Why Do We Read the Tochecha Quietly?

Written by

in

Not to hide from it, but not to dwell there either — plus the Sanzer Rebbe’s post-Holocaust reversal of the custom.

Q. Why do we read the Tochechah (curse) quietly?

The custom isn’t to shove it under the rug but not to stress the negative. There’s a power in speech, to add positive (or negative) feelings, just like we wouldn’t say: you may get cancer. On the other hand, we recognize that reward and punishment are part of life, so we don’t skip, yet read it softly. In the Brooklyn shul of the Sanzer Rebbe, 7 years after the holocaust in which the rebbe’s wife and 13 children were murdered, when the Torah reader began the tochecha quietly, the rebbe whispered to him to read louder. Wondering if he’d heard the rebbe correctly, he continued. The rebbe than turned around to face his hasidim, banged on the table and shouted: “I said: louder! Let the Master of the Universe hear! We have nothing to be afraid of. We have already received all of the curses- and more! Let Him hear and understand that the time has come to send the subsequent blessings!” The reader obliged. At the end of musaf, the rebbe explained, “My beloved friends, the blessings will come, but not from America. G-d has promised the blessings after the curses, but they will only come from the Land of Israel. Let us pack our bags for the last time. Our community is setting out for Israel!” Indeed, soon afterwards, the rebbe led his flock to settle in Netanya, where they founded Kiryat Zanz and the Laniado hospital!

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *