Untangling apparently conflicting traditions about how long, and for whom, punishment in Gehinom (hell) actually lasts.
Q. Dear Rabbi, I have a few questions. My first question is, is it possible that there are differences of opinion regarding is the gehinoma only 12 months or can it last over 12 months? My second question is can it also be that there is a dispute between those who have learned what is meant by eternal gehinom!? Because I heard some say eternal gehinom is forever and then I heard there are other opinions like for example only 4 generation… and my last question is regarding kaf-hakela as we know it’s translated as a “slingshot” of the soul but I heard that Kafakela also has other punishments besides flinging the soul, is that right? And what does it mean that kafakela has several levels? Thanks in advance
The classic case of one who goes to gehinom is 12 months, and then he goes to heaven, but in extreme cases of evil, they will sometimes stay punished forever (=eternal). Kaf Hakela literally means “sling-shotting” the soul, but it’s a parable, and is a spiritual punishment and not a physical one. In general, as opposed to other religions, Judaism is much more preoccupied with us acting G-dly in this world, and that’s why the Tanach doesn’t refer that much to the reward and punishment in the world to come. Focus your time and efforts to be good in this world, and don’t worry, the reward will arrive in the world to come.
Leave a Reply