we call malachim (angels) and sheidim (negative angels). As opposed to other religions, Judaism believes that they have no free-will, are not independent, and are just robot-like messengers doing the will of G-d. This can include germs, viruses etc. The Talmud mentions beings called sheidim, but also states, “one who worries about them- they bother him, while he who doesn’t worry about them, they don’t bother him” (Psachim 110b). Similarly, among the rishonim there are different opinions. The Rashba, for example, talks about them but the Rambam, whenever he must, explains the concept in rational terms (e.g. Hil. Rotze’ach 12, 5). Nevertheless, all agree that man and G-d, and no other forces, run our lives. Only we and G-d have free will, and accordingly we’re not allowed to believe in superstitions or the like. Many point out that certain powers that may have existed, aren’t found any more today (e.g. Magen Avraham 173, 1), and Rav Kook adds from the kabbalists that in the Holy Land of Israel, all the more so, that one need not worry about sheidim.

  • What Is a Mamzer, and Why Is the Status So Severe?

    Not the same as ‘born out of wedlock’ — the actual definition is narrower and more specific than assumed.

    Q. Is a “mamzer” a bastard, and why isn’t he allowed to marry a regular Jew? How could a mamzer exist when there was a death penalty, for if the parents are killed, he wouldn’t be born?

    A “mamzer” is one born from an illicit relationship so severe that marriage would not even “take effect”, even if they tried to get married. For example, conception from an incestuous relationship (like brother-sister), or a married woman with another man (if she hasn’t received a kosher divorce from her husband) would be a mamzer. In such a case, the parents are believed regarding the child’s situation, but they can’t be punished on self-testimony. Accordingly, the child is born and the parents, not put to death. Alternatively, another case could be if witnesses against the parents would only come forth after the child is born. On the other hand, the term “bastard” in English is used regarding a child born out of wedlock, but such a child is not (!) considered a mamzer, because that man and woman could marry each other. It’s forbidden for any couple to have intimate relations before marriage, nevertheless, a child conceived then is not a mamzer. One explanation of the severity of the punishment is that often, the fire of desire may blind a person to think that he doesn’t care about his eventual punishment. Nevertheless, if there’s 1 thing that may deter them, it’s concern for their children, for one usually cares about them even more than for himself.

  • Wasn’t Sending Away Hagar and Yishmael Wrong?

    Avraham himself objected — the text is explicit that this was G-d’s decision, not his.

    Q. How could Abraham dismiss Hagar and Yishmael in such a way?

    Your question is on G-d, not on Abraham- for it was Abr. who did not (!) want to chase away Hagar and Yishmael (Gen. 21, “and it was very (!) bad in the eyes of Abr.”), but G-d nevertheless told him to do so, as He explains there explicitly, so that it should be clear to all (and forever!) that Isaac, and not Yishmael, is the sole continuation of the Chosen Nation. Additionally, although the Torah is usually very concise when it comes to giving insignificant details, G-d does (!) feel it significant to write explicitly that Abr. himself (not through his servants) made sure to give them food and water (see there), and apparently she was heading back to her father’s family (as was the custom for divorced women). The Torah infers that their provisions were enough, but the problem is that they got lost and wandered [21, 14-15, the Hebrew word “vateta”, is translated in the classic translations and commentaries (Unkolos and Targ. Yonatan, Rashbam, Ibn Ezra, etc.): “and got lost”] and only consequently of their getting lost, they ran out of water. This is also clear from the use of this root, in other places that it’s always “to leave the path” (Psalms 119, 110; Ezek, 14, 11), or in our context, to get lost. It should also be pointed out that Hagar knew her way back to Egypt (see Gen. 16, 6 and on), but somehow here, she got lost.

  • Are Midrashim Meant to Be Taken Literally?

    The Ramban disagrees with Rashi on this, and has a complex approach — a working test for telling which is which.

    Q. Are we meant to take midrashim literally?

    The field of midrash is very complex and includes several different types. Interestingly, the Ramban sometimes disagrees strongly with the Ibn Ezra for veering from the midrash of our sages, yet it’s not infrequent for him to do the same, differing with certain midrashim cited by Rashi! The answer to this apparent contradiction is that some, probably most, midrashim are not factual traditions but rather educational vehicles for teaching us philosophic or spiritual idea/s, or how to act properly, while others apparently do come to fill-in ancient traditions. Some possible identification signs for the first category (non-factual) may include midrashim where there are different contradicting opinions, or those many midrashim which “frame” our forefathers as doing sins they clearly didn’t do or exaggerating light offenses into serious ones, to serve as a “springboard” framework to educate others. Similarly, midrashim which seem esoteric would usually fall into this category. On the other hand, midrashim which don’t have an educational message, but are rather fact-filling traditions, like the names of Avraham’s or Shimshon’s respective mothers, may be meant factually. Unfortunately, it’s often difficult to tell whether a certain midrash is meant to be taken literally or not. In short, all midrashim are true (in terms of their message), yet not all are historically factual, and the best thing to do is to study them with a specialist who is experienced in the field and constantly search for the deeper meaning.

  • Should Jews Go Into Politics?

    In a Jewish State, Rav Z.Y. Kook called it ‘G-dly politics’ — not a materialistic distraction.

    Q. Should Jews go into politics?

    Rav Zvi Yehuda Kook would often say that politics in the context of a Jewish State is “G-dly Politics”. The welfare of each and every Jew, the Israeli national security and health, even the national budget, are all halachic, G-dly and idealistic issues, and surely not “materialistic distractions”. R. Yisrael Salanter is quoted as saying that “my fellow-Jew’s materialism is my spirituality!”, for being caring and altruistic is to be G-dly, and how much more so on a national level. This type of national and military politics is exactly what preoccupied our spiritual heroes who we are meant to emulate (!) as the ideal Jews, like Moshe and Joshua, Kings David and Solomon, etc. These halachot, of how to run a moral and G-dly economy, army, and politics are detailed extensively in the Rambam (Hil. M’lachim), and present one of the major challenges of modern poskim. This is a central ideological reason why G-d created Israel as a nation, with a land, language, economy and army, and not just a religion. On the other hand, if you’re asking regarding the involvement of Jews in non-Jewish politics in their countries of exile, Jews are not meant to be living there, and are generally better off keeping a low profile. “A light for the nations”, (“L’Or Goyim”, see Isaiah 42 and 49)- is always (!) in the context of being a unique nation in the Land of Israel, for other nations to emulate. Thank G-d we live in a time when this is once again, possible and from now on, the norm, which we should focus on constantly improving on all the aforementioned accounts.

  • Are Fewer Ba’alei Tshuva Religious-Zionist?

    No hard data exists — but a theory for why an all-or-nothing reaction happens, and why it not only need not but should not.

    Q. Am I mistaken or do most of the Ba’alei Tshuva belong to the less-Zionist element?

    As far as I know, there has yet to be a comprehensive survey, nevertheless, there are definitely some “repentants” who so regret their previous lifestyle, that they go to the opposite extreme, and give up even the positive Zionist, nationalist or modern aspect. For some, especially the younger element, the complex message of religious-Zionism, that tries to take the best of all worlds, and believe that modernism, Zionism and the State of Israel, and Tzahal don’t at all contradict religion. To the contrary, the students of Rav Kook and organizations like Rosh Yehudi strongly believe that the same G-d who gave us the Torah, still runs history and over the past century, has gathered the exiles, revived the Holy Land, the Holy Language, the Holy army and Jewish State. In fact, Rav Kook wrote that anyone who deals with “teshuva” today, but ignores the modern prophetic return of the gathering of the exiles, is unfortunately ignoring & neglecting his strongest proof that the G-d of Israel is alive, runs the world and is currently fulfilling His ancient prophecies.

    G-d is the One who also revealed to us modernity, computers, medicine, etc. and all of these are gifts which are meant to be used for advancing Torah, goodness, idealism, health, fertility, education etc. and not chalila “void of G-d” nor “tests of the Satan”! It’s clearly easier to understand simple black-and -white messages, but our world is complex. It’s also easier to deride and criticize all who disagree with “me”, but the Torah is positive-minded, and believes that we should all take the positive ideology and aspect of truth from every movement, because G-d wants us to cooperate with all Jews and all truths (one of His 13 traits). Additionally, there are a considerable number of Jews in different stages of the process of Tshuva, without leaving their jobs or communities, whose introspection is “invisible” but is nevertheless, taking place.

  • Should You Pay a Stranger to Say Kaddish?

    Three explanations for an old custom, and why it’s often better left unmentioned to a non-religious family.

    Q. Is it true that for a stranger to say kaddish without a fee has no benefit for the soul?

    There obviously is benefit for the soul when every kaddish is said, even without pay. What you heard is probably based upon the Beit Yosef (Y.D. 403) where it seems that for one who isn’t a relative, it is preferred that he be paid. The following explanations are suggested: a. There is that much more merit for the mitzvah of the deceased when he or his family have personally influenced or induced a mitzvah, even through pay. That way it can clearly be considered that they have a part in the mitzvah.

    b. The “kaddish-sayer” will feel more of an obligation and will be that much more conscientious in saying it properly and with the proper concentration (kavana).

    c. It is usually a relatively poor person who supports himself through such an “occupation”, and therefore, one adds the mitzvah and merit of charity.

    In any event, it’s always better, if there are sons, for them to say the kaddish.

    In addition, if the family isn’t religious, and they may not understand the aforementioned explanations, and may even resent the fee. This may cause a chilul Hashem (disgracing G-d’s Name) and accordingly, it’s better not to ask for a fee, for a chilul Hashem is one of the most severe transgressions, and surely disturbs the honor of the deceased.