What Should Israel Offer Its Arab Citizens?

Written by

in

A proposal tying full civic benefits to full civic obligations.

Q. What can we offer the Arabs?

I think the most practical, logical, democratic and halachic religious-Zionist solution is to offer the Arabs living in the Land of Israel, to vote and enjoy both the pleasures of democracy and the western standard of living which they wouldn’t have anywhere else (!) in the Middle East, but on condition that they fulfill the same obligations of every Jewish citizen. This would include giving three years for national service, paying full taxes and abiding by zoning laws, building restrictions and permits, issues which many Arabs in Israel often don’t fulfill. The present situation, where they enjoy the benefits without (!) most of the obligations, is illogical and undemocratic. The judicial and legislative systems, as well as the police, have been “turning a blind eye”, to keep the present status quo in order to keep the Arabs quiet, but that’s clearly unjust towards the Jewish citizens who must fulfill all requirements, and also not wise, for we all must learn there are “no free meals” in life. This is best for all involved.

My educated guess is that for political reasons, as well as social and international pressure (from Arabs abroad), and probably even physical threats from the Islamic terrorist groups, the vast majority of them would opt, in such a case, to forego their Israeli citizenship, even though such refusal would be truly counterproductive for them. We could and should then treat them accordingly, as any western country treats a local who doesn’t fulfill his obligations to society and the law, with fines and sanctions, gradually suspending their benefits, or convincing them that justice and fairness are the best approach.

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *