The Torah is deliberately vague here — which the Rav reads as itself being the answer.
Q. How long were the days in creation? It’s important to stress that the Torah is not a history book, nor a science manual, and therefore when such information is purposely vague, that’s the real answer.
We don’t really care how long the days were. If a certain generation has reason to think that the theory of evolution is true and that each day of creation maybe took millions of years, we can fit that into the Torah and should reap the spiritual benefits of that theory in that respective generation, but if science ever claims that it can conclusively prove otherwise, Rav Kook says we’ll be able to fit that into the text, as well. The Talmud teaches us that the real meaning of the story of creation can only be taught to individual and select learned adult students (Chagiga 11b), which infers that it’s clearly not simple and literal.
The term “yom”, throughout the Tanach refers either to the 24 hour unit (called in the Talmud (Brachot 3a) and in modern Hebrew: y’mama, from the same root as “yom”), or sometimes just to the daylight half (as opposed to the night), as is clear from both usages of the term in the fifth verse in the Torah: “And G-d called the light: ‘day’ (yom!) and the darkness: ‘night’, and it was evening, and it was morning, (together=) one “day” (yom!). In short, you always must look at the context. Accordingly, in the creation, it may be otherwise, for the sun and moon were only created on the 4th day, so obviously it’s may be understood differently.
Leave a Reply