Q. Why are the IDF boys who fight and even fall, considered “Al Kiddush Hashem” (sanctifying G-d’s Name), if some of them are not religious? Q. Why does it say in this week’s parsha that avenging the attack of Midian is “to avenge for G-d” (Bamidbar 31, 3) and also “to avenge for Israel (31, 2)? A. These 2 questions which I received separately, in fact answer each other.
The Rambam writes, “Kiddush Hashem is the opposite of Chilul Hashem” (=profaning His Name, Igrot HaRambam, p. 55). The Moslem Jihad (Holy War) thinks to “prove” that G-d is Moslem and is interested in barbaric slaughtering, based upon their successful terrorism. The “Allahu Akhbar” cry of Islamic terrorists repeatedly heard on the films of the Hamas attack of Oct. 7th and over the past century, literally declares: “our G-d is the strongest”, intending to put down the G-d of Israel. Rav Soloveitchik relates to a similar claim of Christianity that arrogantly wished to “prove” that G-d is Christian, using the Crusades, anti-Semitism and the Holocaust as evidence that He has abandoned the Jewish people (” Kol Dodi Dofek”, Ish HaEmuna [Heb.], 78-79).
As the true representatives of Hashem in the world (e.g. Dvarim 14, 2, “G-d chose you, from among all the nations, to be His treasured Nation; Yishayahu 43, 10, “You are My witnesses”), the international status of Israel is a reflection upon Him, for better or worse. Not only do our individual or national moral and spiritual actions make a Kiddush Hashem or Chilul Hashem in the world (Yoma 86a), but our national pride and military status as seen in the eyes of the gentiles reflects and influences how they view Judaism and the G-d of Israel. The famed R. Yechiel Ya’akov Weinberg pointed out that the State of Israel and the IDF victories show, for those who may have doubted after the Holocaust, that the G-d of Israel is “alive and well” and the Jews are “still” and eternally the Chosen People. He doesn’t change His mind, nor make mistakes (Shmuel I, 15, 29). Conversely, when the IDF and Israel are chalila perceived as weak, this can once again raise the heads, rifles and lies of our Jihadic enemies.
“My tears were [constant]… for they (the gentiles) constantly say to me: Where is your G-d?! (Psalms 42, 4)”. “Oh Lord, have pity on Your nation, and do not disgrace Your Land to be ruled by [foreign] nations. Why should they say among the nations, ‘Where is their G-d?’” (Yoel 2, 17). Accusing: if He is the G-d of Israel, why doesn’t He come to your rescue, Israel?
Accordingly, “Whoever slaps a Jew in the face, is as if he slapped the cheek of G-d” (Sanhedrin 58b; Rambam Hil. M’lachim u’Milchamoteihem 10, 6). When an anti-Semite taunts a Jew, he isn’t relating to him as an individual, for usually, he doesn’t even know his victim! Rather, he is spitting upon the Jewish people, religion and G-d. Even if some of our soldiers and political leaders are not religious and subsequently don’t see the Arab-Israeli struggle as a religious war, as soon as our enemies declare it as such (“Jihad”), whether we like it or not, understand it or not, believe it or not, it is a religious issue of Kiddush or Chillul Hashem.
As G-d’s representative to the world, today that we have no prophecy, Israel is meant to reveal G-d to the world not only by building an “Or Lagoyim” (Yishayahu 42, 6), an ideal and moral exemplary state run according to the G-dly ideals (Rav Kook, Orot, 104), but also by our very existence and national status which must be strengthened by soundly defeating our immoral adversaries (Rav Kook, Pinkasei HaReiya iii, p. 312). This concept is summarized well among the daily morning brachot, “Through Your salvation You will exalt and raise our [Israel’s] pride. Blessed are You G-d, Who sanctifies Your Name among the multitudes”, and “קומה ד’ ויפוצו אויביך” (Bamidbar 10, 35).
An objective Christian theologian Paul Van Buren clarifies this point, in answering why the world is disproportionately preoccupied with the State of Israel: “With Israel back on the scene again, the whole [Bible] story suddenly becomes modern. For anyone with a biblical faith, the existence of this [Jewish] state with Jerusalem as its capital, reawakens the whole possibility that this is not all in the past. Maybe G-d is not as dead as we thought?”
Accordingly, our sages teach:”You find that whoever helps Israel is as if he helps He Who created the world, as it says “for they didn’t come to help G-d” (Shoftim 5, 23). It doesn’t say: “To help us” but rather “to help G-d”. And similarly it is written, “one who touches you [Israel] is as if he touches the apple of His [G-d’s] eye (Zecharia 2, 12), and anyone who rises up against Israel is as if he rises up against He Who created the world” (Yalkut Shimoni, Shoftim, 55).
In short, to avenge for Israel is to avenge for Hashem, the G-d of Israel. This also explains why, in the parsha, Moshe is outraged at the tribes of Reuven and Gad: “will your brothers go to war and you just stay sitting here?!” (32, 6). Yes, Hashem wants “our help” not just through prayer, but to actually help “carry the burden” in battle, and this Kiddush Hashem is explicitly what will bring Hashem to speedily bring our total victory. The words of the Torah are clear and eternal, and to claim that this doesn’t apply today is profane. Shabbat Shalom! Rav Ari Shvat (Chwat)