Category: Weekly Letters

  • Q.Cheer when Terrorists are Killed?

    Question: What is the Torah’s approach to the killing of thousands of Hamas terrorists and especially their leaders who are being killed by Tzahal and the Mossad? Are we any different than the Azzans who distribute candy after terrorist attacks? I davka remember learning that Hashem told the angels not to sing when the Egyptians drowned in the sea! Answer: Any semi-intelligent person knows to differentiate between celebrating the joyful killing of innocent women and babies in their beds, and retaliating to punish and deter those vicious murderers. It’s true, King Shlomo said “Do not rejoice when your enemy falls” (Mishlei 24), but a few chapters before that he already stated: “There’s happiness when the wicked are vanished”! (ibid, 11). The Gemara itself asks about this apparent contradiction (Megillah 16a), and answers through the differentiation: to be sad over the fall of a fellow Jew with whom you are in an argument (that you are not allowed to rejoice), but regarding wicked gentiles who hate and kill Jews, we are not only allowed, but should even be happy when they fall. As Shlomo’s father David HaMelech wrote (Tehilim 58) “Let the righteous rejoice, for he has seen the vengeance of his people…”. In general, anyone who has learned in yeshiva or midrasha knows that it’s always important to see quotes “inside”, in their context, including the source that you quoted. Chazal specify that Hashem said to the angels (not to the Jews!), not to sing at the Red Sea, because they were not parties to the suffering- they weren’t the ones being persecuted and killed by the Egyptians (Megilla 10b). But we who were persecuted by the evil Pharaoh and his army, of course need to thank G-d for the victory. We say every morning the prayer of “Az yashir Moshe u’vnei Yisrael…”, and Chizkiyahu was even punished for not singing to Hashem after his victory over Ashur (Sanhedrin 94a). If my brother is killed and daughter raped by someone, Hashem created us that it’s totally normal and even healthy to feel hatred towards such Hitlers and terrorists. Ahavat Yisrael includes not only feeling love for my brothers, but getting angry and when necessary, fighting and taking vengeance to come to their rescue and subsequently, celebrate victory (that’s many of our holidays!). Of course, we would prefer for our enemies to repent and also love Israel (or at least stop killing and raping us), but in the meantime, let’s not be naïve. As Shlomo himself wrote, “There’s a time for war, and a time for peace (Kohelet 3, 8), and let’s not be childish in confusing the two. Rav Kook writes (Chazon HaTzimchonut, 19) that idealism must be sincere and not a “bluff”. Be honest, and don’t pretend to fool yourself or others, that you’re on an unrealistic level of spirituality and morality, when you don’t really feel it. Similarly he writes that morality is an extremely central ideal, but there are others, as well. For example, justice, truth and love of Israel are also G-dly traits that we are meant to emulate in our “imitateo Dei”, as well. In fact, Rav Kook adds that one who pretends to love foreigners (and how much more so, enemies!) with a similar love and loyalty which he has for his brothers, sons and daughters is apparently showing that doesn’t really know what love is (Orot Yisrael 8, 5)!

    Yes, Christians believe in “resist not evil” and “turning the other cheek” to let one’s enemy slap him there, as well, but Judaism clearly disagrees, believing it’s immoral not to fight and deter the immoral. The war against wars is what bezH will eventually bring peace, and is actually super-moral. In short, it’s natural, healthy, G-dly, a great mitzvah and occasion to thank Hashem when we succeed in killing those satanic evil who joyfully killed and raped us, just as we do in Pesach, Purim, Chanukah, Yom Yerushalayim, etc., and that’s part of Ahavat Yisrael. As a matter of fact, part of our mistake and misconception which enabled the Hamas attack on Simchat Torah, was that we didn’t realize their level of evil. Not being naive can prevent future tragedies. With Love of Israel, Ari Shvat (Chwat)

  • Life is to be Lived- Not Conquered

    Rav Kook on Orot HaMilchama (part vii)- link to the recording: Description: Rav Kook takes the nations to task for preaching morality, but then “losing it” as soon as it comes to war. He connects this with the unrealistic Christian teaching “to turn the other cheek” and “resist not evil”, as opposed to the more realistic Torah approach which gradually raises Israel to a level that even our army is moral. The idea is to harmonize all of the forces of life, rather than conquer them. One who gets into the mindset of “conquering” himself, will probably be unhappy in his constant struggles, and may eventually becoming a “Conquerer”, which isn’t such a compliment. Here’s the link to the recording. Hope you enjoy!

    https://www.yutorah.org/lectures/1084860

    ‪שנשמע בשורות טובות ישועות ונחמות!Rav Ari Shvat

  • Q. How can I explain and justify Israel to my gentile friends, and what is the solution to peace with the Arabs in the Middl

    e East? Answer: The Tanach, Chazal, history and logic show that it’s unwise and immoral to give in to a violent person, nation or religion, but rather, defend one’s self when attacked, and whenever possible, pre-empt and prevent the attack before it’s staged (הבא להרגך השכם להרגו”, Sanhedrin 72a). It’s beneficial to the victim, to society and adds the Rambam, also to the evil person himself (Moreh Nevuchim 3, 35)! Evil people don’t have many friends, happy marriages, or good relationships with their children, or at all. In addition, decisions should be based upon truth and justice: who has the rights to the Land of Israel? Most of the world accepts the Tanach which explicitly and continuously promises Israel to the Nation of Israel. So even says the Quoran itself (7, 137: “הענקנו בירושה לעם שחשב עצמו כחלש את הארץ אשר ברכנו אותה, את מזרחה ואת מערבה, באופן שאלוהים מילא בצורה מושלמת את דברו הטוב על בני ישראל, עקב האריכם רוחם”.”) Historically and politically, whether one decides who owns the land by who was here first (the Jews were in Israel 2,000 years before Islam even began!), or if you decide by the current modern situation, either way, the rights to Israel belongs to the Jews. What logic is there to davka only look at that temporary middle period when the Jews were forcibly exiled from our land before 1948?! Since Yehoshua 3300 years ago, there have always been Jews in Israel, and even though there were also some Arabs over the last 1400 years, they never had a state here, and were living, like the Jews, just as individuals and tribes, as opposed to Israel who had a 1st, a 2nd and now the 3rd Commonwealth and independent state. Regarding the solution, the original and best plan, for both Arabs and Jews, was that of Montefiore, Baron Rothschild and the Jewish National Fund (JNF), to buy the land, “acre after acre, dunam by dunam”, and that way we fulfill the covenant of G-d with Avraham, Yitzchak and Yaacov, to inherit the Land of Israel in a peaceful way, where both sides benefit. What ruined the plan was when the Arabs in the early 1920’s issued a “death penalty” on any Arab selling land to Jews. This racist and immoral vigilante “penalty” stands to this very day (wonder, why are the UN and Harvard so quiet on this issue?), so that even though most Arabs would be more than happy to be instant millionaires (the price is exorbitant because the Israelis really want to buy it at any price), move to a quieter country and solve the Middle East problems, they can’t allow themselves to do so, because of those Islamic fanatics, who would kill their own brothers. There are thousands of acres left empty because they are too close to Jewish lands and pose a security risk for that aforementioned terror towards Jews, but the unfortunate Arabs can’t sell us the land, for fear of their own brothers’ fanaticism

    Just as Islamic terror is a world-wide problem even in the Arab countries, so it is in Israel as well, and only a Jew-hater would stubbornly differentiate and here, they blame the democratic peace-loving victim, rather than the fanatic Muslim aggressors. The maps have changed several times over the last 75 years, because the Arabs tried several times to belligerently push Israel into the sea, and our only “sin” is that we successfully defend ourselves with the abundant help of the G-d of Israel. I think that anyone objective, who believes in freedom and democracy and opposes terrorism and racism, realizes, especially after the recent Hamas attack, who is the problematic party in the Middle East and is the obstacle to peace, as opposed to who is the victim, and what is the mutually beneficial solution. BTW, if your friend doesn’t understand this, don’t waste any more time on him for you don’t stand “an ice-cube’s chance in hell” of changing his anti-Semitic leaning, unless he’s Jewish, where eventually there’s a good chance that logic may register, even if he’s been brain-washed by the non-objective anti-Semitic press. With Love of Israel, Rav Ari Shvat (Chwat)

  • Women- The Unsung Heroes! Every day we read in the news about the unbelievable heroism of men and women on Simchat Tor

    ah and ever since, but it’s time to especially praise the soldiers’ wives! My 2 daughters and daughter-in-law are doing unbelievably in handling their 5-4- and 3 children respectively already for more than 2 entire months (!) on their own. Of course grandparents, Sherut Le’umi girls, neighbors, volunteers and Bnei Akiva madrichim/ot help out, but they come and go, and leave the Ima’s with the real burden (especially when there’s no school and every morning, evening and bed-time!). Even if the soldier may come home for a day or two, they’re usually dead tired and dying for some normal quiet sleep and food. We’ve heard 2 recently widowed young women who now remain alone with 6 children each, who even after hearing of their tragic situation, continue supporting their husbands who didn’t utilize the army’s exemption and went to fight for what is right and for Am Yisrael. Hashem- what awesome and strong daughters You have raised!

    Chazal tell us (Yalkut Shimoni Ruth 604) that if Reuven knew that the Torah would report his actions for eternity, he would have lifted Yosef out of the pit and carried him on his shoulder by foot all the way home to Ya’akov! If Boaz would have known that the Tanach would detail the grain which he gave to Ruth, he would have given her steak!! They then add, that in the olden days, when one did a great mitzvah, a prophet wrote it in Tanach forever, but they ask, today, who writes down our mitzvot? They answer there: Hashem, Eliahu and Mashiach write down those who make history. Today our dedicated wives and daughters, not only our soldiers, are the ones writing the next and most glorious chapter of Jewish history. Yes, this Simchat Torah War is potentially a “game-changer” in history regarding many different issues (e.g. regarding achdut between dati-chiloni + right-left ideologies; clarifying that today’s smart-phone generation is just as brave and idealistic in combat as their predecessors; regarding Israeli security and deterrence all over; regarding the Haredi participation and appreciation of the army; regarding Jews in chu”l facing many surprising eye-openers concerning their continued status and comfort there, and much more that still awaits to be seen!

    Like a marriage, Am Yisrael is a partnership, where everyone chips-in whatever they can for whatever needs to be done in order for our families, Am Yisrael, and all mankind to benefit from the advance of our historic period in the Geula process. But let’s remember to sing the praises, especially tonight before Kiddush, of the “un-sung” heroes: all of our Aishet-Chayil’s! Shabbat Shalom, Rav Ari Shvat and Rav Lior Engleman)

  • Understand Anti-Semitism and It’s Solution

    Q. Why do people often hate Jews for no reason and is there no hope for a solution? Josh A. Yes Josh, it’s hard to believe that even in the modern world, there is still baseless anti-Semitism! Anyone with even a minimal knowledge of Judaism knows that the custom is to throw away an egg which has even a drop of chicken’s blood, so how can one be so ignorant as to suggest that we “use their blood for matzoh”?!! This just shows that you can’t look for logic when it comes to anti-Semitism, and that’s one direction: “It’s known (like a) halacha that Esav hates Ya’akov” (Sifre Bamidbar 69). Even in a modern world, at least one nation in every generation, calls to eradicate Am Yisrael. Just when we thought that mankind had “grown-up”, and that there never could be another Pharoh, Haman, Antiochus or Hitler, ימח שמם, Iran comes and threatens to “nuke” us, or suddenly Hamas barbarically does unspeakable atrocities and part of the modern world, including some profs in Ivy League universities, even applaud. BH, we know that they won’t succeed, but nevertheless, it would be nice to know the cause of age-old anti-Semitism and the eventual solution. Sociologists claim that it’s simply: the dislike of the unlike! On the other hand, my father-in-law, a Holocaust survivor, answered me that the gentiles in Europe were jealous of the Jews’ success. Rav Kook suggests that the cause of hatred for Am Yisrael, is in the double meaning of “מלמד חובות”. First of all, we taught obligations and brought morality and conscience to the world, commanding primitive man not to steal or kill- something that the nations of the world did not want to hear. That’s why the French philosopher Blaise Pasquale called the Jewish people the “conscience” of mankind, and most people don’t like their conscience (even when they eventually listen to it!). Secondly, we showed the world that morality is do-able, something which showed them in a negative light (the opposite of ללמד זכות): that not only should (!) we be moral, but that we could (!) be so. This is the deeper understanding of what our sages teach us that Sinai was named that way because it brought hate (Sina) of Israel to the nations (Shabbat 69a)

    Does that mean there’s no hope this will ever change? We can manage without the love of the hypocritical world, but at least let them stop threatening to kill us! Rav Kook (Orot Yisrael 5, 15) explains that people not only enjoy gifts but even harbor a positive association with the “giver” of that pleasure. Many people go so far as to value the autograph of entertainers for that reason, that they bring us pleasure. The more the world will understand the benefits of morality and monotheism, the more they will eventually appreciate the nation who brought those ideals to the world.

    Just as a child often hates going to his dentist, despite the fact that everything done there is for the child’s own good, yet only when he matures will he eventually recognize and thank his dentist. Although the morality of the Torah which we brought to the world, often make the nations feel guilty, as the world gradually matures, they will eventually thank us for these truths and values, the greatest treasures of modern society, When mankind matures, inevitably they will harbor a positive association with Am Yisrael (see Zecharia 8, 23), the nation that civilized and brought more bracha and true pleasure to mankind than any entertainer or nation.

    Until that time, we can’t be naïve, and must continue, in addition to fulfilling our role of being that moral and shining Or LaGoyim, also continue defending ourselves, deterring our enemies, and davening and thanking Hashem for persistently saving us.

    “אלא שבכל דור ודור עומדים עלינו לכלותינו, והקב”ה מצילנו מידם!”

    Shabbat Shalom and Chanukah Same’ach! Rav Ari Shvat

  • Rav Kook on: How to Fight ‘Clean’ Wars?

    Orot HaMilchama (part v) Although Rav Kook often relates to the importance of Jewish nationalism and Zionism, nevertheless, he writes here that G-d “froze” our nationalism for almost 2,000 years, until we, and mankind, matured and grew out of dictatorships, primitive wars etc. Until today, where we can now run a moral and G-dly Jewish State, army, economy etc. Even so, despite still having barbaric enemies like Hamas which we must fight strongly and deter, Israel is already the most moral army in the world. Yes, it’s more difficult and challenging to run morality on a national level, and Rav Kook isn’t naive, realizing that it will take time to gradually evolve secular Zionism into the Jewish State which it’s meant to be, that’s precisely our role: to be a “Light to the Nations”. Here’s the link to the recording of my class:

    https://www.yutorah.org/lectures/1082269

    שנשמע בשורות טובות ישועות ונחמות!

    Rav Ari Shvat

  • Uniqueness of this WhatsApp Group: The reason that BH there’s a popular demand for this WhatsApp group is the lack of Torat Eretz Yisrael in English

    There are many Anglo rabbis in the U.S., Europe, Australia and South Africa, as well as in Israel, but what’s lacking in English is the world-view of religious-Zionism, as seen for example in the writings of Rav Kook, especially regarding understanding the current events

    What happened on Simchat Torah was not just a pogrom similar to many during the 2,000 years of exile. It was a terrible Chilul Hashem, desecration of G-d’s Name where “Allahu Akhbar”= “Our G-d is greater/the greatest”, was probably chanted by the Moslem world more times in a single day since the wars of Muhammad 1,400 years ago. If this is their proof for Islam and their motivational cheer for barbaric sadism, than we have no choice and our moral obligation to the world, is the sound military trouncing of Hamas, which today is not only possible but bezH also inevitable.

    The frame of reference to understand today’s problem and its solution is not through rereading the more recent history of exile, but davka to recall and rediscover the ancient but vibrant eternal Tanach. Rabbis who haven’t served in the IDF (and spend much more time on gemara than on Tanach) have difficulty identifying with the national pride and answer of David HaMelech and the heroes of the Tanach to the enemies of Israel in the Land of Israel. Similarly, rabbis who haven’t made aliya don’t appreciate how living in Israel is the only solution to meet the needs of today’s students who feel vulnerable on the college campuses and others at work. Why have these young people feel helpless, when a realistic and pleasant solution is clearly within reach!

    One leading rabbi in the States once explained to me, “How can I speak about a mitzva which I myself don’t fulfill?!” I don’t agree but I understand that claim, but at least he should pass on the true message of those who are willing to trumpet it, especially to the relevant idealistic ears of the younger generation!

    Similarly their claim: “How can I encourage the aliya of young Jews which inevitably weakens our local Jewish community?” We must remember that the end goal of Judaism is not the exile, but to end up in Israel, and yes, by definition that weakens the galut. Don’t withhold true-Judaism and the ideal from the young just for ulterior and local motives, or an outdated anachronistic misreading and ignorance of what’s changed over the last 75 years in Israel! Wake up- Baruch Hashem we are no longer in Warsaw or Bialystok, but we’re back in Israel and this time, to stay!

  • Nazis and Deniers- Yes, but Shoah- No!

    It’s true that the sadistic and systematic murder and kidnapping by Hamas of innocent Jewish victims, resemble the Nazis very much, but let’s not make the mistake of those terming it: a Holocaust.

    The two are parallel for anti-Semites aren’t new at cold-blooded systematic murder of defenseless babies. We’ve also seen crackpot denial theories where Jew-haters already within days (!) defend and acquit Hamas even regarding atrocities that we know about from Hamas cameras, and of which they not only don’t deny but brag about! The double-standard of anti-Semites doesn’t accept testimony and proof that would clearly have convicted in every court of law.

    I’m sarcastically waiting for some defense attorneys for the Thailand and Napal agricultural workers to defend them from their suffering afflicted upon them just because of Israel. I challenge the anti-Semitic crackpots to claim that the terror was true and barbaric against the foreign workers towards whom they can direct their classic progressive sympathy, while denying or rejoicing those bullets that missed the workers and hit Israelis!

    Yes, the cruelty and crackpot reality-deniers and double-standard clowns are similar towards Hamas as some are towards Nazis, but we’ve come a long way since the Shoah.

    Yes, Israeli intelligence and the IDF erred terribly before and on Simchat Torah, but let’s keep things in proportion! 80 years ago in Europe Jews had to hide like mice, but today, the Hamas and Hizballah are the ones hiding underground like rodents.

    Yes, the 1,200 murdered was 10 times the casualties of the 1929/תרפ”ט riots, but it was less than one day in Auschwitz, and little compared to the pogroms in Europe (e.g. the documented 17,000 Jews killed by the Ukrainians in 6 weeks in 1918/תרע”ח, and altogether, at least 50,000).

    Let’s not mix-up pain with confusion. We suffer the pain of the 1,200 holy martyrs of the Hamas Nazis, but have no doubt that bezH we will be victorious and Hamas will soon get walloped. This is far from being a Holocaust. We must thank G-d and appreciate His State of Israel and IDF. When anti-Semites attack and curse Jews on campuses in America, England and France, we again feel vulnerable like mice with no one to protect us, but here in Israel, the heads of Hamas and Hizballah are hiding for their lives- where they are the mice who will soon feel the well-deserved wrath of the G-d and army of Israel! Baruch Hashem, we’ve come a long way! Rav Ari Shvat

  • Freeing Terrorists to Free Hostages- On this issue, much has already been written mostly for but also against freeing “s

    mall” terrorists in order to free our brothers and sisters kidnapped by Hamas. This is surely a topic which demands humility, for only a select few top army officers and politicians know all of the information necessary to express a serious opinion

    I’ll just suffice to say that as a rav, I was against freeing 1,027 terrorists including Yichye Sinuar ym”sh and much of the present Gazan Hamas leadership (and many convicted murderers) in order to free Gilad Shalit, a young soldier who was kidnapped because he defied the army’s orders, and surrendered rather than fight. The pragmatic halacha explains that if we pay more than the usual or accepted “price” (generally one of their’s for one of our’s), the enemy will simply kidnap over and over (Shulchan Aruch Y.D. 252). On the other hand, the brutal kidnapping of so many civilians from their homes, many of them children, women and elderly, must be seen differently.

    The story is told of R. Velvel Soleveitchik, an extreme anti-Zionist Yerushalmi, who when asked why he castigates all religious-Zionists aside from R. Meir Bar-Ilan, explained: what can I do, he’s “mishpacha” (they were cousins)! Upon hearing this, exclaimed HaRav Kook: all of Am Yisrael are my “mishpacha”! Every parent of every child kidnapped by Hamas is not to blame for wanting to free their child at any price, and we should also identify with these children mamash as our “mishpacha”! True, Gilad Shalit and every soldier is also our child, but during his years in Tzahal, it’s his national turn to fight to defend Am Yisrael (and himself), which Shalit didn’t do. This is totally different than the kidnapping of helpless babies where, together with our resolve to continue beating Hamas to a pulp (in order to deter our other surrounding enemies), we are obligated, out of love as well as for national morale, to bring them home, and then get back to work fighting evil!

    I’ll just mention again in this context, the gemara we’ve cited in the past (Sanhedrin 106a)”‘He [Bil’am] took up his parable [=prophesizing about our generations, the period of ge’ula] and said: Alas! Who can survive when He does this?'(Bamidbar 24, 23). Woe to the nation who will be found hindering the Jewish people at the time when [our Father] the Holy One, Blessed be He, redeems His children. Who dares place his garment to separate between a male lion and a female lioness when they wish to mate? [Woe to him, for who does so will certainly not “survive”].” We must emulate our G-dly Father (remember: Imitateo Dei= צלם אלוקים…) and do anything to free, and to fight, in order to save and love His, and our (!) beloved children. Shabbat Shalom (!!) Rav Ari

  • Q.Folks Want Me with Them

    Q. Hi Rav Shvat… I just am struggling because my parents ‘love’ Israel but are comfortable overseas and want me to be with them. I have a stronger love for Israel/zionist/will live through a war in Israel view and it is hard to explain to them how I feel towards Israel and also respect them and how they feel. They ‘get it’ but they tell me it’s best to come back in case it worsens or even the current state of war as it is, is bad enough for them. Answer: Shalom! It’s a good and natural sign that your parents love you and want you safe and near them. Otherwise it would be a problem! Nevertheless, it’s logical (and also halachically sound) that at some age (usually around your age), the child already knows, better than his parents, what’s best for him. This is usually difficult for parents to accept, even if their child is 60 years old! Honoring our parents is really important and that’s why it’s even in the Ten Commandments, but that’s regarding their needs, e.g. going to the grocery for them, making them a cup of coffee, and not regarding your life or ideological decisions (Resp. Maharik 166-7; Shulchan Aruch YD 240, 25)

    Moreover, experience shows that idealistic and Zionist children almost always received at least part of this davka from their parents, for which you should respect and sincerely thank them. You may try explaining to them that you actually took the education they gave you even more seriously than they took themselves, e.g. they taught you to love Israel, but you actually made Aliyah. Accordingly, they should davka be proud of you, that you choose to live by the ideals with which they raised you! Love and loyalty are also very important middot to which they surely educated you as well, and accordingly, we should not come to Israel just when we need her, but also when she needs us! The guys who are unfortunately sometimes giving their lives now in Gaza to free the hostages and fight Hamas, are your age. If Eretz Yisrael is worth them dying for, Kal VaChomer it’s worth you living for (where BH, you really are not in any danger)! In short, davka your staying and helping out in Israel is a reflection of your love and respect for parents and their ideals, and I have no doubt that, even if they’re a little worried, they are proud of you! With Love of Israel, Rav Ari Shvat (Chwat)