Author: Ari Shvat

  • P. BAMIDBAR- BETWN YERUSHALAYIM and SHAVU’OT- Kabbalat haTorah via the Nation of Israel

    As we prepare for our annual commemoration of Kabbalat HaTorah on Shavu’ot, we annually celebrate Yom Yerushalayim and read Parshat BaMidbar, where we count the number of soldiers in each tribe of Israel. The interesting term used in the military census, “במספר שמות” (Bamidbar 1), “the NUMBER of the NAMES” seems extraneous. My teacher and friend R. Yoel Bin-Nun explains beautifully that the “number” is obviously necessary, representing that we are part of a nation and must sometimes forego our individualism for the sake of the klal. That’s why on our first day in the IDF we get our “serial number”, and that’s what liberating and defending our Land is about (see Ramban, Bamidbar 1, 3). This minimizing ourselves for the NATIONAL need, is the military and psychological point of the counting, both then and today. On the other hand, in the army of Israel each soldier also has a NAME. Like all religions, we too have the aspect of elevating ourselves spiritually as INDIVIDUALS with uniqueness, via learning my own Torah, choosing the stress in my mitzvah observance, and prayer (my personal relationship with G-d). Both the NAME and the NUMBER are similarly important, but in today’s “ME generation”, the western world must make a conscious effort to remember that Hashem created and gave the Torah to Israel, as a nation.

    Yerushalayim represents exactly that: serving Hashem via Am Yisrael, via our national-religious capitol. Prayer was instituted and organized in preparation for our leaving to exile, where we lived as individuals for 2,000 years. But the original and ideal was to get close to G-d via Kohanim (our national representatives), and national pilgrimage to our uniting capitol 3 times a year. This is not about “Me”, and my spirituality, for “there’s no ‘I’ in the word: TEAM”. The 2,000 year focus on the individual Jew was not in vain, and must be continued, but in tandem with the rediscovery and revival of our national selves. Even in galut, tfila has to be b’Tzibbur, at least with the community, is worded in the plural, and how much more so, the content of returning to Israel, our Sanhedrin and Jerusalem, doesn’t let us forget our national needs and true original identity. Our spiritual climax, both on Yom Kippur and Pesach Seder, is “next year in Yerushalayim!”, where only there we can be complete. Under every chuppa, we recall the missing Yerushalayim. The Abudraham even writes that “ימלוך ה’ לעולם אלוקייך ציון”, was a later addition at the end of kedusha, for it’s unthinkable not to mention Yerushalayim in such a central prayer!

    Hashem had many individually righteous people in previous generations: Adam, Chanoch, Noach, Metushelach, Shem… But with the revelation of Am Yisrael, He revealed His desire to appear to the world davka via a chosen nation (R. Kook, Orot, p. 104): our mass receiving the Torah at Sinai, our prophets, our mitzvot, our history, and today, the fulfillment of the prophecies of our national redemption, gathering of the exiles and extraordinary G-dly altruism during our wars (ibid, p. 138).

    Our national redemption from slavery, our formative 40 years of “gibush” in the desert, and yes, even our receiving the Torah was davka national: “נעשה ונשמע”, “WE will do, and WE will listen”. Many individual religion-founders “claimed” G-dly revelation, but His real disclosure was through the entire nation of Israel, “Was there ever such an idea or [even] a claim, that a[n entire] nation heard G-d speak from amidst the fire…” (Devarim 4, see Rambam, hil. Yesodei HaTorah 8, 1).

    P. Bamidbar reminds us of the dual importance of our individual and national identity, but our commemorating the 6 Day War, which called for so much individual sacrifice and climaxed with the cry “Har HaBayit is in our hands!” is also part of the preparation for Kabbalat HaTorah. Especially when today’s western society climaxes the importance of our individualism, it’s davka important to remember: each of us is but one letter in the national Torah. Kabbalists point out that ישרא”ל stands for: י’ש ש’ישים ר’יבוא א’ותיות ל’תורה””, [= “there are 600,000 letters in the Torah”], where even if one letter is missing- it deems the ENTIRE Sefer Torah as non-kosher! But one cannot even imagine that the goal is just MY personal letter. “אם אין אני לי מי לי?! וכשאני לעצמי, מה אני?!” (= “If I’m not for myself, who will be for me?! But if I’m only for myself, what am I worth?!” Avot, 1, 14). “Shall your brothers go to war while you stay here?” (Bamidbar 32, 6).

    Let’s remember to “raise YERUSHALAYIM above all of my personal joy (“שמחתי”)” (Tehilim 137, 6). Yes, including lifting my national spirituality and needs, over my individual spirituality and needs, if sometimes I must choose between the two, for the Torah was given to Am Yisrael, not “R. Yisrael”. Shabbat Shalom and Chag Same’ach! Rav Ari Shvat (Chwat)

  • Y’RUSHALAYIM- HARMONIZING RELIGION-NATIONALISM-UNIVERSALISM

    The Tanach teaches that Yerushalayim is the NATIONAL capitol of David HaMelech and his descendants; the RELIGIOUS capitol-home of the Sanhedrin; and the UNIVERSAL capitol- home of the Beit HaMikdash, “for My house, will be called a house of prayer for all nations” (Yeshayahu 56, 7). When Y’rushalayim is “built” (learn well: Tehilim 122), she is the residence of the triumvirate, those 3 respective leaders: the KING (natl. leader), the NASI- head of Sanhedrin (the religious leader) and the KOHEN GADOL- the universal leader from Aharon who is “אוהב שלום, רודף שלום..”, “loves and pursues peace”. Already today, when Jews go up to Jerusalem it is mainly for either religious or national (e.g. political demonstrations) reasons, but let’s not forget that when 99.8% of mankind visits, they aren’t interested in our flag or yeshivot, but rather in universal ideals, as the historic center of all major religions and monotheistic ethics. So it was also when there was a Beit haMikdash.

    Rav Kook ingeniously summarizes all of the ideologies of mankind through these three, most basic ones: firstly, religion, in Israel comprised of TORAH and mitzvot, the belief and the holy aspect of Judaism; the second is nationalism or ZIONISM; the third is UNIVERSALISM, calling for the general human content of education, culture, morals and more. [Obviously Jewish nationalism (e.g. the holy land and holy language) and mussar are also religious topics, as Rav Kook continues to explain that the “Kodesh ha’Elyon” (quintessential holiness) is the general heading which includes all three forces, all of which are holy. Yet here he is expressly referring to the religious aspect (among the three) in its narrowest form, as it was in exile (Orot, pp. 70-72).]

    In fact, society and the politics of democracies are comprised of a right-wing party of nationalist hawks, a left-wing party of humanist doves, and depending on the local understanding of the separation of church and state, the religious parties, as we have in Israel. The tens (!) of parties usually running in Israeli elections can all be neatly divided among these three ideologies, which are meant to be the “CHECKS and BALANCE” system, ensuring that we don’t get to the problematic extremism. Like an equilateral triangle, each of the three sides also “kisses” the other two, but also LIMITS the others from exaggeration or extremism.

    For example, Rav Kook writes regarding exaggerated humanism, that one who claims to love all of mankind with that special love usually reserved for one’s brothers and nation, his love “needs to be examined” (Orot p.169). One who cares for Arab civilians in Gaza more than he cares about his innocent Jewish brothers in Sderot or in the Gaza envelope, is like a mother who saves her neighbor’s son from a fire before she saves her own. This is not altruism but selective humanism which is far from morality and normality.

    Similarly, extremists amongst us who mistakenly think that love of the Jewish people requires opposition to universalism and secular education also, add to this dangerous trend, just as those who think that nationalism obliges the hate of every Arab, and those who think that moralism obliges weakness, retreat and national surrender in the face of threat. Likewise, some Haredim who see Judaism only as a religion, and think that this calls for negating nationalism (serving in the IDF, making Aliya, speaking Hebrew…) and universal ideals (secular education, modernity…).

    Even though the ideal is to be broad enough to balance (33-33-33%), like David HaMelech or Rav Kook- harmonizing religious-nationalist-universal ideals, inevitably it’s natural (= G-dly intended!) in every nation that there be groups or individuals who ideologically stress one more than another. Rav Kook writes that we want there to be right-wing, left-wing and religious parties, but only on condition that there is a mutual, not only tolerance but respect and participation (e.g. 50-25-25%). Just as the beauty of musical harmony necessitates the DIVERSE sounds, cooperating and revealing the G-dly unity of all ideologies and creation.

    When I came to Israel about 40 years ago, there was basically a large mechitza (barrier) mutually separating the really religious and the really Zionist. Thank G-d the striving for unity of religion and nationalism has basically succeeded, so much so that today in Israeli politics and society, the religious and nationalists are virtually identified as one camp and one political bloc. The Zionists already know that religious-Zionists are leading the army and settling the land, and the knowledgeable Haredim also recognize that the dayanim in the religious courts are comprised also of leading rabbis with kipot srugot from Hesder yeshivot.

    If so, what factor is still preventing unity in Israel? It seems that the focus should now be in what Rav Kook infers: the unison of the third side among the triangle of world views, which is often seen today (in an unfortunate widespread coalition between the Haredim and the liberals, and even by some of the religious-Zionists), as if there’s a seeming contradiction between religious-nationalism as opposed to universalism, humanism, moralism, liberalism, secular education, modernism, et al.

    Yes, youth have a tendency to be simplistic and go to extremes, to speak AGAINST other ideologies, but the ‘responsible adult’ leadership, must consciously speak in favor, in POSITIVE terms of mutual respect rather than mutual negations (and surely cooperate in the mutual denunciation of Yair Golan’s purposely divisive denunciations!). Today’s Moslem fanatics and ironically the extreme progressive, can be similarly anti-Semitic and dangerous. Conversely, Rav Kook’s students are proud to lead Israeli society not just in Religious+Zionism, but also in morality, as expressed in studying mussar, volunteering, Sherut Le’umi, altruistic kidney donors and soldiers, etc. Perhaps the time has come to complete our movement and prepare for national leadership, by adding the 3rd rib of the triangle through “upgrading” our nickname to be: Religious+ Zionist+ Universalists. “ירושלים הבנויה כעיר שחוברה לה יחדיו!”. Shabbat Shalom and Yom Yerushalayim Same’ach! Rav Ari Shvat (Chwat)

  • R. AKIVA’S STUDENTS WERE THE BAR KOCHVA REBELLION- New Sources!

    Many Torah giants have died in Jewish history, but based upon many conclusive and convincing rabbinic, historic and archaeological sources, I strongly agree with those that say that the 24,000 students of R. Akiva whom we mourn, were murdered, as R. Akiva himself, by the Romans in the Bar Kochva rebellion which took place precisely at that time (122-130 C.E.). [Otherwise, since when do “plagues” only strike young and strong yeshiva boys more than the elderly, pregnant and infants?!]

    We know that R. Akiva and inevitably his yeshiva and followers, were the most active participants and supporters of that rebellion (see Y’rushalmi Ta’anit 4, 5; Rambam, M’lachim 11, 3; ibid, Ta’aniot 5, 3; Igeret Rav Shrira Gaon, edited from ancient manuscripts by R. Dr. B.M. Lewin, and much more). This explanation has been around a long time, but the problem is that either the Romans or self-censorship, removed almost everything about the rebellion from Chazal. I’ve myself published in Hebrew on the topic after finding additional proofs (just Google : המעין ארי שבט עקיבא כוכבא or for an English class, Google: YUTorah Ari Shvat Kochva Akiva, where I elaborate and bezH answer all the inevitable questions). In the brief scope of this framework, I’ll just point out that the Talmud Y’rushalmi and Rambam there, state that R. Akiva and all of the greatest scholars of his time (= his 24,000 students, the rabbinic center of the period) were supporters of Bar Kochva, and were killed by the Romans. Moreover, the Rambam (ibid) sees them as the rabbinic approach and model messianic movement, to naturally and actively bring the ge’ula, and save Israel from our enemies.

    Many remember when the other rabbis cried and R. Akiva laughed upon seeing a fox in the destroyed Holy Temple (Makot 24b), but don’t notice that he explains, “just as the 1st prophecy (of destruction) came true, so too, the 2nd prophecy (of redemption) is BEING fulfilled” (“מתקיימת”), in the present, not that it will come (“תתקיים”) in the future! He was stressing, “we’re going to do something about fulfilling that ge’ula”, via joining Bar Kochva. Now we also understand their reaction: “Akiva, you have comforted us”.

    We also now comprehend the seemingly strange story (Brachot 60b), where R. Akiva wants to sleep in a city, and everyone refuses to host the greatest rabbi since Moshe Rabbenu (Menachot 29b). As his torch is extinguished, his donkey wolfed, his rooster devoured, he “nebech” sleeps alone in the desert and keeps repeating “it’s all for the best!”. But when “coincidentally” that night the Romans “happened” to arrest the entire city where he wished to sleep, and he realizes why everything in the end was, “all for the best”, WE realize why nobody wanted to host the most respected Jew of his time? For the Romans were apparently “on his tail”, and heard he came to town, and in order to capture the spiritual leader of the rebellion, they didn’t take chances and arrested the whole city!

    In the same way, we now realize why R. Shimon bar Yochai (Shabbat 33) and R. Meir (Avodah Zara 18b) are “Wanted Dead or Alive” by the Romans, for we know well, they also are among R. Akiva’s students! It also now makes sense why the 4 species minted on the Bar Kochva coins, have only 1 hadass and 1 arava (instead of 3 and 2 respectively, as we do today following R. Yishma’el’s custom, and as traditionally found on all other “lulav” coins from previous Jewish kingdoms), for the rebels followed R. Akiva’s dissenting opinion (Sukka 34b), that it’s enough to have ONE of each of the 4 species! (to see, just Google: Bar Kochva coin lulav). In short, the Bar Kochva rebellion was the students of R. Akiva!

    Similarly, the historic background helps us understand why R. Akiva (Rosh HaShana 26a) is amazingly found in Arabia, Africa and Europe way before “frequent fliers”! Not only as an “underground” fugitive, but R. Akiva was apparently the 1st “shaliach Bnei AKIVA”, going around to gather the exiles!

    Accordingly, the Rambam writes that the crushing of the BK rebellion after several years (!) of independence, and the disappointment of the great hope they had to build the Third Commonwealth, was not just a health problem in one particular yeshiva, but a historic and national tragedy (!), which he likens to the destructions of the 2 Temples (hil. Ta’aniot 5, 3)! Accordingly, it’s totally understood why this period’s customs resemble the 3 weeks, when we mourn the destruction of the Temples.

    Unfortunately, 1800 long years of galut (exile) warped the picture of the ideal and original Jew. We stopped serving in the army because it wasn’t ours, and “we forgot the Israel has a holy body, not just a holy soul” (Rav Kook, Orot, p. 33).

    I’ll also point out for those who are looking for the Torah-true and genuine approach to Judaism, that these 24,000 holy rabbis, whom we respect as THE transmitters of the Oral Law, were “Hesder Yeshiva” boys, combining Torah with army service just like Moshe, Yehoshua, David HaMelech and all the Tanach heroes. BH, today, the picture of the Living Torah and Ideal Jew has returned, in today’s soldiers having a “healthy soul in a healthy body” (R. Kook, Orot haTeshuva 5, 1), and that’s who, bezH, has the enemies of Israel “on the run”.

    We finally understand what Lag BaOmer has to do with the “bow and arrows” and “bonfires” out in nature, which were the life-style of R. Akiva’s fugitive students!

    But let’s make sure that this time, WE respect each other’s opinions, and obey our commanders and governments!

    Shabbat Shalom and “Lag Same’ach”! Rav Ari Shvat (Chwat)

  • FREE HOSTAGES AT ANY PRICE? An Eternal Nation Must Think Long-Term

    Q. Hi Rav Shvat! In terms of Halacha and in an ideal world in which the Israeli government was run by Jewish Law and not limited by foreign intervention, what would be the best decision: freeing hostages or destroying the enemy so as not to repeat what occurred on Oct. 7? Do we aid our enemies and free additional Sinwars and take any deal in order to save the lives of our beloved hostages who are currently being tortured, or do we prevent many more future terrorism and kidnappings?

    A. Shalom, It’s great to see that your admirable Ahavat Yisrael and care for both our nation and her individuals, is still as strong as ever! Regarding your question, although the deliberation on such decisions is very painful, the halacha is clear. Although we care about each and every hostage as if it were our own child and “there is no mitzvah as great as redeeming prisoners” (see at length: Rambam, Matnot Ani’im 8, 10), the Torah usually prefers the more mature long-term approach, taking into account the larger picture. The Mishna )Gittin 4, 6) writes explicitly that as a nation we don’t pay for hostages “more than their worth”, i.e. one of ours for one of theirs. The logic is, as you inferred, if the gentiles see that we Jews pay exorbitantly for our hostages, they will kidnap on a regular basis, and add even more terror, knowing that it pays and they will eventually be freed. Just as when Israel goes to war, the mitzvah is to give the individual soldier’s life, if necessary, so that our nation can live and function, so too, the individual hostage and his family must unfortunately sometimes pay the price for the long-term needs and war-strategy of Israel. So is the undisputed halacha and rationale (Shulchan Aruch Y.D. 252, 4). [It should nevertheless be mentioned that R. Shlomo Goren (Torat HaMedina, p. 424), legendary and founding Chief Rabbi of the IDF, ruled that should the IDF decide that for reasons of morale, it’s important that every soldier know that we will do everything to bring him home, there is some flexibility to pay a higher price, but he himself stressed the priority of the future war against terror. Similarly, R. Ya’akov Kamenetzky opposed paying exorbitantly and freeing terrorists in exchange for the hijacked R. Yitzchak Hutner (1970/תש”ל), b/c in a time of war, it’s seen as surrendering.]

    On the other hand, we see there that the individual is allowed to redeem himself and his wife at any cost, and the nation allows doing so as well for exceptional (even budding) Torah scholars (Gittin 58a and Shulchan Aruch, ibid, as R. Moshe Feinstein thought to apply regarding R. Hutner). Historically, the gentiles, like the Hamas, revealed this “Achilles’ heel” that we have a soft heart for our brothers, and it was common for pirates to kidnap Jews, and bring them to a totally foreign Jewish community, which would ransom them for almost any price. In practice, notwithstanding the aforementioned leniency, and despite being the greatest rav of his generation (teacher of the Rosh, Mordechai, Tashbetz, Hagahot Maimoniot, et al…), the Maharam of Rottenberg (d. 1293/ה’נג) did not (!) allow the community to ransom him for an exceptionally high price, and even died in jail after 7 years. His altruism and moral/educational message is clear: that even if he personally is allowed to be redeemed, on the national scale, the nation and future Torah scholars, should not have to pay the unbearable price of future kidnappings (Maharshal, Yam shel Shlomo, Gittin 4, 66). The eternal nation of Israel has an infinite future, and must decide accordingly and altruistically for the long-term. [Obviously we don’t know all of the information, and if we can achieve both freeing the hostages and eliminating Hamas without freeing many terrorists, that definitely would be the best!].

    The main directive is that today, BH we are no longer just individuals. Acting as the State of Israel, we must, as David HaMelech, sometimes overcome our soft-heart and, as on the battle-field, place the eternal and long-term national needs as supreme even over our own individual or even family’s needs (see Rambam, M’lachim 7, 15, that in war, we must supremely think only of the G-d of Israel and His nation). To deter enemies and how much more so, not free convicted terrorists to prevent any future Oct. 7th. To paraphrase Rav Kook (Orot, p. 54), “עם הנצח לא מפחד מדרך ארוכה! “The eternal nation is not scared of a long journey”, but we can’t rely on miracles. Shabbat Shalom and Besorot Tovot! Rav Ari Shvat (Chwat)

  • The Yom HaZIKARON SIREN- EVERY ARROW NEEDS A HEAD!

    The siren sounded in Israel on Yom HaZikaron, is a time and feeling that cannot be explained to anyone who hasn’t experienced it. The feeling of millions of brothers simultaneously stopping their individual lives to be together, of national unity, altruism, thanks and resolve are incomparable. We resolve to eulogize and learn from those soldiers, to support, appreciate and feel sorry for the fallen and their families, but also feel sorry for those who miss out on this unique feeling of selflessness, Klali’ut, and belonging to something big and eternal (whether because they live abroad or deliberately choose to separate from the rest of Israel, see Rav Kook, Orot, p. 166).

    It’s a time to especially appreciate the disproportionate share of Kibbutzniks in the military cemeteries and learn to emulate their ideology of the collective, and selfless giving. They never comprised more than 3% of Israeli society, but produced almost all (!) of the Prime Ministers and IDF Chiefs of Staff for the first 30 years of the State, and although to a lesser extent, supply leadership to this very day.

    The present war shows a new phenomenon: that this arrow-head of leadership has clearly been transferred to the Kipot HaSrugot- the religious-Zionists. Our disproportionate share among the officers, battle units and reserves (although admittedly lacking in those early days of the State), is unfortunately also clearly expressed today in the military cemeteries.

    Several days ago, I went to console the Cohen family of Sha’arei Tikva, and heard from Y’ella, Matan’s mother, how this all is not coincidence. That youth who grow up not only learning g’mara but also Tanach, Mussar and Jewish philosophy, are the new arrow-head of Israel, already admired and examples to be emulated by the entire country.

    Youth who grow up in homes like that of Y’ella Cohen, are nursed with the Torah of Rav Kook, and learn in Hesder Yeshivot from giants like R. Aharon Lichtenstein zt”l (rosh yeshiva of Gush Etzion), cannot forget when he analyzed society in 5 simple words: he roared: “האם איכפת לך או לא?!”- “Do you care or not” about other Jews, Israel, the non-religious…?! This is also what gets religious Zionists to be the ones making Aliya.

    I once discussed with R. Eli Saddan, founder of the first pre-army Mechina in Eli, about the need to direct these living examples of religious-Zionist idealism, after leading the charge on the battle-field, to encourage those suitable, to begin a new page in Israeli politics. BezH that day is coming sooner than we thought, for if 3% of the population could once be the arrow-head, how much more so can 20%.

    We must clarify, that we definitely don’t want to “take over”, but to the contrary, to be selfless and share. Every arrow needs a head, a Nachshon ben Aminadav, to show the ultimate idealism for all. No less important than being an arrow-head, is that religious-Zionist youth can logically and practically be the bridge between secular Zionism and non-Zionist religious Haredim. Harmonizing the best of all worlds, reviving the traditions of the heroes of Tanach, who all lived in Israel, served and led the Jewish army, spoke Hebrew and worked- Mitzvat Yishuv Eretz Yisrael (see Chatam Sofer, Sukkah 36; Rav Kook, Orot, p. 14).

    Youth who have the self-discipline not to use their cell-phones on Shabbat, and express that same will-power in the IDF and all of Israeli society, can even serve as a “Light to (all of the) Nations”, showing mankind how to balance modernism, religion, family, nationalism and humanism. If we were all to selflessly emulate that idealism in day to day life, we would be living in the atmosphere of Ge’ula, and won’t need any more wars in the process to get us there.

    Wishing you a meaningful Yom HaZikaron, and subsequently a Happy Yom HaAtzma’ut and Shabbat Shalom! Rav Ari Shvat (Chwat)

  • BETWEEN YOM HASHOA and YOM HAZIKARON

    I was once asked to be a Sandak and hold the baby at a bris which took place precisely between Yom HaShoa and Yom HaZikaron. As the mohel was “cleaning up” the blood, I understood the depth of what we had just recited at the Pesach Seder and again there at the circumcision, “ואומר לך בדמייך חיי ואומר לך בדמייך חיי” (Yechezkel 16, 6). Yechezkel says that Hashem feels sorry for the weak and fledgling Israel, and when coming to redeem and wash us off, tells us twice that through your blood you shall live, and again, through your blood you shall live. All ask the question: what does it mean that through our blood we shall live, and why is this repeated twice?

    Then it hit me that these are precisely the 2 types of “blood” (damayich is also in the plural!) in that process of redemption of Yechezkel, separated every year by one week of differentiation: that of Yom HaShoah, and that of Yom HaZikaron (commemorating those who fell in the wars of Israel). Rav Zvi Yehuda Kook often said that we can never understand the Holocaust, but retroactively, the period was clearly a gett (bill of divorce) of the parting of Am Yisrael from the exile. Most (!) of the large ancient Jewish communities in the world from a century and millennium ago, in Europe, Asia and Africa respectively, within one decade (1940-1950/ת”ש-תש”י) suddenly collapsed. The qualitative and quantitative centers of the Jewish world, have now and forever returned from the Ashkenazi and Sefaradi countries, back to their original, holy and eternal homeland of Israel. Soviet Russia was soon to follow. Inevitably, all significant transitions, especially national and historic ones for most of world Jewry, entail upheavals and challenges. בדמייך חיי.

    It is brought in the name of Rav Kook (R.M.Tz. Neria, Chayei HaReiya, p. 190) upon being asked by a Jew from Europe in the early 1930’s/תר”צ, who was deliberating his future: on the one hand anti-Semitism had already raised its head there, but he also feared the problems the Jews were suffering in Eretz Yisrael from the Arab marauders. Rav Kook answered that when we come across such difficulties, we must remember to clearly differentiate, for there is no comparison between birth pangs (of redemption in Israel) and death pains (of the end of exile). Both are painful, but one is the beginning of life, and no one would trade it for the other, the end of life! He similarly pointed out (Ma’amarei HaReiya, p. 278), that if one doesn’t know which direction is east or west, he can mistakenly confuse the darkness left at the sunrise of redemption (personified by Yom HaZikaron) for the sunset of exile (embodied by Yom HaShoah). In the Land of Israel today, we are on our way up, not on our way down, but that doesn’t mean it will always be easy. Yes, we celebrate Yom HaAtzma’ut, but we first identify that it comes via the altruism of Yom HaZikaron.

    Eretz Yisrael, like Torah, Olam haBah and really anything worthwhile, is acquired through challenges, yissurim (Brachot 5a). Children are our greatest pleasure, but also the source of our greatest heartache.

    Let us thank Hashem, appreciate and differentiate that on Yom HaShoah we remember the blood of 6 years we had to hide like mice, and in the words of the Israeli ambassador to the UN: the greatest hope of the Warsaw uprising was to die honorably, as opposed to Yom HaZikaron, where thanks to Hashem and our valiant altruistic soldiers, albeit the blood it cost us, pretty quickly Sinwar and Hamas, Nasralla and Hizballa were the ones hiding like mice. Yes, there is still darkness and hostages, but it’s part of the sunrise, not the sunset. In short, BH we’ve come a long way. בדמייך חיי, that davka through our blood, we eternally live and survive.

    On Yom HaZikaron let’s also learn from OUR tragic mistakes which led to the Hamas massacre and kidnappings, which are also part of the birth pangs of Mashiach, learning how to and how not to, run a Jewish State. This includes the necessity of solidarity and mutual self-sacrifice, and not to take security for granted. Let’s also take the day to stop and learn from and emulate the altruistic soldiers and volunteers who courageously fought with unity like lions, in a generation where many feared that we had “lost” that determination and idealism. The bumper stickers pasted all around Israel, with each chayal who fell’s picture and idealistic “quote”, are the best way to admire and learn who they were and who we should be, to appreciate those who fell, and the value of the State, Land and People for which they did so. Like Judaism and similarly Israel, if something is worth dying for, how much more so that it’s worth LIVING FOR/IN and appreciating. Shabbat Shalom, Rav Ari Shvat (Chwat)

  • CLEANING FOR PESACH: BETWEEN ‘FEELING’ and ‘BEING’ RELIGIOUS

    In Judaism, we have many tfilot all year round, and especially on Shabbat, holidays and the High Holidays, and we strive then, as when saying all brachot, to “feel religious” as often as possible. Similarly, learning Torah, especially philosophy, Tanach, mussar, particularly with those teachers which each individual finds elevating, often gets us to feel that much more religious, and it’s great to feel that when doing every mitzva.

    On the other hand, all yeshivot close their doors from Rosh Chodesh Nissan, because cleaning for Pesach, like many mitzvot, is about “being religious” or G-dly, even if they don’t get most of us to “feel religious”. Similarly, when remembering to wait 6 hours, or stopping in the middle of a good joke upon remembering that it’s Lashon HaRah, or even while observing Shabbat, often Judaism teaches that being religious is no less important than “feeling religious”.

    Once a Ba’al Teshuva called me about 15 minutes before candle-lighting, upon being informed that you’re not allowed to play guitar on Shabbat. He somehow heard that I use music as an educational means, and figured I could “find him a leniency” for his religious predicament. He explained that as a follower of R. Shlomo Carlebach, his singing with his guitar is the spiritual climax of his Shabbat, and he was not willing to “take no for an answer”. As Shabbat came closer, I had no choice but to starkly present his problem, and asked him, “What would you say if I told you that wearing a cross makes me feel more spiritual? I might “feel more religious”, but it is the wrong religion!”

    Similarly, often a sick person feels wrong when the doctor and rabbi insist that he not fast on Yom Kippur. Yes, it doesn’t “feel religious” to eat on that day, but Judaism is based upon many G-dly actions (including saving life), many of which only activate our religious feeling upon learning the deeper or kabbalistic aspects of those mitzvot. Nevertheless, we “give G-d credit”, that they are worthwhile and beneficial nationally, morally and spiritually even if at present we don’t understand how brushing my teeth the right way on Shabbat makes me more G-dly. True, the Samaritans told me they will not eat on Yom Kippur or drive in an ambulance on Shabbat, and self-righteously tell us “we are more religious than you, and don’t just observe mitzvot when they’re easy!”. On the level of a 5th grader, I could understand them. But a more knowledgeable Jew knows that when seriously ill, it’s precisely MORE religious to eat on Yom Kippur or drive to the hospital or in an IDF patrol on Shabbat.

    One of the major problems among many Haredim is their claim “we feel more religious learning in yeshiva than serving in the IDF”. Again, even if I can sympathize with the rationale of that claim on some level, nevertheless after the halacha clearly states that every healthy Jewish man must actively participate when Am Yisrael is in danger, before worrying about “feeling religious”, one should first “be religious”. We are not Christians nor Samaritans, and are better off letting Hashem, the prophets (who all went to war, e.g. Shoftim 5), the Talmud (Sotah 44a), Rambam (hil. Shabbat ch. 2; M’lachim u’Milchamoteihem 7, 4 and 5, 1) and Shulchan Aruch (Or. Ch. 329), as well as any rabbi who knows and appreciates the needs of the IDF, decide what is “more religious” when Am Yisrael needs combat soldiers.

    Shabbat Shalom and Chag Same’ach!! Rav Ari Shvat (Chwat)

  • BETWEEN CHABAD and RAV KOOK- Erev Pesach which Falls on Shabbat: Example of Shifting Gears to Build a Jewish Nation

    The famed Nazir of Yerushalayim, R. David Cohen, among the closest students of Rav Kook, once asked him: if both religious-Zionism and Chabad love and care about each and every Jew and their observance, and both take the ge’ula seriously as realistic and genuine, so what’s the difference? Rav Kook answered: “We are out to build the nation” (Introduction to Orot HaKodesh, p. 21). We appreciate and support all streams of Judaism for their positive contributions, but today’s current strengthening of Breslav chassidut sharpens this point even more, where the focus is upon MY individual connection with G-d (as opposed to Chabad, where it’s EVERY individual’s), while relatively ignoring the status of Jewish national spirituality, security and physical welfare.

    This year’s unique “Erev Pesach which falls on Shabbat” situation drives this point home (as does selling chametz, Shemitta observance, and many other issues), regarding questions like: what hotels will serve for the double-challah obligation at the 3 Shabbat meals? Without going into all of the details, even in the private home, there’s no perfect solution (we don’t want chametz Challa around the house especially while hosting our grand-children; matzah is prohibited; after the morning- chametz is prohibited; there’s a difference of opinion between Ashkenazim and Sefaradim regarding egg matzah; frying/boiling and then drying matzah is technically infeasible for so many people when there is so much going on at home: finishing Pesach cleaning, preparing for Shabbat, and for the Seder)! How much more so multiply this complexity many times over in hotels. But have you thought of what the entire Israeli army should do, where it’s not just individual affluent families who volunteer to enter this hotel predicament, but rather MANDATORY IDF service for all 18-21 year-olds on a national level?! Especially now during war, when there are more than 100,000 soldiers and thousands of army bases involved!

    An individual family can be machmir (stringent) upon themselves to choose the best among problematic solutions, but hotels, and how much more so a national army, simply cannot. Anyone who cares about Am Yisrael realizes that we must “shift gears” regarding the “klali” halacha of a Jewish State, where it’s not just a difficulty of quantity (both technically and costly), but in a DEMOCRATIC nation of over 7 million Jews, there are obviously going to be many various customs and levels of observance, where there’s both a highest and lowest common denominator, and either way, many will feel slighted.

    My Haredi relatives in Brooklyn don’t even think about such questions, but anyone who cares about Am Yisrael definitely does! A Haredi living in Israel hopefully at least thinks about the question, but then probably sticks his head in the sand, for not wanting to get involved and possibly sacrificing a tiny part of his personal share in the “world-to-come”, for the sake of the national Jewish need.

    The issue comes to the fore now where Haredim know very well that their not serving in the IDF is forcing more and more girls into battle units, with all of the technical and modesty issues involved, for all other (including orthodox) Jews aside themselves. They are against drafting both Haredim and girls, and in the meantime haven’t even taken the trouble to publicize which they prefer: saving their own boys’ “spirituality” while sacrificing the religiousity of the army and the nation, or vice-versa. And what about compromising Jewish security, for the level of those combat units will be lowered to suit the girls’ physical capabilities, or do they only consider their individual selves? I truly hope that war will not strike Haredi neighborhoods, but if so, they might begin to understand that Israel “is really” in danger.

    The IDF has grappled with similar questions every Pesach like negating the holiday-joy of Sefaradic soldiers to effectively eat just potatoes (especially immediately before Pesach where matzah is prohibited) instead of their rich cuisine of satiating kityniyot including: corn, rice, peas, beans… What about R. Yisrael Salanter’s saying, “my fellow Jew’s (or in our case: Jews’!) physical needs are my spiritual needs”!

    The IDF Rabbinate ruled that the army’s order (based on the inability to kasher thousands of army bases on the last 4 days!) to not bring chametz into any army base already the week before Pesach, deems the custom of placing 10 morsels of bread for bedikat chametz impossible and illegal. This halachically non-essential custom would be seen by most Haredi Jews as an afront to their religious freedom, but what do they expect the IDF to do?!!

    A childish response would be to say “it’s their problem”, but that’s clearly not Judaism. In case you haven’t noticed, the G-d Who runs history and brings our national redemption, has decided to force us to take our head out of the sand. Statistically, according to the #1 Jewish demographer Prof. Sergio Della-Pergola, by the end of the 21st century, 20 million Jews (about 80% of world Jewry) will be living in Israel and (as life-expectancy advances), yes, many of you will still be around! Yes, our loving Father is good enough to redeem Israel and extend our life-expectancy, but keeping one’s head in the sand for too long will begin to be dangerous! Especially as Haredim will begin to approach the 50% mark of the national 18 year-olds. The national orientation must eventually change (or more accurately, return to the original).

    Such a “klali” altruistic national mindset will inevitably return all religious to the authentic Torah outlook and realization, that we are not individuals in a tiny shtetl, but once again, we are the authentic Am Yisrael with the Living Torah, who really care not just for ourselves, but about EACH OTHER’S religiosity AND security. With all true respect which we obviously have to always do double-Chalot, and customs regarding kitniyot on Pesach, every (even non-Zionist) rabbi will agree that the present Milchemet Mitzva (saving Israel, Rambam, hil. Milachim u’Milchamoteihem 5, 1 and 7, 4) which should be pre-occupying all of us, is an even greater mitzvah than all these aforementioned examples which are preoccupying us. Shabbat Shalom, Rav Ari Shvat (Chwat)

  • LET’S NOT BLOW IT AGAIN!” Achdut in the IDF and the Mishkan

    A rabbi friend of mine wanted to speak about the idea of Achdut- unity, and asked me if I “could find” a connection with the Mishkan and parsha? I answered that according to Rav Kook, all of Torah and monotheism, is based upon this central issue of Achdut (see my most recent weekly she’ur on YUTorah, “Achdut- Uniting (Even!) the Opposites as THE Central Theme in Rav Kook” (Ayn Aya Shabbat v, 70), and the Mishkan, His “resting place”, is no exception.

    In fact, one of the classic explanations why the Mishkan is reviewed so many times in the Torah, is because the idea of doing away with Bamot (where everyone sacrifices privately and as individuals in their own back yard), and rather having one central national Mikdash and capitol (both religious and political), is a novel innovation of Am Yisrael and monotheism. Similarly, the Mishkan was designed by Betzalel from Shevet Yehuda (the first tribe when traveling in the desert) and Ohaliav from Shevet Dan (the last tribe there), to symbolize that all Israel is involved. “Make a Mikdash and I will dwell in them” (Shmot 25, 8), not “in it” but “in them”= in Israel (Lekach Tov, Truma 25)! Similarly, the Mishkan’s construction is constantly stressing uniting the boards, the curtains, the walls, etc. etc. “והיה המשכן אחד”, “and the Mishkan will be one” (Shmot 26, 6).

    Accordingly, the Talmud teaches that the 2nd Mikdash was destroyed either because of Sinat Chinam (needless hate) or because most of the Jews from Bavel didn’t come on aliya with Ezra (Yoma 9b), where the common denominator between the two, is clearly: a lack of unity. Accordingly, Rav Kook writes (in maybe his most popular quote!) it’s Ahavat Chinam, needless love, which will rebuild our 3rd Commonwealth (Orot HaKodesh iii, pp. 323-324).

    Achdut is another name for G-d, “ואהבת לרעך כמוך, אני ה’”, that when we love each other, Hashem admits that’s how He is revealed in the world. “What does [Hashem] ask from us? That we should love each other” (Midrash Eliahu Rabba 28), for we all know it drives parents crazy when their children fight.

    If unity is not just an ideal, but also logically very beneficial, why do we see it is so hard for Jews? Because “Israel is the most brazen of all nations” (Gittin 25b). The Maharal explains: there’s a fine line between idealism (which is great) and being argumentative (which isn’t!), and that’s what Free-Will is about. As Ben-Gurion said: “Two Jews have three opinions!”. Israeli political infighting, which intelligence revealed is why Hamas moved up their attack, has resurfaced again this week. I can’t believe that our politicians (both “just not Bibi” and “just Bibi” camps) and even more so, security leadership, haven’t learned their lesson! Like all of society’s problems, Rav Kook stresses the solution is not in the leadership (for they are the problem), but in educating the next generation differently (Ma’amarei HaReiya, p. 230). The younger generation of soldiers and officers, religious and non-religious (and hopefully we should involve the Haredim, as well) in the IDF, clearly know how to work together shoulder to shoulder, and we should try transferring the political steering-wheel to them ASAP.

    “אתה אחד ושמך אחד ומי כעמך ישראל גוי אחד בארץ” (עמידה של מנחה בשבת)

    Shabbat Shalom!!! Rav Ari Shvat (Chwat)

  • WHAT DID CHAD GADYA DO TO THE CAT? (Mis)Understanding the Movie “No Other Land

    We often are missing nice divrei Torah for those fun songs at the end of the Seder, so here it goes: The famed R. Yonatan Eibshitz asked: If the cat ate the goat in Chad Gadya, so the dog who ate the cat did the right thing, and the stick who beat the dog is wrong, and the fire who burned the stick is among the “good guys”, etc. The problem is that accordingly, Hashem comes out among the “bad guys” and that cannot be! He answered: Apparently the goat started up with the cat, and our lack of knowledge “who started” led us to the opposite and tragic misunderstanding of the whole story!

    An especially nice and intelligent Jew, after seeing the Academy Award winning anti-Israel movie portraying the IDF as continuously tearing down the homes of innocent Palestinians, wrote “I’m embarrassed to be a Jew!”. On the other hand, upon verifying the facts, it turns out that under the Oslo Accords (which the Palestinian leadership agreed to), Israel has full control over that Masafer Yatta area- known as Area C, and it was those Arabs and their illegal building who were the ones breaking the law, as opposed to the IDF who was simply upholding it.

    This unfortunate situation for which those Arabs are clearly the ones responsible, leaves us no choice but to implement the law as every other country would do, and protect ourselves, even if it doesn’t film well. What is the alternative? To let them do whatever they want and let ourselves be run over by that immoral and law-breaking ideology?

    I was then asked: “But why would people build in an area and spend so much money, where they know their homes will be legally torn down?” It’s a great question for a rational situation, but when it turns out that the anti-Israel European Union supplies most of that building money, it makes more sense.

    A second point is that a similar question can be asked on a larger scale: why do the Gazans and Palestinians in general constantly start wars and use terror against Israel which is much stronger, where they “lose” time after time? The answer is clearly connected to their religious concept of Shahid (holy martyrs) and Jihad war, where even if they are killed and lose, they see it as a ticket to Heaven, so they believe they always gain! I’ve found that this mindset is so different from a western way of thinking, and that’s why many American politicians simply can’t understand that the Arabs are the aggressors, for it really doesn’t make sense why they keep starting up?

    On the other hand, the IDF is comprised of normative, democratic and nice educated Jewish people like our children, who are altruistic enough to volunteer leaving their families for months on end, but instead of thanks, some (even Jews, like Yuval Avraham that movie’s producer) are not even willing to present our side of the story (he knew very well that the easiest way to win awards in Berlin and Hollywood is “Israel-bashing”, especially by an Israeli!). To start showing any scenario from just one lens, and without seeing the law, or the beginning of the story and the decades of irrational war and daily Arab attacks on innocent Jews, is inevitably going to misinform and be very very biased.

    A more objective movie which I myself cannot stomach to watch but is apparently important for the internationally confused to personally see, is the real-time Hamas self-videos which can be found online, where they proudly present and even brag about their sadistic attacks and mutilation of 1200 innocent Israeli citizens on one (!) day! Some of the seemingly unfortunate “No Other Land” scenes were fabricated (see proof on YouTube, but they couldn’t even fabricate similar accusations against the IDF doing such “atrocities” that Arabs have been doing to us for over 50 years), but the Oct. 7th ones are unfortunately real and not fabricated. If you wish to see the whole picture, the latter is surely more real and objective, and it is our boys in the IDF who have been giving their lives day and night for 17 months, who are precisely the “good guys”, and definitely not the “bad guys”.

    Ironically “No Other Land”, would be a much more fitting title for a movie about Israel, as opposed to the other 22 Arab lands, but the first thing one must verify is which side are the victims and which side, the “bad guys”, for it makes a 180-degree difference. See Chad Gadya. Shabbat Shalom, Rav Ari Shvat (Chwat)