The essence of Yerushalayim is that she “unites it all” (Tehilim 122, 3). When she is complete, our capitol unites the national (King’s palace), the religious (Sanhedrin) and the universal (Beit Hamikdash, “כי ביתי בית תפילה ייקרא לכל העמים”, ישע’ נו, ז), or the right-wing, the left-wing and religious. As we learned together, Rav Kook writes that these are the 3 ideologies which comprise mankind, and like 3 sides of a triangle, they must each kiss, as well as limit the other 2 from going to an extreme (Orot, pp. 70-72). It’s not a coincidence that davka David HaMelech, who was a nationalist, religious and sensitive/poetic leader, acquired Yerushalayim.
Accordingly, Yom Yerushalayim during our present war with Hamas is an ideal time to call the Haredim to join our dangerously under-manned army. Just as Rav Sraya Deblitzky zt”l, one of the leading Haredi (!) rabbis of the previous generation in Bnei Brak, couldn’t believe that many Haredim don’t celebrate Yom Yerushalayim, simply because religious people are often so “wary of change”, they forget the elementary decency of thanking Hashem for His great salvations. Similarly, any objective study will reveal within 5 minutes that all Yeshiva boys are obligated to serve in the IDF, as they must in every Milchemet Mitzva (Sotah 44a; Rambam hil M’lachim u’Milchamoteihem 7, 4 and 5, 1) of protecting Israel from dangers.
But let’s be honest, that part of the real problem is that the army must also take a step forward to accept the Haredim and leave their hubris and anti-democratic position of trying and convince those wavering Haredim who do draft, to leave their understanding of religion (albeit galuti).
It took me years in the army to realize that most generals in the IDF are not leftists because they’re generals, but rather they are generals because they are leftist, and they are the only ones who can advance past Brigadier General. Those idealistic leftist generals must become truly democratic and also stop “stopping” the advance of religious Zionist colonels. If most of the officers on the battle-field are religious-Zionists, and similarly are most of the fallen combat soldiers in this present war, it’s unthinkable that just a disproportionately small minority of RZ are allowed to become generals and influence the army to be more offensive and spiritual. The biggest mistaken conception which led to this war with Hamas is the IDF’s thinking that defense is enough. Just like we need an over-haul in our political leadership, so too we need to have equal representation in the only left-wing army in the world! Not just for the sake of fairness and true democracy, but mainly, because we need to add (not replace!) an additional alternative military mindset, to the present homogeneous and “war-avoiding” generals.
David HaMelech knew that Yehuda alone (in sefer Yehoshua 15, 63) and Binyamin alone (in sefer Shoftim 1, 21) couldn’t conquer Yerushalaim, so he left Chevron (the capitol of Yehuda) and united the sons of Rachel and Leah and only then succeeded. In the War of Independence, the Hagana, Irgun and Stern Gang were not yet united, so we didn’t liberate Yerushalayim until the united IDF did so in the Six Day War, 19 years later. Similarly, we don’t want to “overtake” the leftist monopoly in the Supreme Court or the upper echelons of the IDF, but the time has come for true equality and democracy. This will enable the Haredim to draft, and bring all camps to unity and mutual respect. Both Religious-Zionism and Yerushalayim show that yes, we can unite and harmonize the nationalist, moral and religious!
Shabbat Shalom,
Rav Ari Shvat (Chwat)