Impure-animal restrictions are a Torah category — they never applied to Noach, or to anyone else outside it.
Q. G-d clearly punished the world because of the sin of the people. If there was no Torah, then why was sin punished? After Noach left the ark, Hashem said he could eat all the moving animals of the earth. I understand that concept of pure and impure animals was known by Noach. Why did Hashem tell Noach he could eat all meats while he may not sacrifice impure animals, and He later forbids those same meats?
The world was punished in the time of Noach because they didn’t observe even the most basic and elementary morality, for which every human being was obligated, even before the giving of the Torah. Idolatry, adultery, murder, and theft are not so demanding, yet even that, they transgressed. Impure animals are not forbidden for non-Jewish consumption, not before the giving of the Torah, and not afterwards, not for Noach and not for President Trump. Just as if I, as a non-Cohen, were to give a sacrifice or chant the priestly blessing, it wouldn’t have Torah significance, and similarly, there’s no reason for me not to go to cemeteries. So too, there’s no reason for a non-Jew to wear tfilin, nor abstain from bacon. Even if Noach gave kosher sacrifices, that has nothing to do with his own personal diet. In short, G-d is exact regarding every commandment, regarding who, what, where, when and how they are obligated or exempt, and it’s not our place, nor Noah’s, to “invent” new commandments when they don’t apply.
Leave a Reply