Category: Q&A

  • Should Women Bow During the High Holiday Service?

    Three explanations for a common custom, and the one rule that applies regardless: don’t stand out.

    Q. On Rosh Hashana and Yom Kippur when the congregation bows down on the floor during Aleynu, and the Service of the Kohen Gadol, should women bow, as well?

    Like many questions, this should really be addressed to your local rabbi. In general, one should do like the local custom, so if the women in your shul bow or refrain from doing so, that’s what you should be doing. It’s definitely wrong for only individuals to bow, for it’s “yuhara” (the prohibition of “showing off” religiously).

    Several reasons are offered to explain why in many shuls, women don’t bow:

    a. R. Chaim Soloveichik of Brisk said that the prostration is in memory of what we used to do in the Beit HaMikdash (Temple). Accordingly, women, who were not in the Azara section there, didn’t bow, so also today, there’s no reason for them to do so. b. Some feel that even if there are no men watching, it’s not a tzanua (modest) position for women. c. Sometimes the women’s section was just too small and there was no room for everyone to prostrate!

    It’s important to note, that when bowing onto the floor, you should place a towel or talit to separate between your face (not your knees!) and the ground, for it’s forbidden to bow down on the floor outside the Beit Hamikdash. Regarding those who wish to put under their knees so as not to get dirty, it’s okay, but don’t think that that’s enough. Ktiva vaChatima Tova!

  • When an Apology Would Offend the Person You’re Apologizing To

    You spoke badly about a friend who has no idea — so how do you make it right before Yom Kippur?

    Q. I spoke negatively about someone and wish to apologize before Yom Kippur. On the other hand, this friend isn’t aware at all of what I did, and asking his forgiveness will both notify and deeply offend him, which is the opposite of what I want. What should I do?

    Unfortunately, this is a common problem. Although l’chatchila, one must specify exactly what he did in order to truly apologize properly, nevertheless, if the apology itself will offend, than you shouldn’t (Mishna Brura 606, 3). On the other hand, you must apologize!

    R. Yisrael Salanter writes that thank G-d, we Jews have Yom Kippur, a time where everyone is conciliating and apologizing to everyone. This is the ideal situation when you can sincerely ask for forgiveness (“If I did anything wrong”) without going into detail, just like he probably goes and apologizes to many people, whether he offended them or not. Consequently, he will whole-heartedly forgive you, without your offending him. Chatima Tova!

  • Lesser-Known Laws of Sukkot

    From wobbly pre-fab sukkah walls to the ring on your finger during the lulav shake.

    Q. What laws should I know about Sukkot?

    We’ll mention several common, yet less-known points. Firstly, it’s mentioned explicitly in the Torah (Lev. 23, 43) to remember why we sit in the sukkah: commemorating the exodus from Egypt and the divine protection we enjoyed for 40 years afterwards in the desert. It’s always good to know why we do any mitzvah, but here, it’s inherently essential to remember each time. In addition, the sukkah walls must be stationary. This is a common problem with many “pre-fab” soft-sided sukkot which wave in the wind. The Chazon Ish allows for it to move 24 cm. in each direction, which does leave some leniency. The solution is to attach 4 taut horizontal elastic bands or wire (either inside or outside the sukkah)), with less than 23 cm. between them (and between the ground and the bottom band), which altogether, must reach a height of at least 80 cm.

    Regarding taking the lulav and etrog, many forget to remove their rings from their fingers, which disconnect your hand from the species. If this happens, then Ashkenazim must retake the 4 species and shake them again, just without making the bracha, while Sefaradim needn’t do so, if they forgot. Also, on the first day, there is a special requirement that the species belong to you. If you wish to borrow, you must ask the owner to give them as a gift, even though he knows that you will return them afterwards. This solution is only valid if the owner is over Bar/Bat-mitzvah.

  • Are Secular Newspapers Off-Limits?

    Staying informed is a real value — but the editors know exactly which photos they’re choosing.

    Q. Do inappropriate pictures in newspapers make them forbidden?

    It’s definitely important to know what’s going on with Am Yisrael, especially because we’re in the center of the world news so often, and we must know what we should/can do (e.g. if there’s danger of war, if we should apply political pressure on the Prime Minister of Israel or President of the U.S., or volunteering to look for a missing child, donating money or clothing if there’s a fire, etc.), and also what to daven (pray) for. For this reason, the Netziv and many great rabbis regularly read news journals. On the other hand, one isn’t allowed to do a mitzvah through doing something wrong (“mitzvah haba’a al y’dei aveira”). Even if you are accustomed to looking away when seeing immodest dress in the street, it’s almost impossible to avoid when your task at hand is to purposely look at the paper. In addition, the editors and advertisers deliberately choose especially attractive and provocative pictures, so it’s even more problematic. Listening to the radio news is one solution. Even better, thank G-d, today there are religious or kosher radio stations, websites and newspapers like Arutz Sheva and Makor Rishon, which are fine in this regard, and hopefully also regarding lashon hara (slander/gossip), which is no less problematic, often even more (here, the radio doesn’t help, except for its brevity!). May I suggest my Hebrew article “Newspapers- Mitzva or Prohibition?”, found on the web.

  • Shaving on Zionist Holidays During the Omer

    A national celebration gets the same leniency the Omer period already grants a personal one.

    Q. Are you allowed to shave, get a haircut, or hear music on Yom HaAtzma’ut and Yom Yerushalayim or is it prohibited like the rest of the Omer period?

    Just as an individual who has a personal celebration (e.g. the sandak, mohel and father at a circumcision ceremony) during the Omer period, is allowed to do all of the above, how much more so is it allowed on a national celebration like Israeli Independence Day or Yom Yerushalayim, which were proclaimed by the Chief Rabbinate as national holidays after the War of Independence and the Six Day War. There is an interesting precedent in Mo’ed L’Chol Chai (p. 37), where R. Chaim Fallaggi, a leading posek from Turkey, allowed the Jews of Angora to shave annually on the 11th of Iyar, even for a local holiday commemorating salvation from danger, despite the Omer period. The reason is because the aforementioned customs of mourning are not even mentioned in the Talmud, and accordingly aren’t so severe and are easily superseded by the rabbis and allowed when there is a legitimate mitzvah or religious celebration. How much more so regarding a national reason for all Jews to celebrate our God-given Jewish State, only 3 years after the Holocaust, and His lightening-like victory over those who wished to annihilate Israel in only 6 days.

  • Baseball Caps on Shabbat

    The halacha of a portable umbrella, applied to a stiff brim — with a tape measure recommended.

    Q. Is one allowed to wear a baseball cap on Shabbat?

    The Shulchan Aruch (301, 40) says that one is not allowed to wear a firm brim for shade on their hat on Shabbat if it protrudes more than a “tefach” (8 cm.= or in the U.S., about 3.5 inches), for the same reason that you can’t use a portable umbrella (“ohel arai”). On the other hand, if the brim is soft and floppy, than it would be allowed. The adult baseball hat brims which I measured were less than that amount so accordingly, it would be fine (although some men’s hats or women’s caps are problematic). Additionally, in many places it might not be considered “shabbosdik” (befitting the spirit of Shabbat) to wear one, so you should ask your local halachic authority if this is the case in your community. Also, some local authorities may prefer prohibiting them, so people won’t come to wearing cowboy hats or “sombreros” which are often more than the 8 cm. and not floppy. Accordingly, it’s a local “call” (and just to be sure, measure your brim before Shabbat!).

    With Love of Israel, Rav Ari Shvat

  • Can You Renounce Being Jewish?

    You can’t — and that’s framed here as the good fortune, not the burden.

    Q. How can I renounce being Jewish?

    You are very fortunate that you cannot renounce your Judaism, for Judaism is not just a religion but also a national identity- even non-religious Jews are still 100% Jewish! You are lucky enough to have been born to the Chosen People, who have, in the words of Mark Twain, “contributed more… and done more to civilize mankind than any nation in history”. The reason this virtue is irreversible is because only the ignorant would dream of leaving this great nation, so G-d does them a favor and basically “forces” them to discover their good fortune! Like a kingly loving father, who wants to give his son a great gift, but his son isn’t mature or learned enough to realize why this gift is so great- the father will not give his foolish son any choice, but keeps the gift waiting until the son understands. Aren’t you curious why the Jewish people outlast the others, as promised by the Bible? Why the nations of the world are so preoccupied with the Jews and the small State of Israel, way out of proportion to our size? Be proud that your nation brought monotheism (belief in One G-d) and morality, the two greatest achievements of mankind, to the world. In short: do yourself a favor, and learn more about yourself.

  • Grafted Citrus Trees and Kilayim

    A backyard orchard raises the question of forbidden cross-species grafting — and why citrus gets a pass.

    Q. We bought some citrus trees some years ago without paying proper attention to the fact that they are grafted (we live in Israel). The bark of the rootstock below the grafting point looks slightly different from the bark of the upper tree, but it also looks like some type of citrus tree. It is no longer possible to get clear information, whether the grafting was done in a halachically permitted way within one species or if there is a problem with kilyaim (the prohibited grafting of different species). Is it permitted to keep these trees which are possibly kilayim?

    Shalom, After checking with a citrus specialist, it turns out that citrus fruit can only be grafted upon other citrus bases. According to the Chazon Ish, all citrus fruits are considered halachically one species regarding grafting, accordingly there are no problem regarding grafting with each other. Even though some poskim disagree with him, most fruit tree nurseries in Israel graft according to the halacha, otherwise the rabbinical supervisors won’t let them sell to any of the orchards which market to Tnuva (which has almost a monopoly on fruit), which would be very counterproductive for them. In short, although one should check out the “history” of a tree before buying it, in your situation, there’s no problem to plant and enjoy the fruit- and as a matter of fact, it’s even a mitzvah to plant, especially fruit trees, in the Land of Israel (Mitzvat Yishuv HaAretz)! With Love of Israel, Rav Ari Shvat

  • Why Could Noach Eat Animals We Now Call Impure?

    Impure-animal restrictions are a Torah category — they never applied to Noach, or to anyone else outside it.

    Q. G-d clearly punished the world because of the sin of the people. If there was no Torah, then why was sin punished? After Noach left the ark, Hashem said he could eat all the moving animals of the earth. I understand that concept of pure and impure animals was known by Noach. Why did Hashem tell Noach he could eat all meats while he may not sacrifice impure animals, and He later forbids those same meats?

    The world was punished in the time of Noach because they didn’t observe even the most basic and elementary morality, for which every human being was obligated, even before the giving of the Torah. Idolatry, adultery, murder, and theft are not so demanding, yet even that, they transgressed. Impure animals are not forbidden for non-Jewish consumption, not before the giving of the Torah, and not afterwards, not for Noach and not for President Trump. Just as if I, as a non-Cohen, were to give a sacrifice or chant the priestly blessing, it wouldn’t have Torah significance, and similarly, there’s no reason for me not to go to cemeteries. So too, there’s no reason for a non-Jew to wear tfilin, nor abstain from bacon. Even if Noach gave kosher sacrifices, that has nothing to do with his own personal diet. In short, G-d is exact regarding every commandment, regarding who, what, where, when and how they are obligated or exempt, and it’s not our place, nor Noah’s, to “invent” new commandments when they don’t apply.

  • Can We Psychoanalyze Tanach’s Heroes?

    Modern methods can help — but ancient father-son relationships weren’t built on modern assumptions.

    Q. What were the psychological consequences of the Akeida upon Yitzchak?

    In general, we are supposed to learn from our parents and biblical forefathers, and it’s not our place to analyze them. That being said, the Tanach is (!) meant to be studied in depth for all generations, where in addition to the oral traditions, we can occasionally use current methods, sciences and analyses (constantly keeping in mind that we’re not talking about “average” people. Just like the Chafetz Chaim, Rambam or Einstein would be hard to understand using conventional methods geared for “average” people). Another problem is that it’s usually much too speculative; for example, we know nothing about Yitzchak’s, or most other Tanachic characters’, relationship with their parents. One also should be careful not to suggest anachronistic explanations or conjectures, because the father-child relationship was totally different in ancient societies, especially when, again, we’re talking about out-of-the ordinary figures. Avraham’s extraordinary kindness which is held as the example for generations (Micha 7, 20, and as demonstrated regarding his saving Lot, trying to save Sodom, the guests, etc.), in addition to the acceptance of child sacrifices in the ancient Middle East, surely brought Yitzchak to see the Akeida in a totally different light than the “average” and modern child-father relationship would see it!