If relocating theoretically shifts which customs apply, why do Ashkenazim and Sephardim keep their distinct minhagim anyway?
Q. Does the halacha state that when one moves, he takes on the new minhagim instead of his old ones? If so, why should people keep Ashkenazi or Sefaradi minhagim in Israel since they are not in those lands anymore?
That’s theoretically true, but we don’t yet have a Sanhedrin to decide which custom should be accepted by everyone “across the board”. Kibbutz Galuyot, the gathering of the exiles, by definition, demands addressing this question, and the Sanhedrin shoule be revived asap, but until then, we basically continue our previous customs, unless there is, as you inferred, a clear “Israeli custom”, e.g. finishing Arvit during the week with “Shomer Amo Yisrael La’ad” and omitting “Baruch Hashem l’Olam…” as was accepted in the diaspora; accepting Shabbat 24 minutes before sunset (not 18) except Y’rushalayim and Petach Tikva which do 40 minutes; obviously doing 1 day of Yom Tov; saying “Sim Shalom” instead of “Shalom Rav” at Shabbat Mincha, etc. Regarding pronunciation, in most places in Israel, the Sefaradic pronunciation has been accepted, unless in your shul there are many varied customs.
Leave a Reply