Is a Midrash About Avraham Really First Found in the Quran?

Written by

in

The actual rabbinic source predates it by centuries — it just wasn’t in the midrashim you’d think to check.

Q. Someone told me that the oldest written source of the midrash about how Avraham “found” G-d, after the sun set and the moon disappeared, is in the Moslem Quran. Could that be true?

The ancient rabbinic source you are looking for is found in a midrash from the ancient Cairo Geniza (Mann ed., p. 42), as well as the Zohar I, 86a, and the Otzar HaMidrashim I, p. 7. Although your question is probably based on the fact that this midrash doesn’t appear in the more common midrashic compilations (like Midrash Rabba, Tanchuma or the Talmud), nevertheless, hundreds, if not thousands (!), of ancient midrashim, like this one, are only found in other ancient midrashic sources (like the aforementioned, or Midrash HaGadol). Here’s a good example that one must often invest time and effort to find sources, and not just rely on the books found at home! Additionally, it’s common knowledge that many places in the Quran reflect Jewish traditions, which were all passed down orally (!) and only beginning about 1,850 years ago, many (but not all!) were put into writing in the midrashim (beforehand, it was prohibited to write them down). Accordingly, there’s nothing wrong or suspicious about saying that the first place a certain midrash may have been written down was the Quran. In short, this midrash is clearly “kosher”, and legitimately “mainstream” as part of the Jewish tradition, and subsequently cited by many later rabbinic sources.

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *