THE ‘EVIL’ IN TEHILIM?

Written by

in

Q. I am learning sefer Tehillim and see many references to tzadikim and resha’im (perfectly good people and evil people). Of course, most people are somewhere in the middle. Still, David HaMelech speaks about evil people as those who ignore Hashem’s mitzvot, and who are more concerned about people not catching them at doing bad things than about what Hashem sees and knows.

This got me thinking. For the vast majority of Jewish history, virtually all Jews learned and tried to follow the Torah. Those who rebelled against the Torah left the fold completely. But nowadays, particularly in Israel, the situation is different. Many people believe in G-d and follow some of the traditions (since the beginning of the current war, these numbers are BH rising). Most “secular” Jews are good people who do not wish any harm on our nation. Rather, they love our people and our land. So many non-religious Jews do so much chessed and risk their lives in the IDF, etc. These people know about Torah laws, but do not consider themselves “religious,” therefore choose which mitzvot to follow and which not to. I would like to think that these are not resha’im. I would like to hope that these Jews are considered “somewhere in the middle.” But according to what I have learned in sefer Tehillim, people who choose not to follow the Torah are seen as evil. I would appreciate your perspective on this issue.

A. Regarding the definition of “resha’im” in both Tehilim and today, it all depends why those people chose not to follow the Torah. It’s true that there were almost no atheists in the time of King David, and most of the “evil” in Tehilim are referring to pagan gentiles, who really were evil both spiritually and morally. Over the last several generations already, it’s unanimous, spanning from Rav Kook (Igrot 555) to the Chazon Ish (Y.D. 2, 6-16) to Rav Ovadia Yosef (Chazon Ovadia, Kaddesh), that there are almost not such people in Am Yisrael (unfortunately, although many of the gentiles have matured, we see throughout the world and especially in the Middle East, that there still are evil gentiles).

The 2 most common reasons there are no Jewish “resha’im” today are as follows: With so many anti-religious influences around us (e.g. social media, relatively anti-religious press…), most non-believers are considered Tinok Shenishba (like a child who was kidnapped and raised by gentiles) and is not responsible for his own lack of proper Jewish education and surroundings (Rambam Mamrim 3, 3, “whom we should try returning through ways of shalom”). Alternatively, the Ramban (Bamidbar 15, 22 · chumash) regarding the accidental sin offering of the nation (chatat shogeg tzibbur), gives the example of a society who thinks that the Torah’s time has passed, but not applicable for all [modern] generations (which could have been written today!).

Rav Kook (“HaDor”) goes further that, as you inferred, the secular Jews today, surely those in Israel, are particularly idealistic, and their ideals are truly Torah ones, but they are often “turned off” by certain old-fashion and Galuti elements that they see among the religious. Their love of Israel, the Land, the Nation, and their desire to be part of Jewish destiny has been demonstrated every day of the past two years, since the Hamas attack, often more than among those considered “religious”. Similarly the statistically proven national reawakening which you mentioned, to be that much more traditional as expressed in prayer, tefillin, tzitzit, song (the official Song of the Year on Galei Tzahal was: “Hashem Yitbarach always loves me!”), Shabbat candles, and taking Challah, is just an expression of the latent Emuna (belief) that’s ALWAYS THERE but is just waiting to be awakened and “by-pass” the distractions and anti-religious element around!

All Jews have the same G-dly soul, “This nation I CREATED for Me, they will tell of My praise” (Yeshaya 43, 21). We must “seize the moment”, and not let the politicians and media ruin the present national natural unity and Emuna. Shabbat Shalom! Rav Ari Shvat (Chwat)

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *