When major authorities disagree on something as basic as reincarnation, how should a Jew navigate believing either side?
Q. When there is a debate in Jewish thought, e.g. most opinions believe there is such a thing as reincarnation but the rambam and rav sadia gaon believe there isn’t ,is that a situation where it is elu velu or is one wrong?
It’s a good example of “elu va’elu” (that both opinions are legitimate Torah opinions), e.g. before studying each one, we must say Birchat HaTorah. In the end, we’ll see who is correct (or both, for perhaps there is a certain amount of reincarnation in certain cases), but in the meantime, both give important Torah messages. On the one hand, even if a person makes terribly wrong and bad decisions, he can always get another chance, yet the main point is this world, and we shouldn’t “push off” that improvement and correction for “another life”, but do it today!
Leave a Reply