Category: Weekly Letters

  • THE MASTER PAINTER and the IDF

    The master of parables, the Dubna Maggid tells: There was once a world-renowned artist who was commissioned to paint a landscape for a great king. The artist spent years perfecting his craft, using his incredible talent to paint a scene of a lush forest, a rushing river, and a distant mountain range.

    The painting was so breathtakingly realistic—the shading of the leaves, the reflection on the water, the texture of the rocks—that it transcended art. When it was finally unveiled in the royal gallery, the viewers were stunned. However, a strange thing happened:

    Instead of praising the artist for his skill, the people began to walk right past him. They pointed at the painting and said, “Look at that beautiful forest! Look at how clear that water is!” Because the painting was TOO PERFECT, the people forgot it was a painting at all. They MISTOOK IT FOR A WINDOW. They believed they were looking at reality, and thus, they saw no need to credit the artist.

    The artist, seeing that his genius was being overlooked because of its very perfection, walked up to the canvas. In front of the gasping crowd, he took a knife and SLASHED THE CANVAS right down the middle.

    Only when the “sky” tore and the “mountains” parted did the people realize: “This wasn’t nature. This was the work of a master creator.”

    The Moral: Why the Sea Split

    The Dubno Maggid explains that this is how G-d runs the world.

    • The Painting: The “Natural World” is G-d’s masterpiece. It is so consistent, so beautiful, and so perfectly functional that humans often mistake it for a self-sustaining system. We see the sun rise and the tides turn, and we call it “Nature,” forgetting the Artist behind it.

    • The Tear: On the seventh day of Passover, the Jewish people were trapped at the sea. To remind the world (and the Jewish people) that “Nature” is merely a canvas, G-d “slashed” the sea.

    • The Lesson: When the water—which naturally flows—stood up like a wall, the “canvas” of nature was torn. In that moment, everyone realized that the water only flows because the Artist wills it to flow.

    As the Midrash says, even a handmaid at the sea saw a level of prophecy greater than the prophet Ezekiel. By “tearing” the world, G-d forced everyone to look past the scenery and see the Creator.

    This is why we read the Shira (Song of the Sea) and the Haftarah of David on the 7th day of Pesach. Both are songs of recognition. After the “tearing of the canvas,” the people finally had the clarity to sing, “This is my G-d, and I will glorify Him.” [cited by my friend and relative R. Paysach Krohn, may this bring merit to his speedy refuah shleima among the rest of the wounded and sick of Israel].

    Similarly, we’ve gotten so used to Hashem’s salvation via the IDF in our present war with Iran, we can mistakenly take it all for granted! Let’s learn from Moshe and David HaMelech, that the war’s of Israel are also run by G-d, as Rav Kook points out: “בעל מלחמות… מצמיח ישועות” or in the words of Chazal, “מלחמות נמי אתחלתא דגאולה היא”, “wars are also the beginning of redemption” (Megilla 17b, incidentally, the only time the term “atchalta d’ge’ula” is found in the Talmud, is regarding the wars of Israel which not only shouldn’t get us down, but are actually part of the process, as seen in Yechezkel 38-39, and Zecharia 14!). Chag Same’ach, appreciating Hashem’s miracles בימים ההם ובזמן הזה ! Rav Ari Shvat (Chwat)

  • Between CHAD GADYA and V’hi She’Amdah

    We often are missing nice divrei Torah for those fun songs at the end of the Seder, so here it goes: The famed R. Yonatan Eibshitz asked: If the cat ate the goat in Chad Gadya, so the dog who ate the cat did the right thing, and the stick who beat the dog is wrong, and the fire who burned the stick is among the “good guys”, etc. etc. The problem is that accordingly, Hashem comes out among the “bad guys”, and that cannot be! He answered: Apparently the goat started up with the cat, and our lack of knowledge “who started” led us to the opposite and tragic misunderstanding of the whole story!

    An especially nice and intelligent Jew, after seeing the Academy Award winning anti-Israel movie “No Other Land”, portraying the IDF as continuously tearing down the homes of innocent Palestinians, wrote me “I’m embarrassed to be a Jew!”. On the other hand, upon verifying the facts, it turns out that under the Oslo Accords (which the Palestinian leadership agreed to), Israel has full control over that Masafer Yatta area- known as Area C, and it was those Arabs and their illegal building who were the ones breaking the law, as opposed to the IDF who was simply upholding it.

    This unfortunate situation for which those Arabs themselves are clearly the ones responsible, leaves us no choice but to implement the law as every other country would do, and protect ourselves, even if it doesn’t film well. What is the alternative? To let them do whatever they want and let ourselves be run over by that immoral and law-breaking ideology?

    He then asked me: “But why would people build in an area and spend so much money, where they know their homes will be legally torn down?” It’s a great question for a rational situation, but when it turns out that the anti-Israel European Union supplies most of that building money, it makes more sense.

    He then asked me a similar question on a larger scale: why do the Gazans, Palestinians in general, Hizballah and the Hutis constantly start wars and use terror against Israel which is much stronger, where they bezH “lose” time after time? The answer is clearly connected to their religious concept of Shahid (holy martyrs) and Jihad (Holy War), where even if they are killed and lose, they see it as a ticket to Heaven, so they believe they always gain! I’ve found that this mindset is so different from a western way of thinking, and that’s why many American politicians, and even Jews there, simply can’t understand that the Arabs are the aggressors, for it really doesn’t make sense, why they keep starting up?

    On the other hand, the IDF is comprised of normative, democratic and nice educated Jewish people like our children, who are altruistic enough to volunteer leaving their families for months on end, but instead of thanks, some (even Jews, like Yuval Avraham that movie’s producer) are not even willing to present our side of the story (he knew very well that the easiest way to win awards in Berlin and Hollywood is “Israel-bashing”, especially by an Israeli!). To start showing any scenario from just one lens, and without seeing the law, or the beginning of the story and the decades of irrational war and daily Arab attacks on innocent Jews, is inevitably going to misinform and be very very biased. Accordingly, the Arab producers at the Academy Awards couldn’t even mention (!) our innocent kidnapped hostages, and some got angry at Yuval Avraham who did, which testifies to their selective “humanism”.

    A more objective movie which I myself cannot stomach to watch but is apparently important for the internationally confused (especially Jews!) to personally see, is the real-time Hamas self-videos which can be found online, where they gleefully present and even brag about their sadistic murder and mutilation of 1200 innocent Israeli citizens on one (!) day! Some of the seemingly unfortunate “No Other Land” scenes were fabricated (see proof on YouTube, but they couldn’t even fabricate similar accusations against the IDF doing such “atrocities” that Arabs have been doing to us for over 50 years), but the Simchat Torah (Oct. 7th) ones are unfortunately real and not fabricated. If you wish to see the whole picture, the latter is surely more real and objective, and it is our boys in the IDF who have been giving their lives day and night for 2 and a half years, who are precisely the “Good Guys”, and definitely not the “Bad Guys”.

    Our present war with Iran is another reminder to the world who are the Bad-Guys who want to Nuke the Good-Guys, but here too, surprisingly many Americans are against the war (I imagine not siding with Iran, simply naive…)

    Ironically “No Other Land”, would be a much more fitting title for a movie about Israel, as opposed to the other 22 Arab lands, but the first thing one must verify is which side are the victims and which side, the “Bad Guys”, for it makes a 180-degree difference. See Chad Gadya. Chag Same’ach v’Kasher! Rav Ari Shvat (Chwat)

  • TODAY STATISTICALLY OUTDOES PESACH!

    Q. You wrote last week about the “Kvetchers” in Israel in our war with Iran. But with all due respect, how can we not complain when running to shelters, and shrapnel or missiles are falling, and our fellow Jews wounded and frightened?

    A. Crying out and praying to G-d is always good, especially when many of His people are inconvenienced or frightened. But we dealt here with how NOT to be scared, not just as a strategic beneficial mindset, but also because it’s really TRUE!

    As we wrote, undoubtedly there were pessimists and Kvetches as G-d delivered us from Egypt, but they were proven totally wrong. Moreover, in the Haggada’s machloket (Brachot 1, 5), the halachic conclusion is like Ben Zoma, that we must mention G-d’s taking us out of Egypt every night (not just in the day), but NOT in Y’mot HaMashiach (Rambam Kr.Sh. 1, 3; Mishna Brura 67, 3-4), for we can ALREADY see that the final redemption PALES and OVERSHADOWS the Exodus from Mitzra’im.

    Without getting into the discussion of who and when can we make that modification in our daily, weekly and yearly calendar, that Yom HaAtzma’ut, Yom Yerushalayim and future celebrations will REPLACE Yitzia’t Mitzra’im, objectively TODAY’S REDEMPTION is ALREADY much greater on 6 accounts (doubling the list of R. Uri Cherki):

    1. It’s been 2,000 years of hell, not just 210.

    2-3. The salvation follows an unprecedented systemic and sadistic murder of 6,000,000 Jews, not just slavery (qualitative) of about 2,000,000 (quantitative).

    4. Today’s redemption is from 102 different countries in 6 vastly dispersed continents, not just from Egypt.

    5. This century’s redemption is through natural and not super-natural means, showing that G-d totally controls and solves even the most complicated complex problems over long periods of time, unlike the quick ‘zapping’ in Egypt (which BTW was followed by many difficulties and kvetchings during 40 years in the desert…). In one of his classic letters Rav Kook writes to Rav Charlap (Igrot HaReiya 753), “Woe, we should not leave NATURE in her lowly status, without connecting her with the holy bond of eternal light… The fact that the redemption of Israel is approaching “bit by bit” (gradually and naturally, as we were taught, Yerushalmi Brachot 1, 1) is NOT WEAKNESS, but rather Gevura shebaGevurot (the ultimate in greatness of G-d). Not b’dieved but for us, it’s l’chatchila!

    6. This redemption is final, and there won’t be another exile (just Google: Another Exile Ari Shvat), while boy, have there been a lot of exiles since Egypt!

    In addition, we should stop arguing about whether the glass is half-full or half-empty and be grateful that we HAVE A GLASS at all. Moreover, the glass is always 100% full: half with water, and half with air, because everything has value, even the aspects that seem “empty” or invisible, like peace or especially educational lessons.

    “The optimist sees the glass as half-full. The pessimist sees the glass as half-empty. The engineer sees a glass that is twice as large as it needs to be.” Let’s start viewing our situations from a new, G-dly and historical perspective.

    Statistically, the missiles are getting scarcer, an average of 10-15 a day. From the beginning of the Lion’s Roar operation, 400 missiles have been fired towards Israel, and the IDF has successfully intercepted over 92%. Nevertheless, security has constantly stressed that our world-leading advanced defense system is not air-tight, so civilians MUST go to shelters. MOST of those killed or wounded were those who didn’t follow the security directives, because of psychological, “religious” or sociological excuses. The Rambam, writing as world-leading rabbi, philosopher and doctor COMBINED, writes (Guide for the Perplexed 3, 12) that most of the problems and pain in the world we bring upon ourselves (I’ve heard some expressly say, “we’re not “makpid” on shelters”).

    As I return home once again from my shelter (together with millions of other Israelis), in wake of the aforementioned ideas, I strongly suggest reading last week’s post once-again, to be that much more thankful to Hashem and His Jewish State and IDF. If shelters and army are the price we must pay to rid ourselves from those who wish to nuke us, let’s not kvetch but objectively rejoice upon where we are in Jewish history.

    Who knows, perhaps chalila their own wounded may lessen the derision in Bnei Brak towards human efforts on behalf of Jewish security to undergo some important rethinking, which will also be a significant Teshuva and return to the original Torah (Rambam) approach, obligating shelters and armies. In truth, more important than if the glass is half-full or half-empty; is that we should all learn there is a FAUCET nearby that we should notice and use! Rav Ari Shvat (Chwat)

  • ON KVETCHERS and PROPORTIONS

    As we approach Pesach, imagine if during the Ten Plagues, someone complained they can’t sleep because the Egyptians are crying too loudly, or about the pain of asking neighbors for wealth and Oy, having to pack for a long journey of Matzah! I would guess the complainer is a little child who doesn’t fathom the greatness of freedom from slavery which will be celebrated forever.

    I remember overhearing a stewardess grumble that the flights to Israel are particularly trying because Jews tend to be real Kvetches. Some may even remember the SNL sketch about “The Weiners” (Whiners), who you couldn’t miss were distinctively Jewish! That’s the 40 years in the desert!

    We see in this week’s Haftarah, “This nation [Israel] I created for Myself; they shall recite My praise” (Yishaya 43, 21). I think the pshat is that in the ge’ula, EVEN the Jewish Kvetches will have no choice but to recognize and praise G-d. He’s addressing 2,000 years of neurotic Jews, “And now, listen, Jacob My servant, and Israel whom I have chosen. So said the Lord your Maker, and He Who formed you from the womb shall aid you. FEAR NOT, My servant Jacob, and Yeshurun whom I have chosen. As I will pour water on the thirsty and running water on dry land (sound familiar from the 40 desert years, 44).”

    Despite all the anti-Semitism until this very day, which apparently gives us a “right” to be nervous and kvetch, G-d again allays our fears, “Fear not and be not dismayed; did I not tell you way back… and you are My witnesses; is there a god besides Me?!” (ibid). We have seen over the last century that MOST of the prophecies of redemption have already been fulfilled, so we Jews better get used to not kvetching. Mention at this year’s Seder: the Netziv stresses that G-d told the kvetching Moshe, “DON’T TELL ME HOW TO RUN MY REDEMPTION!, and adds that this message is for modern anti-Zionists, as well! (Shmot 4, 13 and Shivat Tzion, p. 17).

    “But the State of Israel and the IDF are not 100% religious!” they kvetch (ignoring that neither were our fathers in Egypt, and most Jews and people in the western world aren’t either…), but G-d teaches us patience, ” This one shall say, “I am the Lord’s,” and this one shall call himself by the name of Jacob, and this one shall write [with] his hand, “To the Lord,” and adopt the name Israel” (ibid).

    Keeping proportions is particularly important for Jews in general, and especially in Israel today. One can understand the complaints about 3 AM sirens to shlep down 3 flights to the shelter with a child on each arm and a third on your shoulders on an average of once a night, but don’t forget that just 2 weeks ago it used to be several times a night (and thank G-d we have shelters!). Feel PAIN but NOT DESPAIR when remnants of exploded Iranian missiles meet up with Israeli Iron Dome shells and rain debris breaking windshields and an occasional home, but would we rather not have worked decades to discover the Iron Dome, Arrow and David’s Sling and have to deal with the missiles themselves?!

    For decades the worst scenario imagined in Israel was a full-scale war with Iran, our largest, most sophisticated enemy with the most oil, Russian aid and nuclear plans. Well, that day is here, and we must profusely thank G-d and the IDF for pre-empting them with unprecedented intelligence, and professionalism to take out their entire leadership, anti-aircraft missiles and blow up their boats, planes and launchers without contest. We must thank Hashem for an American leadership, aid and military support, and for their generous replenishing of our shells (which was one of the biggest kvetches in the war against Hamas, that BH we eliminated our enemies at will, but were running low on ammo)! Others kvetch that we have to kill so many enemies, but that surely isn’t up to us.

    Let’s be honest and objective, just 2 generations from the Holocaust. We have no right to complain about our sons being called up for the 5th time to go and conquer Lebanon as far as we want (how many armies know that victory is BH guaranteed?!), and we must still thank G-d and the IDF for those victories and consistent motivation. But we DO have a right to kvetch that many Jews (in Israel and abroad) belittle and don’t appreciate the years of research, and hundreds of days and nights of soldiers’ service, and don’t share the burden in the army. I think we can justifiably demand that they at least educate their children to participate in the next war, so that eventually we may ALL not have to run to shelters!

    Our complaining shouldn’t hide the glory of the G-d-sent victory, which COULD NOT HAVE BEEN ANY EASIER (except were more Jews willing to share the burden). Let’s not forgot that we’re winning. Some people feel uncomfortable thanking G-d, and begrudgingly the IDF and the State of Israel whom He uses as His shlichim, for it may legitimize drafting yeshiva boys. Well maybe it does, but that doesn’t mean not to give credit, praise and thanks where it is due! Shabbat Shalom, Rav Ari Shvat (Chwat)

  • Between the Labor Room and Bachelordom: Faith in the Fog of War

    It has been 12 days since war erupted in Israel. Sirens, shelters, schools closed, and a nation mobilized for reserve duty. One question hovers in the air: When will it end? When can we finally return to a normal routine without fearing the next siren?

    The truth is, nobody knows (not even Trump, only the true “King of the World”). But perhaps the truly important question isn’t exactly when it will finish, but rather: What should be our approach/mindset until then?

    Here are three points worth pondering in the protected room during the next siren:

    1. Understanding Why It’s So Hard

    You see, there are two types of hardships in life. PREGNANCY, for example, can be an incredibly difficult period. Nausea, exhaustion, backaches and irregular contractions. But one thing sustains the woman: the knowledge that, in the end, comes the birth. No baby stays in the womb forever, and BH today, it’s successful.

    Bachelordom, on the other hand, carries a unique challenge because of the uncertainty. It also holds loneliness, disappointment, and heartache, but above it all hangs a heavy shadow: there is no deadline for its end. It could take months, it might last years, and—G-d forbid—it might never end…

    And wars? In this sense, regarding the time element they are more like bachelordom, but regarding the outcome, at least in Israel, it’s more like pregnancy. True, we know they aren’t forever—but no one can say exactly how long they will last.

    If there is anything that helps in such a situation, it is shifting our gaze from the “End” to the “Middle.” What does that mean? It means stopping the futile preoccupation with questions like “When will I finally stand under the Chuppah?” or “When will the war end?” and focusing instead on a different question: How am I living today? How can I make this day as strong, encouraging, and meaningful as possible?

    2. Remembering That Great Things Take Time

    We were taught back in kindergarten: “Patience, patience”, and we know, Israelis are “patience-challenged.” We like things fast and sharp—”lightning operations.” The Six-Day War style. Long, gradual processes? We don’t like them, but we have to get used to them! That’s maturity.

    History is full of long struggles, and the redemption of Israel appears “Kim’a Kim’a” (step by step, bit by bit, Yerushalmi Brachot 1, 1). Remember the Blitz of London in 1940/ת”ש- the Nazis bombed the capital every night for eight months! A million bombs were dropped, 43,000 civilians were killed, and over a million homes were destroyed. Thousands lived for months in subway stations just to find shelter.

    And yet, the British held on. How? Because they knew they were facing the Nazi monster. They knew that if they wanted to stop it from taking over the world, they needed stamina and patience. They knew they had no other choice but to endure, which is what the civilians must do in order for the country to win!

    3. Seeing the Big Picture

    Let’s not forget—the struggle happening here is bigger than Israel’s security. We live in a “crazy” world where basic concepts of good and evil are blurred. Precisely within this confusion, the Jewish people have a unique role. The whole world is looking at us right now, learning how to distinguish between light and darkness and how to eradicate barbarism—all while we harness the world’s greatest superpower to fight by our side.

    It is no coincidence that the war broke out on Shabbat Zachor, when we read about the struggle against the root of global evil—Amalek. The mission we began then, we are simply continuing today.

    At the same time, it’s important not to lose perspective. We are not in an existential war like in 1948/תש”ח, nor are we in the traumatic moment of October 7th/שמחת תורה of 2 years ago. The State of Israel today is BH strong, stable, and steadfast. The ones struggling for existence are Hamas, Hizballah and the brutal Iranian regime, not us! BH we also have shelters (most in their own homes!) and don’t have to live in the subways! BH we have the greatest Air Force in the world, aided and supplied by the 2nd greatest (America), nowhere else has absorbed such a volume of fire with so few casualties.

    So, until it’s over—we will continue to live, to believe, and to build. Similarly, this SHABBAT HACHODESH, we commemorate both the START of the Jewish Nation (Chodesh=month, comes from the word CHADASH=new, as symbolized by Pesach in Eretz Yisrael’s month of spring blooming= Chodesh haAviv) and today’s present RESTART of Israel. We will remember that we are living in an historic era, fulfilling a dream of generations, and writing the next chapter of the Bible, or more accurately: fulfilling the chapters of national redemption and her wars. Thank G-d, we are told (and have already seen!) what the end will be, precisely likened to the end of a pregnancy: a birth (not bachelordom!). Yishayahu (66, 9) prophesies precisely about the labor-pains of our period of the messianic era: “האשביר ולא אוליד יאמר ה’, אם אני המוליד?! “, “”Will I bring to the birth-stool and not cause to give birth?” says the Lord. “Am I not He who causes to give birth?!”. Shabbat Shalom! Rav Ari Shvat (Chwat) and Rav Yoni Lavie

  • MI LAHASHEM ELAY- THE TORAH MINDSET

    Yishayahu (25, 1) calls the mitzvot, “counsels from long ago”, and the Rambam writes that the mitzvot teach us ideas, actions and traits that serve us well throughout life (Guide for the Perplexed 3, 31). R. Soloveichik adds that even the halachic frameworks and details help us clarify proper mindsets.

    Our sages continue and elaborate such ideas even more in their midrashic and aggadic works full of great and provenly successful ideas. For example, my father z”l used to often quote in daily life, “מצוה הבאה לידך על תחמיצנה”, “A mitzvah which comes to you, don’t let it sit and ferment to become chametz (but do it immediately)” (Mechilta on Shmot 12, 17). Similarly, “אל תאמר לכשאפנה אשנה שמא לא תיפנה”, “don’t say ‘when I have time I will learn’, for you may never find the time” (Avot 2, 4). Also, “”המתחיל במצוה אומרים לו מרוק (=גמור) whoever begins a mitzvah, tell him finish it” (Yerushalmi Megilla 2, Tosfot Hullin 29a). The common denominator is that Chazal teach us not to procrastinate, and to finish that which we began. If something is worth starting, it’s usually worth finishing!

    The Israeli army is presently in the process of finishing off in Iran what we began in the previous 12-day-operation “Am KaLavie”, just 8 months ago to prevent their nuclear and ballistic programs directed against us. Why we didn’t complete the job then, I don’t know, but once we are there again, we surely must do so now efficiently.

    In life, you never know how circumstances may change, and we must “seize the moment”. Especially in Israel, maybe the Prime Minister will change, maybe the President of the U.S. will change. Perhaps the unity and nationalist mindset of Israel may wear down, perhaps we may run low on ammunition, perhaps anti-Semites will turn the UN against us, and much more. So often, people lament that after the Six Day War we didn’t take full advantage of the atmosphere with our enemies! G-d teaches us the Torah “mindset”, when he sent a prophet to rebuke Achav for not finishing off Ben-Haddad, King of Aram, whom He gave to Achav to defeat (M’lachim I, 20). In short, we must make sure that this time, we are careful to “finish them” properly!

    BH Israel has basically wiped out the Iranian anti-aircraft, assassinated their “Supreme Leader” and 40 of his top military and intelligence heads within the 1st minute of the war. They are clearly “on the run”, and as in boxing, we must now finish them off, as they planned to do to us. After the “Beeper Attack”, Hizballah was reeling, but unfortunately we let them regroup. Hashem has given us this G-d-sent situation that we can do there whatever we want, so all we have to do is ‘want’.

    We find another clear Torah educational “mindset” in this week’s parsha, when Moshe Rabbenu calls “מי לה’ אליי”. He keeps it simple and clear: “Whoever is for G-d, comes and helps. There are no two ways of understanding this: if you are for G-d, you come and aid when it’s time for war. And if you do not come, you are not for G-d (Shmot 32, 26).

    Matityahu copied (even if not precisely), where in the Book of Maccabees I (2, 27), “Whoever is zealous for the Torah and the covenant (with G-d), will follow me” and fight the Greeks. The ancient historian Yosifun (ch. 19, the end of the Geonic period, about 1,100 years ago, according to most editions), claims that Matityahu (or Yehuda HaMaccabee) actually copied Moshe’s words precisely. Either way, whoever celebrates Chanukah should also learn and emulate from the clear words of Matityahu and the Maccabees.

    Moreover, Moshe Rabbenu (rebuking Reuven and Gad, “Shall your brothers go to war while you stay here?!”, Bamidbar 32, 6), Deborah the prophetess (Shoftim 5, 16 and 23) and Rambam harshly rebuke those who don’t come to help Israel during war, ‘Cursed be he who does G-d’s work deceitfully, cursed be he who withholds his sword from blood’ (Rambam, Hil. M’lachim u’Milchamoteihem 7, 15, based upon Yirmiyahu 48, 10– it should be noted that he is even referring there to a Milchemet R’shut, an “optional war”). Regarding those who don’t help during war, Rav Soloveichik even applies the very severe castigation of the Rambam elsewhere to one who doesn’t participate with Israel in her time of trouble (Community, Covenant and Commitment [Hebrew], 2011, 68, 244, based upon Rambam Hil. Teshuva, 3, 11.).

    As regarding the issue of energetic action without delay, here too the advice and obligation of the Torah mindset, concept and wording are clear as can be: whoever is loyal to G-d, comes to fight His and His nation’s enemies, with that same zeal. Shabbat Shalom! Rav Ari Shvat (Chwat)

  • WHEN WILL THEY EVER LEARN?

    The 1,800 year old Midrashim on Esther, could actually have been written today! Our sages teach that King Achashverosh hated Israel more than Haman did (Yalkut Shimoni, 1054), but they had a difference of opinion: Achashverosh said to Haman that all the many who tried killing Israel never succeed, for the G-d of Israel is always on our side. Haman and Zeresh answered with 2 creative theories:

    1. Theologically: G-d USED to choose the Jews, until we sinned, upon which He abandoned us. He thought to prove from Nevuchadnetzar’s destroying the Temple in Jerusalam (ibid). [In reality, it was a threat that wasn’t meant to be carried out. Only after hundreds of prophetic threats, we left Him no choice but He had to TEMPORARILY send us to Bavel. In Persia, G-d PRETENDed to ALMOST DESTROY US- one of the reasons for costumes on Purim, see 1053, and Megilla 12a). Similarly, the Christians claim that G-d changed His mind and left us to chose them.

    2. Also, G-d saved Jews from furnaces, lion-dens, jails, deserts but nobody ever tried hanging us (ibid, 1057)! Similarly, Iran thought that nobody ever tried NUKING Israel!

    Here’s an unbelievable Midrash which is worthwhile to publicize to all of these and future anti-Semites: G-d said to Haman “You are the biggest FOOL! Even I TRIED and DIDN’T SUCCEED (as if it were!) to wipe out Israel after the Golden Calf sin! And YOU think that you will succeed in your “wish(ed) to obliterate, kill and do away with all the Jews”?!, ibid 1054). Our sages are teaching that the MOST IMPOSSIBLE thing in the world is to wipe out Israel! Also, “if there is no Israel, what use is Torah?!” (ibid, 1056)

    How much more so TODAY when G-d is in the process of redeeming Israel forever, ” ‘He [Bil’am] gave a parable [=prophesizing about the end of days] and said: OY! Who can survive when He does this? (Bamidbar 24, 23), OY to the nation who tries hindering when the Holy One, Blessed be He, redeems His children (Israel). Who (What FOOL) dares place his garment to separate between a lion and his female lioness when they wish to mate? [Woe to him, for he who does so will certainly not “survive”]” (Sanhedrin 106a). Put in the names of the fools: Hamas, Hizballah, Syria, Iran…

    Many don’t note the exact “dotting” in Shoshanat Ya’akov, NOT “תשועתם היְתה לנצח” )=their victory was forever- which it wasn’t!), but rather “תשועתם היִית לנצח”, =YOU have been their eternal salvation. Our salvation is the salvation of the G-d of Israel, as we saw just yesterday once again in Persia!

    After the Six Day War, the famed R. Menachem Kasher (intr. to his edition, Kol HaTor) suggested adopting the reading in Al HaNissim, adding the letter vav, that G-d miraculously saves Israel בימים ההם וּ- בזמן הזה= “in those days AND today, but from now on, on Purim we can have that in mind without needing to change any wording, for He saves us “בימים ההם בזמן הזה” “in those days at this time (Adar) AND in our time!”

    Surprisingly, the Rambam allows teaching Torah to Christians (despite his considering the trinity as idolatry) for they accept the Bible, but writes it’s a waste of time to try teaching Muslims (despite that they are monotheists like us), for they say that Israel “warped” the Bible! (Maimonides’ Letters, Blau edition, 148)

    Pres. Trump and many Christians know Megillat Esther, but the Islamic world doesn’t, that’s why the Persians keep uselessly trying and getting walloped. Many Christians have already learned not to FOOL with the G-d of Israel. That He obviously doesn’t make “mistakes”, will never abandon His Chosen People, and that they should even help us! But many Islamic religious leaders would be wise for their own sake, to objectively recheck and revise their clear and proven folly and immorality. Only then can there be world peace.

    If Moslems aren’t interested in learning Bible, at least we should teach them Pete Seeger’s classic song against violence, “Where have all the flowers gone?… When will they ever learn?!” It’s surely better for us and better for them and their people as well!

    In the meantime we must all celebrate and thank Hashem, the IDF (especially our Intelligence and Air Force: taking out their ruthless leader+ 40 (=most) of their military heads within 1 minute in 3 simultaneous strikes, probably a world record!), and Trump! He may be flawed (as was Achashverosh), but they understand something that Haman and Iran do not! Purim Same’ach! Rav Ari Shvat (Chwat)

  • “AGAINST OUR BETTER NATURE- Why We Must Arouse Hatred of Amalek”

    The ingenious and rational Rambam (hil. M’lachim 5, 5) adds several surprising words in defining the Torah mitzva to remember what Amalek did to us: “to constantly (!) remember their evil deeds and their ambush of Israel TO AROUSE OUR HATRED of them”. We usually relate to hatred as something we are meant to overcome, and surely not consciously or even artificially “arouse”! And why does the Rambam add that this obligation is “constant”?

    Another obvious question is: if there is no longer any biological Amalek in the world, why must we stubbornly “remember what Amalek did to us”? We Jews have a long memory, but when an historic issue seems no longer relevant, the Talmud asks: “מאי דהוה הוה!”, “What was, was”- so who cares? (e.g. Yoma 5b), so what’s the “nafka mina” (practical application)?! Any way you look at it, it’s been 2500 years since there was a practical mitzvah to fight Amalek!

    I think this mitzvah can be likened to the classic advice of many a father to their teenage daughter: “BH you have grown up to be a very sweet and beautiful young lady, and we love you that way, but don’t be naïve. Just know that there are some evil people out in the world. Don’t let them take advantage of you!”

    We Israeli citizens who comprise the IDF are normal peace-loving people who are not naturally “tough”, and would prefer spending our time on creative pursuits. This is exactly the problem which enabled the Hamas to surprise us on that fateful Simchat Torah. Many Israelis, especially those enveloping Gaza, lived in a naïve dream-world, thinking that if we just pull out of Gush Katif, if we just treat the Arabs nicely, there will be peace. We mistakenly PROJECTED our own mindset onto our enemy. Didn’t our parents teach us: “it take two to tangle”? So if we are adamant to be friendly with them, rationally that’s what we should get in return (see Mishlei 20, 17).

    Unfortunately, the past year two years with Hamas and Iran have proven to anyone objective that the lack of peace in the Middle-East is a direct outcome of their understanding of Islam. What does murdering the helpless, rape and mutilation have to do with their “freedom”?

    Accordingly, our self-defense, retaliation and deterring the enemies of peace is LIFE-GIVING and moral, and the exact opposite (!) of Islamic terror which brags about how many innocent citizens they killed, and even name their streets after those evil “heroes” of terrorism. The world has difficulty understanding why the Arabs in Gaza could be the aggressors, if they consistently suffer more casualties, because thank G-d, the world doesn’t understand the mindset (and illogic) of religious Jihad!

    I admit that I don’t know much about their religion, and I hope that there may be other, more peaceful interpretations to Islam, but as long as Hamas, ISIS and Iran interpret it the way they do, we cannot put our heads in the sand and deny reality. Yes, Am Yisrael yearns for peace, but in our eternal role as a Light to the Nations, our loving Father teaches us this Shabbat, that it’s irresponsible to be naïve and let evil people take advantage of us. The Rambam stresses this is a CONSTANT mitzvah that must sometimes even be consciously or artificially “aroused”, just in case we sometimes may want to forget the irrationality of anti-Semitism… Shabbat Shalom and Purim Sameach! Rav Ari Shvat (Chwat)

  • THE ‘EVIL’ IN TEHILIM?

    Q. I am learning sefer Tehillim and see many references to tzadikim and resha’im (perfectly good people and evil people). Of course, most people are somewhere in the middle. Still, David HaMelech speaks about evil people as those who ignore Hashem’s mitzvot, and who are more concerned about people not catching them at doing bad things than about what Hashem sees and knows.

    This got me thinking. For the vast majority of Jewish history, virtually all Jews learned and tried to follow the Torah. Those who rebelled against the Torah left the fold completely. But nowadays, particularly in Israel, the situation is different. Many people believe in G-d and follow some of the traditions (since the beginning of the current war, these numbers are BH rising). Most “secular” Jews are good people who do not wish any harm on our nation. Rather, they love our people and our land. So many non-religious Jews do so much chessed and risk their lives in the IDF, etc. These people know about Torah laws, but do not consider themselves “religious,” therefore choose which mitzvot to follow and which not to. I would like to think that these are not resha’im. I would like to hope that these Jews are considered “somewhere in the middle.” But according to what I have learned in sefer Tehillim, people who choose not to follow the Torah are seen as evil. I would appreciate your perspective on this issue.

    A. Regarding the definition of “resha’im” in both Tehilim and today, it all depends why those people chose not to follow the Torah. It’s true that there were almost no atheists in the time of King David, and most of the “evil” in Tehilim are referring to pagan gentiles, who really were evil both spiritually and morally. Over the last several generations already, it’s unanimous, spanning from Rav Kook (Igrot 555) to the Chazon Ish (Y.D. 2, 6-16) to Rav Ovadia Yosef (Chazon Ovadia, Kaddesh), that there are almost not such people in Am Yisrael (unfortunately, although many of the gentiles have matured, we see throughout the world and especially in the Middle East, that there still are evil gentiles).

    The 2 most common reasons there are no Jewish “resha’im” today are as follows: With so many anti-religious influences around us (e.g. social media, relatively anti-religious press…), most non-believers are considered Tinok Shenishba (like a child who was kidnapped and raised by gentiles) and is not responsible for his own lack of proper Jewish education and surroundings (Rambam Mamrim 3, 3, “whom we should try returning through ways of shalom”). Alternatively, the Ramban (Bamidbar 15, 22 · chumash) regarding the accidental sin offering of the nation (chatat shogeg tzibbur), gives the example of a society who thinks that the Torah’s time has passed, but not applicable for all [modern] generations (which could have been written today!).

    Rav Kook (“HaDor”) goes further that, as you inferred, the secular Jews today, surely those in Israel, are particularly idealistic, and their ideals are truly Torah ones, but they are often “turned off” by certain old-fashion and Galuti elements that they see among the religious. Their love of Israel, the Land, the Nation, and their desire to be part of Jewish destiny has been demonstrated every day of the past two years, since the Hamas attack, often more than among those considered “religious”. Similarly the statistically proven national reawakening which you mentioned, to be that much more traditional as expressed in prayer, tefillin, tzitzit, song (the official Song of the Year on Galei Tzahal was: “Hashem Yitbarach always loves me!”), Shabbat candles, and taking Challah, is just an expression of the latent Emuna (belief) that’s ALWAYS THERE but is just waiting to be awakened and “by-pass” the distractions and anti-religious element around!

    All Jews have the same G-dly soul, “This nation I CREATED for Me, they will tell of My praise” (Yeshaya 43, 21). We must “seize the moment”, and not let the politicians and media ruin the present national natural unity and Emuna. Shabbat Shalom! Rav Ari Shvat (Chwat)

  • REFINING ‘PATIENCE’ W/ KIDS WHO LEAVE ‘DERECH’

    Q. After dedicating 35 years and so much time and effort in raising and educating our children, how can I deal with the frustration of some of my kids who “left the Derech” of Torah, which is so dear to me? I feel such a failure!

    A. Regarding those who received good education in good families, it hurts to say it, but they are also, to a certain extent, victims of other outside factors, as well. It’s not just up to us! The super-strong world-wide allurements of smart-phones (whether it be non-stop sports, social media, movies, music, various levels of porn or anything and everything each individual likes), not to mention cannabis, travels to India and South America, and 2 years of war and unprecedented traumas, can and often do distract a person today 24/7 from life and its deeper meaning for years.

    The distractions (most of them can be really good mixed together with the problematic!) and temptations are much stronger than ever before, simply because we are in the process of ge’ula, and we must clarify and purify all topics which have yet to “finish” their “tikkun” (“fixing”). The galuti “black and white” simplistic way of protecting children from “outside” factors, doesn’t work any more, because BH the world is not where it used to be. The “stakes’ today are higher than ever before, but so is the Torah more alive, appealing and truer than ever before, in the various yeshivot, midrashot and mechinot, which can (together with the miracles and anti-Semitism of the last 2 years), and often do equalize the stiffest of competitions and distractions. Those who meet and overcome those challenges, rise to unprecedented levels, but that doesn’t mean that all of our children will pass the mark before age 35 (many need even more time).

    We must also get used to a broader definition, where in Eretz Yisrael, Torah is not just defined by observing Shabbat, but also through the very serving of Am Yisrael in this long war. Yes, while in battle many of the laws of Shabbat are superseded (and are not considered Chilul Shabbat at all), but one can understand that over 2 years one gets “out of the habit” of observing a beautiful and regular Shabbat. Despite the army getting more religious all the time, it’s still a challenge, and the best solution is to build their own home of Torah to where the soldiers return to their wife and kids, when on leave or when finishing their turn in milu’im.

    Accordingly, the “Derech” must include a wide 12 lane highway in order that even our own children not “leave the Derech”, and also getting used to not all of our children getting married in their young 20’s, where it’s easiest to build “regular” families of Torah. Those 2 examples of necessary tolerance (both open-mindedness and patience) are actually an essential part of the historical clarification of one of the 13 G-DLY TRAITS: Erech Appayim (literally: patience)!

    Hashem also does us a favor- that we also did for ourselves (through increasing care in our health)- that life-expectancy is getting longer, which also contributes to acquiring that G-dly mind-set of patience. In addition, BH in most of our families, we idealistically raised many children, so there are still ENOUGH children who relatively do follow the ways of their parents, to keep us sane and not blame ourselves too much!

    Keep on praying, thanking and seeing the good (“Ayin Tova”) in each and every child, not just in order to keep your sanity, but because these are really true and positive ways of seeing things and acquiring the G-dly ERECH APAYIM. Shabbat Shalom! Rav Ari