Should We Forgive Those Who Kill Out of Antisemitism?

Written by

in

How should a Jew relate to someone who murdered a fellow Jew purely out of religious hatred?

Q. To support this question I would like to know should we forgive a person who killed a Jew out of antisemitism (e.g. a Muslim terrorist) ? How should we treat this person in fact if it happens that we meet this person ?

We actually sing and praise G-d when He avenges our blood and punishes our enemies, as on Purim, Pesach, Chanuka, etc. Whenever we could (as above), we ourselves avenged our brothers’ blood, fighting the enemy as did all of the heroes of the Tanach, Avraham (when they kidnapped Lot), Moshe (slaying the Egyptian who beat the Jew), all of the Books of Judges, Samuel, and Kings Saul, David, in fact all of the kings did so (even Yael killed Sisera after the war was over, Judges 4). Only Achav is punished for having mercy on the enemy King Ben-Haddad at the end of the war (Kings I, ch. 20) and the prophet rebukes him, that G-d will do to you like you should have done to the enemy. Judaism does not “turn the other cheek” but fights evil and avenges wrong. We believe that it’s moral to fight evil, and thus save the underdog, society (Am Yisrael), and the evil themselves- by deterring them and showing the price they will pay, and that they are better off being nice, getting married and having a nice family!

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *