Is it appropriate for Jews to hold a deliberately public prayer service as a form of protest?
Q. Is it allowed when groups of Jews use prayer to protest something in public? Meaning we deliberately hold a public prayer service like shacharit in order to protest something. The event could actually lead to more fights. As much as I would want to do it, it seems wrong to use a prayer service to protest, whether people call it a protest or not, it’s exactly what it is.
There is no black-and-white answer to such a question, and anyone organizing such an event must confer with rabbinic authorities who are also involved in communal or national leadership, to weigh all of the factors, benefits and drawbacks involved. In general, the Living-Torah sees protests, especially regarding our beloved and G-dly Jewish State and Land, when appropriate, not only as legitimate but obligatory and spiritual, just as prayer! In the words of the saintly R. Yisrael Salanter: “The physical needs of my Jewish brother/brethren are my spiritual needs!”.
Leave a Reply