Sarah’s request to send away Hagar and Yishmael looks harsh on its face – how do the sources actually judge it?
Q. In parashat Vayera we see that Sarah asked Gd to expel Hagar and Ishmael so that Ishmael doesn’t inherit together with Itzhak. this seems like a bad thing to do in my opinion. what is the explanation? wasn’t it mean of Sarah to do so? even if Ishmael isn’t her son, she herself wanted Avraham to marry Hagar… it seems out of character for her to do such a harsh thing
In fact there are midrashim which seem to criticize Sara. On the other hand, by this stage Yishmael is already making problems and fighting with Yitzchak, where a 13 year difference between fighting children is really a lot, and a problematic difference. Also remember that these are not just children, but Sara & Avraham already know that they are to be the future heads of nations, Yitzchak who will be the father of the Chosen People, and Yishmael who will be his nemesis! Nevertheless, Avraham also felt that it wasn’t right to expel them, until G-d told him that he should listen to Sara, for in this case, it’s the right thing to do, to insure Yitzchak’s proper education and clarify that only he will be Avraham’s spiritual & national continuation.
Leave a Reply