Who Pays When War Cancels Your Plans?

Written by

in

Driving lessons, hotel bookings, missed workdays — the halacha of a sudden reserve call-up.

Q. Many monetary questions arose as a result of the sudden war and the last-minute call-ups of the military reserve soldiers. Must we pay for the unexpected cancelation of a driving lesson, hotel reservation or lost work days?

In general, both sides must clearly keep their end of just about any agreement. The Torah knows that life is much nicer in a society when one’s word is honorable, and accordingly, we can honor and trust each other. Nevertheless, if the situation changes unpredictably, the side which must pull back can do so. Accordingly, if you couldn’t make a driving lesson do to a call-up, you don’t have to pay for that lesson. Similarly, if you couldn’t make it to work, the business can’t hold it against you to fire you, but they don’t have to pay your salary for those missed days (unless the government passes explicit directives, which they often do, after military campaigns). Likewise, if you cancelled the reservation because of your husband’s call-up, you don’t have to pay the hotel for something you didn’t use. On the other hand, if you didn’t call the hotel immediately to cancel, and waited until it was too late for them to avail the room for others, than you must pay the hotel (not the entire original cost, but just the loss of profit they incurred). [Based upon R. U. Sadan]

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *